41 ms·
Anyone who thinks a game with microtransactions isn't designed to push you towards buying them is a fool. And I don't mean only what EA is doing. They affect an
by nottorp 6y ago
Anyone who thinks a game with microtransactions isn't designed to push you towards buying them is a fool. And I don't mean only what EA is doing. They affect any game's design when they are present.
Just. Avoid. Them.
- Throwaway1771 6y agoRIP ad-hoc GTA multiplayer.
- hutzlibu 6y agoThere are free to play Multiplayer games, where microtransactions are for skins and other cosmetic stuff. Thats fine by me. In other games, you can make progress faster if you pay. That is more annoying, but still no pay to win, or dishonest. But all those lootbox games and arcade ones, designed to lure you into more buying, well, everybod gets what they deserve.
- Wowfunhappy 6y ago> In other games, you can make progress faster if you pay. That is more annoying, but still no pay to win, or dishonest. But who is to say you aren’t being manipulated to buy those microtransactions? Their presence gives designers the wrong incentives.
- d3nj4l 6y agoI personally think direct micro payments for skins, even without randomness and lootboxes, are still problematic. They aren't as bad as lootboxes, which are clearly designed to extract money, but their problem is that the potentially limitless money you can spend. If you go into a game knowing that it costs $60, you know that's how much you're spending on it. If you go into a game that hands out skins for $2.50 a piece, there's no limit, and unless you're good at making and sticking to a budget (which is a large portion of the world, especially kids who have no experience!) you can just as likely spend way more than $60. This is worse when such things as skins end up getting tied to status within the game world. Fortnite doesn't have randomized loot boxes anymore, but that hasn't stopped kids from spending tons on V-bucks, especially since they get bullied if they don't [1]. Seriously, just look at videos of people bullying "defaults" on Fortnite. I think it's especially bad because there is a way to finance long-running multiplayer games: battle passes. It's an upfront cost so you always know what you're getting into. 1: https://www.polygon.com/2019/5/7/18534431/fortnite-rare-default-skins-bullying-harassment https://www.polygon.com/2019/5/7/18534431/fortnite-rare-defa...
- Throwaway1771 6y agoThe budget to win is the cost of the game. If you're an aesthetics whore, welp.
- d3nj4l 6y agoYou're completely ignoring the second half of my comment.
- hutzlibu 6y ago"Seriously, just look at videos of people bullying "defaults" on Fortnite" Well, but thats the beauty of a shooter game. If theres some moron fixed on style trying to bully, you can just shoot him and enjoy his whining. Knowing that cosmetics are no match for skills. And about spending in general: I believe that is a valuable skill to be learned as early as possible, don't you think? So if a kid spends all his pocket money for the month on day 1. There is opportunity to learn. (and if he spends all his parents money, then there is opportinity for the parents to learn)
- RealStickman_ 6y agoWhen there is an option to pay for faster progress the developer is incentivized to make the overall progression slower and grindier in the hopes that more people buy those boosts. See EA Battlefront 2's original hero progression system or to a lesser degree AC Odyssey.
- hutzlibu 6y agoYes it is. But it still means, that people with more time than money get to play the game. And those with more money than time, can take a fast dive here and there. I've seen that work (more or less) in some games.
- username90 6y agoBut this happens for games you pay full price for, so you get the worst of both worlds.
- hutzlibu 6y agoTrue. Thats why I don't buy or play those games. Neither do I play pay to win games.
- nottorp 6y agoCheck if a game has IAPs before paying the full price, and skip it if it does. I think one of the Dead Space games was the first EA title to both be full price and have IAPs for materials you could also slooowly grind? Also Devil May Cry 5.
- nottorp 6y ago>There are free to play Multiplayer games, where microtransactions are for skins and other cosmetic stuff. Thats fine by me. Actually no, it's not fine. Because if the cosmetic stuff would have been obtainable just through game play, it would have been easier to obtain. If it's available for real money, they have an incentive to make it more grindy to obtain otherwise. Consciously or not. And if you think the availability of those cosmetic items doesn't affect you - consciously or not - you're deluding yourself. No matter how they're implemented, microtransactions are a burden on either your wallet or your time.
- Shivetya 6y agoHell, there are companies who use this time of year for a big push for loot boxes and each year they tweak how it works to further their income. An example, Wargaming which runs World of XXX games of which World of Tanks and World of Warships are the biggest tells players of their Warships game that containers can contain one of any one hundred and six premium ships but players noticed patterns and soon determined there was a short list of ships you had to roll first before the rest were available[0]. While they offered a refund after being called out they did not advertise such a refund in game or even on their own site. Duplicate premium ships used to reward the premium currency but that was replaced with another roll last year. Their World of Tanks sister game operates under more generous rules but that may be more from their primary market is in a different region. Neither publishes odds but a version of the game on consoles does publish its odds because that platform requires it however there is no play against PC [0]https://www.reddit.com/r/WorldOfWarships/comments/k6ivy5/how_wg_chooses_your_santa_gift_ship_and_why_you/ https://www.reddit.com/r/WorldOfWarships/comments/k6ivy5/how...
- iamacyborg 6y agoI very much like Path of Exile because it goes against this grain. The vast majority of MTX items in that game are cosmetic, adding new skins to armour, new skill VFX, etc. Some of the MTX is different in that you can purchase more stash tabs (though you get quite a few for free already) but it very much feels like ethical MTX, in as much as this kind of thing can be ethical. https://www.pathofexile.com/shop https://www.pathofexile.com/shop
- nottorp 6y agoYeah, and those items aren't obtainable (or very hard to obtain) via game play :) It affected the game's design.
- iamacyborg 6y agoSure, they're impossible to obtain via normal gameplay, but they have no tangible bearing on gameplay either.
- nottorp 6y agoThat's debatable. Check out Guild Wars 1 skin collectors. There is no such thing in Guild Wars 2 because there are very few skins obtainable from gameplay, and the rest are in the IAP store. If you're the hypercompetitive type yeah, I guess you don't care. Except you could be competing for the largest skin collection... In any case, a lot of people do care.
- pndy 6y agoThere's tons of skins obtainable in GW2 from gameplay; some pop from regular loot you get - the very basic ones, for some you need a little bit of engagement like dungeon, fractal, raid sets, (there are also pvp sets) or sets added within Living Story updates. There are rare skins you can get from mystic forge, or if you're lucky juggling unidentified gear loot. The really exclusive ones would be legendary weapons and gemstore special offers - the latter you can still obtain via gold to gems exchange. Then there are unique cosmetic items like Queen Bee, Liquid Aurillium, Chak and Confetti indusions and Invisible Boots skin. Path of Exile and GW2 seems to be sharing microtransactions model - both include account/character upgrades, convenience items and additional more appealing skins. Not sure about PoE but GW2 still allows you to exchange in-game currency for shop currency / gems to gold at I'd say fair rate.
- throw_m239339 6y agoMicrotransactions is a generic term. Microtransactions can be purely cosmetic like skins, so it doesn't matter when it comes to gameplay, or extensions which had levels/story/whatever to an existing game. So microtransactions aren't bad, especially in a free 2 play game. What EA and co are doing on the other hand is different, it's called 'pay 2 win', the more you pay, the easier it gets to win whatever you have to win in that game (or progress faster). The latter is a questionable practice. Pay 2 win games should absolutely be regulated and be 18+ only.
- smichel17 6y agoFunny aside about abbreviations, I've seldom seen it written with a 2 that way. Usually either "free to play // pay to win" or "f2p // p2w".
- Technically 6y agoPutting microtransactions in a free to play game seems like an inherent contradiction. If there's a transaction, it's not free, it's just what people used to call demos or shareware—you get a small slice for free, the rest you pay for. Note that there are a ton of games out there that are actually free to play and won't ever gate content behind paywalls.
- falcolas 6y agoApologies, but you just hit on a pet peeve. If cosmetics didn’t matter, why are they such lucrative items to sell? Cosmetics were once the reward for playing the game, not for spending money. And the look of your in-game avatar matters - has always mattered - to a vast majority of players. The reward for playing the game now? Getting the opportunity to spend more money.
- hnick 6y agoExactly, gamers have gone from thinking horse armor is stupid to now accepting "only cosmetic" and it's a problem. Are you going to put better looking items in the game for free if you could charge $20 in the store? Are you going to spend time writing an engaging and rewarding quest line when you can just throw a price tag on it? Games do need content so they won't do this for everything, but the mere existence of a cash shop and MTX is a perverse incentive on development quality. It also often ruins the cosmetic experience of the rest of us, with knights running around wearing angel wings for some weird reason. That aside, Jim Sterling brought up something I hadn't even considered since I'm too old. Kids getting bullied because their Fortnite characters only have the default skins and they can't afford (or aren't allowed) to buy anything else. "Only cosmetic" indeed!