4 ms·
> especially older adults Someone at the CDC disagreed with the strategy of vaccinating people in long-term care facilities first because their weaker immune s
by dehrmann 6y ago
> especially older adults
Someone at the CDC disagreed with the strategy of vaccinating people in long-term care facilities first because their weaker immune systems might not have an effective response to the vaccine. I'm not even sure if vaccinating front-line heathcare workers first makes sense because they've probably been exposed already (or not; this is easily checked with antibody tests).
You want to vaccinate people most likely to spread it. Who that is, I'm not sure.
- riccia 6y agoI think along the lines you're thinking, you would actually want to come up with an expected cost of an infection of an individual ("cost" being in a misery-illness-utility sense, not financial). This would presumably include the average expected illness severity of the person infected but also the average illness burden in others indirectly attributable to that person being infected. So you'd want to give it first to people who are very likely to become severely ill themselves, and whose infection would cause others to become severely ill, directly or indirectly (eg through disease spread or through lost resources, as if an ER doc in an understaffed area became severely ill).
- makomk 6y agoThe trouble with vaccinating people most likely to spread it, at least as I've seen it explained, is that you have to vaccinate a lot of people in order to have an impact compared to vaccinating the most at risk groups and there's only a limited supply of vaccine and limited capacity to administer it right now. (Also, technically there's probably more evidence of it working to protect at-risk people from severe disease and death than for it stopping anyone spreading it, but that's mostly just an artifact of what's been tested so far.)
- aegis4244 6y agoWe don't test health care workers in America. https://www.npr.org/2020/12/07/943945361/think-health-care-workers-are-tested-often-for-covid-19-think-again https://www.npr.org/2020/12/07/943945361/think-health-care-w...
- lupire 6y agoUntrue and off topic. > 42% of RNs in hospitals said they had ever been tested for the virus. and anyways that's different from a one-time pre-vacccination test.
- plorkyeran 6y agoOnly 42% of RNs having ever been tested is pretty solidly "We don't test health care workers in America". I would expect close to 100% of them to be tested on a regular basis.
- iso1210 6y ago> You want to vaccinate people most likely to spread it. Who that is, I'm not sure. Not when your vaccine isn't proven to stop spread.