4 ms·
It has nothing to do with network admins. Everything the majority of customers care about in the US is available on IPv4 and sometimes ipv6. If v6 goes down for
by kortilla 6y ago
It has nothing to do with network admins. Everything the majority of customers care about in the US is available on IPv4 and sometimes ipv6. If v6 goes down for your customers, they probably won’t even notice. If you don’t have v4, you don’t have a business.
It hasn’t even been that long that Amazon EC2 has had v6 support, which is where a huge chunk of the Internet is hosted.
The network admins at ISPs are just providing connectivity the customers demand. It’s hosting providers and sys admins that don’t bother setting up anything interesting on v6 in the first place.
- jiggawatts 6y agoFirst: Here in Australia no major ISPs provide a native IPv6 service, and if they do, they don't provide it to business. It's obscenely difficult to obtain IPv6 in Australia. None of the major telcos do it, you have to go down the list to like the 5th or 6th biggest ones before it becomes an "experimental option" for residential connections only. Second: Ever since IPv6 has been a thing, I've offered to customers the option to turn it on for free. No added charge. We'll just flip the switches and it's there. Not one customer, ever, has said "yes". They've all actively refused to turn it on, for any purpose. Third: The few times IPv6 has been forced upon our customers, mostly due to Microsoft Windows DirectAccess, it was the network administrators frothing at the mouth, ranting and raving about how they don't want to do it, that DirectAccess should use IPv4 (I'll call Redmond and I'm sure they'll get right on it!), etc... Fourth: As you've mentioned, AWS, Azure, and GCP had practically zero IPv6 support until very recently. Now, they have broken IPv6 support which is worse than useless, because it gives the impression that the problem is with IPv6, not with the people holding on to an appreciating asset of IPv4 addresses that they intend to use to lock out the competition. TL;DR: IPv6 is held back by a combination of bad ISPs, lazy network admins, and monopoly seeking public cloud providers.
- BlueTemplar 6y agoAt some point the government just has to step in and forbid the sale of IPv4 compatible hardware...
- rescbr 6y ago> Ever since IPv6 has been a thing, I've offered to customers [...] They've all actively refused to turn it on, for any purpose. As such a customer, I’m worried that my ISP would eventually bait-and-switch me from routable IPv4 + optional IPv6 to CGNAT IPv4 + IPv6 when convenient to them. Sorry, but I’m not risking going behind a 1:n NAT layer that I don’t manage.
- detaro 6y agoOf course nothing stops an ISP putting you behind CGNAT IPv4 without IPv6.
- rescbr 6y agoSure, but the threat of me cancelling and switching to another ISP as the service is now unsuitable for my needs is enough to keep them from doing that. Does this strategy work? Maybe, when I upgraded my plan they wanted to switch modems, the new one didn’t have working bridge support, and I said to them it was a requirement for me. No bridging, revert everything. The field tech escalated to engineering and they approved a business-class modem. I expect the same with IPv4, even if I have to pay extra.
- jiggawatts 6y agoKeep in mind that many Australian Telcos are already using CGNAT, although they do allow customers to opt out. I've had to opt out, because CloudFlare was showing me Captchas all the time. For example Aussie Broadband had a nice writup of their CGNAT setup: https://www.aussiebroadband.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/Ausnog-2019.pdf https://www.aussiebroadband.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2019/0...