6 ms·
I've been curious if the spikes we've seen since October is the flu season giving people with cold symptoms which get them out of the house to be tested and it
by dmix 6y ago
I've been curious if the spikes we've seen since October is the flu season giving people with cold symptoms which get them out of the house to be tested and it caught many more asymptomatic people than usual.
While the vast majority of asymptomatic just stayed out of the system during the spring and summer.
Also, slightly off topic, but the recent spike in Turkey shows how mind-blowingly fast it can shutdown your country, they went from obscurity to 4th place in daily counts after US, India, and Brazil within a month, despite much lower population levels:
https://i.imgur.com/busPOrn.png https://i.imgur.com/busPOrn.png
https://gisanddata.maps.arcgis.com/apps/opsdashboard/index.html#/bda7594740fd40299423467b48e9ecf6 https://gisanddata.maps.arcgis.com/apps/opsdashboard/index.h...
- jsight 6y agoI do wonder if this is having some impact. The rate of hospitalizations are rising pretty fast along with the positive case rate in my state, though. The percentage of positive tests has climbed quite a bit as well.
- DennisP 6y agoNationally, the number of deaths is going up pretty rapidly too.
- IamZeroBalance 6y agoAgreed
- conductr 6y agoSpike in October was back to school in September and wide spread reopenings and increased activity associated with these. I have no data, but the correlation seemed strong and I can't figure out why everyone is scratching their heads about it. Puts me in the "change my mind" camp on this linkage.
- Exmoor 6y ago14 day average case counts in my county are 10x what they were when school went back. But, we never went back to in-person schools for 99% of kids. Anecdotal, but it's certainly very possible for rates to go up even without in-person school.
- conductr 6y agoNo idea where you are. In US, things opened up and returned at such a rate the ripple effect is wide.
- mlyle 6y ago> I've been curious if the spikes we've seen since October is the flu season giving people with cold symptoms which get them out of the house to be tested and it caught many more asymptomatic people than usual. You'd expect that to decrease positivity rates (by getting a wider pool of people to get tested), but instead the positivity rates --- the percentage of tests that are positive --- have been increasing.
- dmix 6y agoThat's a good point. The flu numbers tended to be higher, or at least they used to be, so if it is indeed 1 in 5 Americans (and similarly higher in other countries) and a high crossover between the two demographic groups, than it still could account for a partial increase at a minimum. There will of course be more than one contributing factor here. But as I mentioned in another comment my pharmacist said she has barely sold any cough/cold syrup at all this year when by this time of the year they'd be flying off the shelves. The lockdown may have helped stopped common cold / flu spread as well. So my proposition may be insignificant.
- mlyle 6y agoFlu/cold have much lower presumptive R0's than COVID. So, in general, measures that are effective against COVID are fantastically effective against the flu (influenza isn't quite at historic lows for this time of year, but it's close). My area is "minimal" in flu activity in the flu surveillance systems, but has increased COVID positivity rates from 3.3% to 5.4% in the past couple weeks, despite increased testing (and increased testing, in general, can be expected to push positivity rates down).
- ashtonkem 6y agoMasks would also seriously put a damper on any other respiratory virus, such as the flu.
- meragrin 6y agoWhy would it decrease it? It seems to me it would only increase it. The people likely to get the flu are the same group likely to get covid. The flu is harder to get than covid.
- majormajor 6y agohttps://www.latimes.com/projects/california-coronavirus-cases-tracking-outbreak/#patients https://www.latimes.com/projects/california-coronavirus-case... I don't know a good national set of equivalent graphs, but in California the hospitalizations are tracking the case counts with some delay, as are the deaths (though those are even more delayed), so I highly doubt you're just seeing additional asymptomatic cases. The curve of the ICU cases vs overall hospitalized cases is interesting - it's lower, so potentially that could be good news like we're better at treating it now, or bad news that capacity is already low enough (<%10 in some counties) that it's harder to get an ICU bed than it used to be.
- sbinthree 6y agoWe are way better at treating it, there's just so many more cases. A lot of invisible cases where people get hardcore antivirals a day before they would be hospitalized, etc.
- dmix 6y agoThat's a start, although it'd then be good to compare to compare hospitalizations for flu as well to weed out some of the numbers. I've long want to pull in some data locally and do so some data science on it. Like ranking countries by cases vs population ratios.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- denimnerd46 6y agoflu season is pretty low as far as I've heard. I don't have a lot of evidence only this and some articles I read last year about it being dead as soon as masks and social distancing came about https://www.fox4news.com/news/cooks-childrens-hospital-reports-zero-flu-cases-so-far-this-season https://www.fox4news.com/news/cooks-childrens-hospital-repor...
- spijdar 6y agoI can't speak to a wide area, but where I live in the US, the flu is definitely not dead. Despite wearing a mask, keeping socially distance and basically not traveling except when essential, I caught type B of the flu, and my doctors told me they've had a shocking number of flu cases. They seemed to expect to see fewer, too, but have observed the opposite.
- chrononaut 6y ago> Seasonal influenza activity in the United States remains lower than usual for this time of year. https://www.cdc.gov/flu/weekly/index.htm https://www.cdc.gov/flu/weekly/index.htm While not dead as GP expressed, there are notably fewer infections so far this year.
- neves 6y agoI'll probably start to use a mask every flu season.
- spijdar 6y agoThat's fair. I didn't mean to imply things are exploding, though I guess it sounds like I did. It just sounds like even doctors expected flu to be almost non-existent, but instead it seems ... oddly normal.
- denimnerd46 6y ago> Key Points > Flu activity is unusually low at this time but may increase in the coming months. How did you even get the flu.
- randallsquared 6y ago> I've been curious if the spikes we've seen since October is the flu season giving people with cold symptoms which get them out of the house to be tested and it caught many more asymptomatic people than usual. I don't think that can be the explanation, because deaths have also spiked.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> I’ve been curious if the spikes we’ve seen since October is the flu season giving people with cold symptoms which get them out of the house to be tested and it caught many more asymptomatic people than usual. If that were the case, you wouldn’t see the hospitalization, ICU, and death rates surging at the usual delay behind the general case rates, but you do, which suggests that, no, the surge in COVID cases isn’t inflated significantly by finding COVID-asymptomatic cases with a concurrent symptomatic common cold.
- neves 6y agoUsing masks and doing social distance I'm much less sick this year.
- irq11 6y agoAlmost no areas are seeing above-average utilization of hospital or ICU beds. It’s a media narrative that doesn’t hold up to scrutiny. ICUs routinely run at 90% capacity during the winter. Right now, most states are below this.
- ashtonkem 6y agoYou made this same argument here about 80,000 deaths ago.
- irq11 6y agoDon’t know who you think you’re talking to, or why you think this is a rebuttal to a factual statement. Hospital utilization is pretty much in line with seasonal levels: https://mobile.twitter.com/justin_hart/status/1327740997078380544 https://mobile.twitter.com/justin_hart/status/13277409970783... https://protect-public.hhs.gov/pages/hospital-capacity https://protect-public.hhs.gov/pages/hospital-capacity You have to cherry-pick individual hospitals to create the narrative that “hospitals are overwhelmed”....which is exactly what the news media has been doing.
- ashtonkem 6y ago
- gorkemyurt 6y agoUntil very recently Turkey was only reporting symptomatic patients. After some pressure from healthcare unions they started reporting all positive cases.
- dmix 6y agoThat definitely would account for a big percentage of the near 4x jump. But there have been plenty of articles of Turkey's hospitals getting absolutely rammed and doctors saying it was nothing like it was in the old 'bad days' in April but far worse.
- kingofpandora 6y agoFor a while Turkey was only reporting patients who needed treatment and not releasing the actual number of infected. They were eventually shamed into being more forthcoming about the situation.