3 ms·
> I've been curious if the spikes we've seen since October is the flu season giving people with cold symptoms which get them out of the house to be tested and i
by mlyle 6y ago
> I've been curious if the spikes we've seen since October is the flu season giving people with cold symptoms which get them out of the house to be tested and it caught many more asymptomatic people than usual.
You'd expect that to decrease positivity rates (by getting a wider pool of people to get tested), but instead the positivity rates --- the percentage of tests that are positive --- have been increasing.
- dmix 6y agoThat's a good point. The flu numbers tended to be higher, or at least they used to be, so if it is indeed 1 in 5 Americans (and similarly higher in other countries) and a high crossover between the two demographic groups, than it still could account for a partial increase at a minimum. There will of course be more than one contributing factor here. But as I mentioned in another comment my pharmacist said she has barely sold any cough/cold syrup at all this year when by this time of the year they'd be flying off the shelves. The lockdown may have helped stopped common cold / flu spread as well. So my proposition may be insignificant.
- mlyle 6y agoFlu/cold have much lower presumptive R0's than COVID. So, in general, measures that are effective against COVID are fantastically effective against the flu (influenza isn't quite at historic lows for this time of year, but it's close). My area is "minimal" in flu activity in the flu surveillance systems, but has increased COVID positivity rates from 3.3% to 5.4% in the past couple weeks, despite increased testing (and increased testing, in general, can be expected to push positivity rates down).
- ashtonkem 6y agoMasks would also seriously put a damper on any other respiratory virus, such as the flu.
- meragrin 6y agoWhy would it decrease it? It seems to me it would only increase it. The people likely to get the flu are the same group likely to get covid. The flu is harder to get than covid.
- mlyle 6y ago> Why would it decrease it? It seems to me it would only increase it. The people seeking tests were mainly two groups: people particularly concerned about COVID-- because of known exposure or COVID-specific symptoms, or people who occupationally are being tested because of surveillance. If you water that down with people with the flu, you'd expect the positivity rate to go down: not that influenza carriers are even more likely to have COVID than those previous groups. Influenza surveillance is showing "minimal" activity in my area, but a huge explosion in positivity rates for COVID-19 (3.3% to 5.4% in the past couple of weeks).