7 ms·
Some of these (I'm looking at you, BBC iPlayer) aren't even available in the USA.
by wyclif 16y ago
Some of these (I'm looking at you, BBC iPlayer) aren't even available in the USA.
- biot 16y agoYou should bring up that injustice with your Member of Parliament.
- corin_ 16y agoAnd likewise none of the streaming options for American shows are available in the UK. Now, with American shows, I think there could easily be a good business model - we've seen English TV channels pick up American shows (sometimes running almost in sync with America, more often than not running a year or two behind) with success. Examples include The West Wing, Friends, Glee, Will and Grace, Family Guy, CSI and so on. So I think there could be enough of an audience over here to be worth doing it. But iPlayer for non-UK viewers, it just isn't feasible. Firstly, BBC have the content licensed for UK viewing only, and they can't pay extra for international viewers because they are funded by the public (TV license over here). For the BBC website, international viewers see adverts, but that model can't be extended to iPlayer for a few reasons. Firstly, and least importantly, BBC never puts advertising into its shows, and they don't want to go against that, even for an international audience. That could be got around quite easily. Secondly, selling video adverts is a lot more complex (from a sales point of view, not technical) than shoving them into a website, it would take more work from them. And finally, if they were to sell adverts and open up iPlayer to an international audience, I doubt they would make enough revenue from the adverts to justify internationally licensing the content, i.e. there just wouldn't be enough people watching it.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- jodrellblank 16y agoWhy couldn't the BBC charge international viewers directly? $(License_fee/12) per month, say.
- corin_ 16y agoTechnically they could, but it would mean creating and managing a new license fee system. Right now there's no enforcement of the license fee, just the knowledge that, to watch live broadcasts (either on TV or online) you must have a license, and if a TV license inspector catches you, you'll be in trouble.
- lookingsideways 16y agoWith the iPlayer service, if you watch any of the live-streaming channels and you don't have a TV License you will eventually get a letter informing you that you need to pay the license fee. Fail to obtain the TV License after that point and you are subject to the normal fines. I think the BBC must have some form of tie-in with the ISPs as I know a number of people that have had this happen to them.
- corin_ 16y agoI'm regularly tunnelling all my traffic through a UK VPS (not for geolocation regions, I'm in the UK myself anyway), and never had any issues watching iPlayer. And if I watched to avoid it, I could always use something like www.tvcatchup.com to watch the live content, and just go onto the iPlayer for VOD content (for which you don't need a license). I wonder - traditionally a TV license is per household, not per person, meaning that if I want to watch on a TV in a friend's house, they need to have a license, not me. With internet access, how does that work. For example, say they were able to prove I had been watching iPlayer live streams in my house, what if it was a friend watching on their laptop, and they own a license? What if you're watching from a public WiFi or a 3G connection on a train? The "license for the house" doesn't quite translate.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- Tyrannosaurs 16y agoThey'd still need to differentiate between shows that they could show to a US viewer and ones which they couldn't (because they didn't have the rights to international distribution - for instance most sport, any drama they've bought in and so on).
- darren_ 16y ago> But iPlayer for non-UK viewers, it just isn't feasible. It seems like they're working on it (iPad only, by the looks of it): http://www.guardian.co.uk/media/2011/mar/02/bbc-global-iplayer-app http://www.guardian.co.uk/media/2011/mar/02/bbc-global-iplay... You're right, though, ad-supported iPlayer isn't feasible.
- Tomek_ 16y agoWell, but isn't that what the whole problem is about? Doesn't matter if it's BBC, iTunes or Spotify - it's that the country-based licensing model doesn't work in the age of Internet.
- corin_ 16y agoBut with the sale of content that should be an easy fix, whereas BBC is a pretty unique situation.
- rwmj 16y agoiPlayer for non-UK viewers is actually pretty easy to get. Rent a virtual private server on any of the many UK VPS services. Then use get_iplayer[1] to download TV and radio programmes when you want to. Although I live in the UK (and pay a TV license), I use this method because it's much more convenient. It doesn't require flash, lets me keep the programme for as long as I want, and downloads are really fast. For example I can grab a 2 hour film from iPlayer into a .flv file in about 15-20 minutes. [1] http://www.infradead.org/get_iplayer/html/get_iplayer.html http://www.infradead.org/get_iplayer/html/get_iplayer.html
- Tyrannosaurs 16y agoiPlayer isn't a commercial service, it's funded by the UK tax payer though the license fee. I agree that this is something the BBC should look at making available more widely as a revenue generator to fund it's operations but it's not a priority for them.
- danohuiginn 16y agoless 'not a priority', more 'politically impossible'. They're constantly under pressure from the Murdoch empire, and other commercial TV, trying to prevent the BBC doing anything popular/profitable. International iplayer would send the lobbyists into an epic tantrum.
- AlexC04 16y agoWhat's the TV license at now? 180 pounds or ~275 US? If it came with access to iPlayer, 4oD & iTVoD I'd probably be willing to pay for a UK TV license. (I'm in Canada)
- archivator 16y agoThat's an interesting model - pay the full price for a TV license and only use the web services. There would be technical difficulties, of course (guaranteeing a decent connection to the BBC servers, possibly adding international data centres) but it certainly provokes thought. On the other hand, how exactly will the government justify collecting tax from non-citizens (even worse, non-residents!)?
- Tyrannosaurs 16y ago> On the other hand, how exactly will the government justify > collecting tax from non-citizens (even worse, non- > residents!)? How do the US justify taxes when I (in the UK) buy something from Threadless which is based in the US? Or my subscription to Backblaze? Or the sales tax when I visit the US (where I'm neither a citizen nor resident)? It's pretty much a non-issue. Technically though it probably wouldn't be a tax. A tax is collected by the state and this would almost certainly go through a limited company which while ultimately owned by the state is legally different.