5 ms·
I really don’t see how this is news. Automated system that matches song samples and can’t possibly know if a steamer went and licensed the copyrighted music on
by Spivak 6y ago
I really don’t see how this is news. Automated system that matches song samples and can’t possibly know if a steamer went and licensed the copyrighted music on their stream trips on hearing copyrighted music. The banhammer falls automatically because there are so few cases (like this one) of legitimate usage requiring the content to be restored.
Like if anyone on HN was tasked to design a system to protect your companies asses against copyright lawsuits you would implement the same thing.
- zinekeller 6y ago> I really don’t see how this is news. Me too, for a different reason (he doesn't technically own the copyrights, Universal does). I do not support it, but if I were a signed artist, this wouldn't shocked me.
- crispyporkbites 6y agoThen it’s not a system that works and shouldn’t be in place. You can’t just say, that’ll do, it’s too hard or expensive to do this properly, so let’s not. Amazon is one of the wealthiest companies in the world and could easily manually moderate channels before auto-banning them. As consumers we don’t have to accept these excuses for substandard services.
- Spivak 6y agoI don’t get this. The entire point of these systems is to detect and stop copyright violations because they open up platforms to lawsuits. It’s not enough to just respond to DMCA takedowns after the lawsuit between Viacom and YouTube because (I think pretty reasonably personally) these platforms previously enabled copyright violations at a scale that literally could not be policed by copyright holders and so ContentID and the like was the compromise.
- kodt 6y agoMore evidence that automated systems like this should not be used.
- jagged-chisel 6y agoI don't think it's the automated detection that's a problem. It's the "you cannot object, you have no recourse, you cannot reply, you cannot show your license, and when we decide this has happened enough times, you cannot use our platform" that's the problem.
- kodt 6y agoYes, an automated system that flags content but is human reviewed would be more reasonable. But the human review part slows things down and you end up losing much of the advantage of the automated system as you would be throttled by human review or have to spend much more on manpower.
- Spivak 6y agoWhy? Their purpose is to stop platforms from getting sued for copyright violations. They are remarkably successful to that end. Their goal isn’t to allow all content that wouldn’t get them sued but to catch all content that would. False positives get you angry messages on Twitter but false negatives get you multimillion dollar lawsuits.