5 ms·
These standards aren’t just “plug C is 0.25 inches wide.” They are intimately tied to the compression technology itself. Developing new standards involves devel
by rayiner 6y ago
These standards aren’t just “plug C is 0.25 inches wide.” They are intimately tied to the compression technology itself. Developing new standards involves developing new compression technology, building and testing reference implementations, iterating, etc. All that costs money to develop. That will get paid for one way or the other. What way that happens affects the public interest analysis.
Look what happened with web standards. Developing and testing new web standards requires building reference implementations in browsers. Browsers are expensive to develop, so the standards are controlled by a handful of companies like Google and Apple. But the standards are free to implement. Is that better for the public? Maybe, but the public interest analysis is more complex than “free to implement.”
There is no such thing as “free.” R&D will be monetized somehow—the question is how. Different monetization approaches have different and non-obvious impacts on the public interest. Consider for example the shift away from paying for software to giving it away “free.” You used to pay Symbian $5-10 bucks per phone for an OS. Android you can get for free. But Symbian didn’t build an advertising platform into the core of each phone. Monetization matters.
- damnyou 6y agoI'd be more sympathetic if the money were mostly going to the engineers and researchers who did the work, not a bunch of corporate fat cats.
- rayiner 6y agoMy point has nothing to do with sympathy. I’m talking about the impact on the public of monetizing R&D one way versus another. Additionally, the companies pay the salaries of engineers and researchers who did the work. If your point is that engineers and researchers don’t get paid enough for the value they create, you’re talking about a completely distinct issue that has more to do with the structure of corporations generally.
- ineedasername 6y agoIt takes more than engineers to make a standard. The organizational infrastructure, investment in those engineers, associated risks if the investment doesn't bear fruit, engagement with the capital markets necessary to provide the financial infrastructure to keep the blood flow of money pumping... There's a heck of a lot more going to make any moderate R&D project happen. Why is the engineer more important than the many people required to make the organization function in a way that makes the engineer's work possible in the first place? Maybe people at the top get too much of the compensation, but what about the network technicians and IT departments that provided a functional work environment? What about building maintenance? What is harder, the research involved, or learning & navigating knowledge of the legal and financial mechanisms necessary for large complex organizations with a thousand interlinking pieces to other organizations? Who should get more compensation when the absence of any one component, not just the researchers, might have caused failure? I want to be clear though: I'm not defending astronomical compensation of the very few at the top. I'm saying that if there's inequity here, it doesn't begin or end with the engineers and researchers. Its victims are the sum total of all the people, all of the functions, without which the system fails.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoYou're making more of a criticism of advertising as a business model than of free software. AV1 is supported by Google, sure, but also companies like Netflix and Apple. If Google's business model for YouTube was to charge a subscription fee to everyone like Netflix, wouldn't they still have the same incentive to develop AV1? This is really commoditize your complement. Which works regardless of the revenue source in the primary market. https://www.gwern.net/Complement https://www.gwern.net/Complement
- rayiner 6y ago> You're making more of a criticism of advertising as a business model than of free software. I’m saying that if your business model is free software, it needs to be monetized some other way. Advertising is one way, which has become common. How that happens needs to be part of the public interest analysis.
- ddingus 6y agoWell, fully funding developers is one option. Rather than monetize the software, fund its creators. They, along with everyone else, get great use value out of the software and they are empowered to live, live, do, play, and generally be.
- chaosharmonic 6y agoValve is a great example of this. Aside from just shipping Proton as a single layer to manage the various compatibility libraries involved with playing Windows games on Linux, they've also hired multiple developers that were already working on projects like DXVK and Zink because of how their platform benefits from the underlying enhancements to Vulkan as an ecosystem.
- rayiner 6y agoWho pays? And where do those entities make the money?
- 6y ago
- phkahler 6y ago>> There is no such thing as “free.” R&D will be monetized somehow—the question is how. There is such a thing as free. People who write Free software are doing R&D without any plans for monetization. Codecs are software. Software has about zero manufacturing or distribution cost. Development does take effort. Very much effort for modern CODECs, but it's one thing to cover development costs and another to collect rent from - err monetize - a "standard".
- sz4kerto 6y agoI'm not sure that FLOSS developers have no plans to monetize. First, many of those devs offer paid support. Or their employability gets better. Etc. If people could not get any reward whatsoever out of FLOSS, it would be a much less active space.
- rayiner 6y agoEven with the Linux kernel, almost all development (over 90%) is done by people paid to work on Linux: https://thenewstack.io/contributes-linux-kernel/ https://thenewstack.io/contributes-linux-kernel/
- nitrogen 6y agoThis serves as evidence that 90% of all codec development could be done by people paid to work on the codec, and yet still available permissively and for free.
- rayiner 6y agoSure. You can also make web browsers for free. But how do those companies make their money, and what are the public interest implications of that?
- nullc 6y agoThis technology can be valuable, but getting a patent made standards essential doesn't just compensate you for your invention-- it creates a unearned windfall. Practitioners regularly us anticompetitive and dishonest moves to get their techniques made into mandatory parts of formats, regularly these techniques offer little value over non-patented alternatives-- in some cases they actually hurt coding performance over completely naive techniques. Xiph.Org's 2011's letter to the FTC directly discussions "industry standard" unethical conduct like effectively concealing what would later be claimed to be a patent encumbrance from a standard setting organization, exactly as Nokia did in this case. https://www.xiph.org/press/2011/ftc/ftc-comments-20110614.pdf https://www.xiph.org/press/2011/ftc/ftc-comments-20110614.pd...
- nine_k 6y agoHow come it's an unearned windfall and not return on investment of sorts? Developing the technology that has become the standard takes a lot of resources; you have spent them. Standard bodies usually compare several technologies and pick one; you have risked that your development effort would not make it into the standard, and would be a dead end. It looks a bit like bidding for a military contract. Did General Dynamics receive unearned windfall when USAF accepted their bid for a fighter jet, and kept paying for each F-16 they ordered? Surely the price of each included a part of the R&D costs.
- nullc 6y agoBuilding a valuable bridge that people voluntarily pay you to use is an investment. Planting a flag next to General Dynamics driveway so that you can collect a percentage off every aircraft that goes buy is rent seeking. If patent holders were required to specifically identify and price the technology they encumber standards with such that the standards setters can pick and choose which were worth it-- that would be a different matter, but it isn't how it works. Note that I pointed out that the specific patented technologies often have negligible or even negative benefits.