4 ms·
> The idea that banning certain information will somehow result in it disappearing has been shown repeatedly to not work. A cursory reading of history should ma
by rayiner 6y ago
> The idea that banning certain information will somehow result in it disappearing has been shown repeatedly to not work. A cursory reading of history should make this clear. You cannot turn the entire world into West Coast USA by banning everyone that disagrees with you. You’ll only create further echo chambers, both on your own platform and on the (new) platforms inevitably created by the exiled.
And in the process you’ll create a system that will eventually alienate enough people in the middle to undermine you. Banning discussion of this—instead of letting the courts do their work—will alienate the half of the country that voted for Trump. It’ll alienate traditional liberals for whom free speech (not in the narrow legal sense but the larger social sense) is a core value. And eventually the system you’ve created will do something to overreach. The desire to censor the other side won’t end here. And at that point, the majority of people will find themselves on the other side and you’ll have a problem.
Traditional liberal values were a good thing and we should hesitate to abandon them. Liberals defended nazis marching through American cities in the name of free speech. If we can handle that we can have handle baseless claims of election fraud that are being swiftly dealt with by the courts.
- hackyhacky 6y agoThe half of the country that voted for Trump is already alienated. They're fully prepared to destroy every American institution, simply because Trump them that they should. As we've already seen countless times, there is no amount of rational discussion or documented evidence that will persuade them otherwise. The question is, do the rest of us have to go along with it, or are allowed to fight back?
- tomcam 6y ago> They're fully prepared to destroy every American institution, simply because Trump them that they should. Reading minds is not your strong point.
- yew 6y agoSpeaking as an American who didn't vote for Trump, either time, you've certainly alienated me. You'd (collectively) best hope you're making more friends than enemies. Hope's all any of us have at this point.
- rayiner 6y agoThis. Trump will be gone. The trashing of our liberal values in the name of “moral clarity in the age of Trump” will remain.
- southeastern 6y agoEh when your consider things like this; https://www.fox7austin.com/news/texas-gop-chair-suggests-law-abiding-states-should-form-a-union-after-supreme-court-rejects-texas-suit https://www.fox7austin.com/news/texas-gop-chair-suggests-law... >Texas GOP chair says 'law-abiding states' should 'form a union' after SCOTUS rejects election suit I feel there may be a real point to that. Is he being a bit emotional with his post? Sure. Should that be enough to write off a possible threat to democracy? No. I mean if that alienates you, I expect what the TX GOP chair did will REALLY make you passionate
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dasil003 6y agoTrump support is more about disillusionment and distrust of career politicians and frustration at the steady decline of blue-collar prosperity than it is about actually believing his mouth words.
- watwut 6y agoTrump did not performed that well among blue collar demographics.
- inglor_cz 6y agoIs being alienated the same as being dead, e.g. a final, irreversible state? I would say no. There is always a lot of fence sitters. Say "fuck you" to their faces and you lose any chance of winning them back.