3 ms·
I’m honestly surprised they don’t just make RHEL free and take the CentOS market for themselves. Gate the current RHEL specific features behind support contract
by Spivak 6y ago
I’m honestly surprised they don’t just make RHEL free and take the CentOS market for themselves. Gate the current RHEL specific features behind support contracts and call it a day. Why make your customers have to migrate to pay you?
- josephcsible 6y agoThis is what Oracle Linux already does, so Red Hat is only hurting themselves by not doing so, since anyone who wants this can just go to Oracle. (Notwithstanding the fact that Oracle is evil.)
- pixl97 6y agoYea, going to Oracle is always a bad idea and they'll find a way to get money out of you. It's pretty common for me to convert customers from Oracle JRE/JDK to OpenJDK/JDE when Oracle says they need to pay millions for no good reason.
- Spivak 6y agoLook I just did an Oracle to OpenJDK transition for the same reason but I don't really think Java SE licensing is an example of Oracle being particularly Oracle. It's just that Oracle Java isn't free and they're doing what every company is doing switching from one-time license fees to subscriptions.
- josephcsible 6y agoBut here's the kicker: the worst thing Oracle can possibly do is to say "yeah, that whole Linux distro that we used to give you for free? We're not doing that anymore." So even if you do move to Oracle Linux and they go full evil, you're no worse off than you are on CentOS right now.
- yjftsjthsd-h 6y agoDisagree: RH isn't likely to sue you.
- bonzini 6y agoThere are no RHEL specific features.
- Spivak 6y agoAu contraire, there are and they're quite valuable their enterprise customers. The most important is the detailed security errata published along side their RPM packages which are necessary to do things like "only install security updates" or "check if any packages have upatched vulns." RHEL but not CentOS also come with security/regulatory profiles like STIG which are necessary to run in certain environments like the DoD. Red Hat also has a license to distribute Oracle Java that CentOS lacks and so it's not available in their repos. They also ship with the Cisco network drivers that CentOS again doesn't have a license to distribute.
- cesarb 6y agoThere's also the extended support for minor releases. With RHEL, it's possible to stay in a minor release for longer while in CentOS you always have to migrate to the next minor release. For instance, according to the graphic at the middle of https://access.redhat.com/support/policy/updates/errata https://access.redhat.com/support/policy/updates/errata with Extended Update Support one can stay at RHEL 8.2 until the middle of 2022 (so RHEL 8.2 has a full 2 years of support), while with CentOS, you had to migrate to CentOS 8.3 this month if you want to keep receiving updates (so CentOS 8.2 had only 6 months of support before being replaced with CentOS 8.3).
- freedomben 6y agoYeah I really wonder if this is coming. It's wishful thinking on my end so maybe isn't reasonable, but man it'd be neat. I get annoyed when people point out "you can already get a dev license for free." Sure, but there are hoops to jump through and you can't run it "in production" (which I think is mostly a meaningless claim, but still not something I like). Nevertheless I'm optimistic and hope they announce it sooner rather than later. Hopefully the current blowback will move things along ;-)