6 ms·
Thanks for the response, and thanks for reading. You make a terrific point: > This logic makes sense, with one exception: this assumes that the standard for r
by freedomben 6y ago
Thanks for the response, and thanks for reading. You make a terrific point:
> This logic makes sense, with one exception: this assumes that the standard for release quality remains unhindered pre/post swapping the position of RHEL / CentOS.
I don't really have an answer for that. It does seem like it would come down to "trust" and as a skeptical person I don't like that very much.
As I think about it more, while we have realigned some economic incentives for the better, it does seem (in addition to your points) there might also be an "incentive" to break CentOS from time to time, just to remind enterprises who are using it that "RHEL" is the gold standard and CentOS is "unsupported" D-: Knowing Red Hat and many of the volunteers that work on these projects, I would be shocked (and indeed would quit my job immediately) if such a thing were to happen, although it would be hard to prove.
That said such a thing would no doubt backfire. There would be outrage of course, and it would hurt the CentOS brand (which also hurts RHEL since these days the two are inextricably linked). We all fully expect another distro to "take the place" of old CentOS as a bug-for-bug rebuild (I'm excited about Rocky Linux personally) so not will there still be an option for that, but competition is great for quality of projects :-D
Anyway, much appreciate the comment :-)
I'll keep mulling it over as well.
- syshum 6y ago>>it would hurt the CentOS brand That ship has sailed. Even if what you say is true, the public reaction this is change has tarnished all the Brands, CentOS, RHEL, RedHat, and IBM... It will be a very long time to rebuild the trust, and honestly if RedHat stays the course and refuses to support CentOS 8 for the full life cycle I think CentOS will usage (and RHEL usage) will drop off a cliff I have already seen several software vendors with RHEL only official support announcing they are working on debian and ubuntu certification, and since it seems CentOS Stream at the most will only be supports for a 5 year life cycle down from 10, I am not sure why I would not move to debian at this point. debian is just as stable, the one thing CentOS had over it was the 10 year support, that is gone now