2 ms·
Well, the problem is that there are all these intertwined concepts so that for the most part we have:¹ * We want individuals to be able to express themselves s
by renewiltord 6y ago
Well, the problem is that there are all these intertwined concepts so that for the most part we have:¹
* We want individuals to be able to express themselves so long as they are not explicitly deceiving people or hurting them
* We believe groups of individuals should have the freedoms individuals do
* We believe that individuals whose sole purpose is to act to provide a service to individuals expressing shouldn't be liable for the expression under some conditions. e.g. if I let you rent my sound equipment, I shouldn't be liable because you use it to call for violence against some dude and likewise for online platforms provided they take some reasonable measures
* We believe that picking and choosing what people can use your platform to express is expression in itself, but sometimes you are obligated to suppress some expression
So YouTube is one of these platforms. They should be allowed to pick and choose what people can use them to express because that's a freedom one person has, and therefore that they have as a group of people who individually have it. So the defence rests on it being expression.
However, the defence for them not being liable for expression on their platform is that they're "just the platform". By choosing not to enforce on other things and choosing to enforce on these things they're not "just the platform" - the expression they permit is their expression.
It's a bit hazy, but it feels to me like you forfeit some of your "just a platform" defence when you exercise your "it's my right to expression" defence. Morally, of course, not legally. IANAL and this isn't a court so who gives a damn about the law on its own.
¹ If you don't hold these beliefs, then you're not in the audience for the comment. Skip safely.
- chordalkeyboard 6y agoThis is an excellent summary of the dilemma. Thank you for summarizing it so clearly and succinctly.