6 ms·
So it's finally okay to say there's multiple strains with different infectiousness and (possibly) severity? Back in February-ish (I forget exactly when), we ha
by Izkata 6y ago
So it's finally okay to say there's multiple strains with different infectiousness and (possibly) severity?
Back in February-ish (I forget exactly when), we had confirmed community spread in Washington (West-coast state in the US), with the belief that it had been spreading for weeks and no one noticed, because of how few cases there were, and no bump in hospitalizations. This was likely the Wuhan strain, which likewise had been spreading in Wuhan for at least a month and a half before it was detected.
On the flipside, when it reached Italy, it hit that country hard. It wasn't clear why, but I remember a report sometime during the summer that the most prevalent version of the virus in Italy was distinct from the Wuhan one, and could possibly be labeled a different strain because of its increased infectiousness, that mutation apparently occurring somewhere in Europe and spreading out from there (France was also hit hard at the same time IIRC, but Germany for example was not).
Not long after that I remember a cross-country comparison that said the primary version of the virus in New York (US East coast, also hit hard) matched the one in Italy, but not the Wuhan one, and that what we had in Chicago was a mix of the different strains with (at the time) no one winning out over the others.
Nice to finally see confirmation about there actually being different strains that are shifting over time, but unfortunately the timing makes it look like lockdowns may have selected for the more virulent version and caused the pandemic to be worse than it otherwise would have been (see the graphs in the "G strains take over" section, where the cases spike only after, well, the "G" strains take over and the Wuhan "L" strain has been pushed out).
- jstanley 6y agoCan you elaborate on why a lockdown would select for a more virulent strain?
- Izkata 6y agoI'm mainly basing it on the graphs provided: The cases don't spike until after the "G" strain is present, no matter how long the "L" and "S" strains were present beforehand. Actually I think I should have said "infective" rather than "virulent" there; basically lockdowns select for versions of the virus that can spread despite the lockdowns. It only looks more virulent because of the larger number of total infections.
- chimprich 6y agoIt's worth bearing in mind that the graphs in the article are quite distorted. Testing was not widely available until months into the pandemic, making the early spikes look much smaller than they were. Later strains may indeed turn out to be more infectious, but I don't think we have the evidence for that yet.
- divbzero 6y agoBased on the graphs alone it’s also possible that more infective strains lead to spikes which lead to lockdowns.
- LeCow 6y agoTo which it will become more contagious more quickly...
- usrusr 6y agoAs long as the epidemic doesn't run close to saturation (and given the multiple effective vaccines it likely won't, ever), NPI-induced relative spread advantages of one strain over another don't make a difference unless they are also absolute advantages compared to non-NPI-scenario. And given the strength of pre- and asymptomatic spread of this particular virus, it's almost immune to selective pressure for weaker symptoms anyways (scarcity of PCR and deep connect tracing can cause some pressure).
- gcanyon 6y agoNot an evolutionary biologist, but I think it's better to think of it as potentially killing off an earlier, less virulent strain. Putting it in concrete terms, if you have two versions of the virus, X which for each infected person tends to infect 1.8 others, and Y which tends to infect 2.8 others, then after ten days there might be more people infected with Y than X, but X would still be around. Now if everyone takes precautions, maybe those rates are cut in half. Now X only infects 0.9 people per infected person, and thus dies out, while Y is still infecting 1.4 people per infected person, and thus is still spreading, just slower.
- craftinator 6y ago> Putting it in concrete terms, if you have two versions of the virus, X which for each infected person tends to infect 1.8 others, and Y which tends to infect 2.8 others, then after ten days there might be more people infected with Y than X, but X would still be around. This is actually an observed effect in many transmittable illnesses; over time, they become more transmittable, and less deadly. Extremely deadly forms kill their hosts, ending the ability to reproduce via transmission, and the more transmittable strains reproduce effectively. This type of optimization leads to things like the common cold and flu. The scary thing about COVID19 is that it has a very long lead time between infection and symptoms, if they develop at all, meaning it can circumvent some of those "normal" optimization peaks; it can be both very deadly, and very transmittable, because of the latency in the signal.
- hedora 6y agoImagine the original strain had a mortality rate of zero, but later strains had high mortality rates. The original strain would effectively be a vaccine. The lockdown would be the equivalent of the anti-vaxxers. There’s no evidence the mortality rate has actually increased; this was just a thought experiment. In prior pandemics (1918 flu), future strains were more deadly than earlier strains. The nightmare scenario now is that a COVID-20 emerges with a 5% mortality rate instead of 0.5%. If catching COVID-19 gives you immunity to COVID-20 (and all the vaccines fail), then the lockdown would increase the death toll by 10x. These are all hypotheticals that looked somewhat plausible in April, and implausible today.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- rolph 6y ago[N.B. mods, deleted accidental dupe comment] a lockdown would select for a more communicable strain, not a more virulent strain. the big problem is this virus has morbidity latent to infection incubation and transmission. these conditions mean that the virus can be 100% lethal and not succuum to the usual dynamics
- acqq 6y agoNo, according to the majority of experts, there's still no sound basis for claiming that the strains have different infectiousness and there's even less evidence for different severity. The only thing known is that we can decode the genome across the world and that the virus, as it spreads, slowly gets some small changes which could be followed. There's no sign that anything people did (especially "lockdowns") up to now had any evolutionary effect on the virus. Coronaviruses mutate much slower than a lot of viruses. The majority of experts believe that what we observe (these still minimal changes) could be attributed to the "founder effect."
- brian_cloutier 6y agoNature has a decent article on this: https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-020-02544-6 https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-020-02544-6 Apparently we have little idea whether D614G is more infectious but that is hard to believe given that it has so thoroughly outcompeted other strains.
- twic 6y agoHard to believe, but true - because it didn't outcompete other alleles, it was just in the right place at the right time, as has been carefully documented: https://twitter.com/ballouxfrancois/status/1331669118001537024 https://twitter.com/ballouxfrancois/status/13316691180015370... Still, assuming that massive success is due to competitive advantage rather than random chance is extremely on-brand for HN.
- Throwaway1771 6y agoTotally uncalled for, and hilarious, knifejab by a man in black pajamas.
- brian_cloutier 6y agoThe founder effect doesn't seem capable of explaining the spread of D614G given that it has replaced other varients in every place it has been introduced to, and that it has even doubled back and outcompeted other variants even when those variants were introduced far before D614G. I'll read this paper, though, to get a better idea of what they're claiming; thanks for the link. You have assumed I'm ignorant when you could have attempted to understand why I believe the things I do which seems at least as big a mistake as the one you accused me of making.
- rolph 6y agothe D614G strain has a loose binding domain in its spike. this modifies what was a specific key into a lockpick. this allows the virus to bind to a number of allelic versions of ACE2 rather than one or few specifics. thus promiscuous binding.
- blackrock 6y agoInteresting premise. But why doesn’t anyone look at the bigger elephant in the room? Sometime in April 2019, reports of a mysterious illness started surfacing. They thought it was related to vaping products. [1] Then in July 2019, a respiratory illness hit a retirement home in Virginia, and killed a bunch of old people. [2] Then the Wuhan military games was in mid October 2019. Then China reported of an unknown pneumonia in early December. They thought it came from a seafood market, which was proven incorrect. The western world harassed them and accused them of eating bats, and transmitting the disease, which is also proven to be incorrect. China then back-traced the earliest case to mid November. Which happens to coincide a few weeks after the Wuhan military games. Just the right amount of time for the virus to incubate and wreck havoc. New evidence is suggesting that the virus was in Italy before it was in China. [3] But the interesting thing, is that when they took MRI scans of the vaping outbreak patients, they saw white orbs in the picture in their lungs. Coincidentally, Covid-19 victims also had these white orbs in their lungs. The whole origin of this virus was always very mysterious. Something just never seemed right about it. The vaping thing just came and disappeared. Nobody really knows what caused it, just a few random theories about contaminated cartridges. But here’s the strange thing. Those vaping pens, are all made in China. And are sold all over the world. People in China uses those vaping pens everywhere, but there were no reports of a mysterious illness from it in China. Only in the United States and a few in Canada. Not even Europe reported any issues. Why was it reported only in the United States? Then soon after, all the other pieces began to fall into place, one after the other. To get down to the true origin of this virus, then they need to check those vaping people. Check them for the Covid-19 antibodies. Then check the nursing home people from Virginia, for those that survived, for Covid-19 antibodies. Then check the people that went to the Wuhan military games for Covid-19 antibodies. Or not. And just conveniently blame China for being the origin of the virus, just because they were the first ones to detect it, and report it. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2019%E2%80%932020_vaping_lung_illness_outbreak https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2019%E2%80%932020_vaping_lung_... [2] https://www.cnn.com/2019/07/11/us/virginia-retirement-community-respiratory-illness-outbreak/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2019/07/11/us/virginia-retirement-commun... [3] https://www.reuters.com/article/health-coronavirus-italy-timing/italian-study-suggesting-covid-predates-china-outbreak-sparks-scepticism-idUKL8N2I351V https://www.reuters.com/article/health-coronavirus-italy-tim...
- animal531 6y agoAround March I already saw some reports detailing the different strains of the time.
- jaclaz 6y ago>On the flipside, when it reached Italy, Only for the record/FYI, there is growing evidence that the virus (cannot say which strain) was present in Italy months before, possibly since September 2019. https://www.reuters.com/article/health-coronavirus-italy-timing-idUSKBN27W1J2 https://www.reuters.com/article/health-coronavirus-italy-tim... https://wwwnc.cdc.gov/eid/article/27/2/20-4632_article https://wwwnc.cdc.gov/eid/article/27/2/20-4632_article
- khuey 6y ago"Some people had antibodies that react with SARS-CoV2 prior to January 2020" isn't great evidence that the virus itself was present prior to 2020. There's some amount of cross-reactivity between antibodies to other human coronaviruses and SARS-CoV2.
- jaclaz 6y agoBesides that finding, there is the other more recent article, about the actual RNA found.
- kordlessagain 6y ago> when it reached Italy, it hit that country hard In general, Italians have issues with high blood pressure. High blood pressure seems to be a factor in the severity of the illness.