3 ms·
> But: spatial audio only works (for now at least) when the video source is an iPhone or iPad. The AirPods (Pro or Max) know when your head is moving, but the s
by crazygringo 6y ago
> But: spatial audio only works (for now at least) when the video source is an iPhone or iPad. The AirPods (Pro or Max) know when your head is moving, but the source device needs to be location-aware too... it’s natural to want to use AirPods Max to watch a movie with the full spatial audio experience, as loud as you want, on the biggest screen in your house... But you can’t. You can only get this big room-sized audio experience with the small visual experience of an iPad or iPhone screen.
Even with the AirPods Pro, I'm so baffled by this.
Why does the source device need to be location-aware?
Wouldn't it be enough to just orient the spatial audio to something like your "median" head orientation? Obviously, the vast majority of the time you're watching something, you're looking at the screen.
Or for something fixed (like a TV), just click a button during setup while wearing your headphones saying "I'm looking directly at the center of the screen now."
I'm curious what I might be missing that makes it so critical for the source device to have an accelerometer and gyroscope.
(As a side note, I guess I also don't actually understand how your AirPods know how to orient themselves towards the direction of your device in the first place -- I don't believe they have an internal compass component.)
- archagon 6y agoI don't think it's essential. The Audeze Mobius is able to do this without the source being location-aware. (In fact, IIRC it appears as a 7.1 speaker in your audio settings.)
- jedimastert 6y agoWhat you need is the location of both, at the same time, in 3D space relative to each other. Just a direction doesn't really work without distance. What would could do, I suppose, is put the headphones on top of wherever "home" is and use that...
- henriks 6y agoDo the AirPods actually orient themselves towards your device, or just assume you're looking at it most of the time? I've noticed that the sound stage seems to recenter if I look away from the device for long enough when listening to some show on my iPad, and doing something else on a computer.
- mleonhard 6y agoAccelerometer drift is a hard problem. You can experience it with VR headsets that have no base station, like Playstation VR. They require re-calibration every 10-30 minutes or so. I assume that the iPhone/iPad is constantly re-calibrating user orientation using the camera and depth mapper. I imagine two ways that Apple could make AirPods Max work with Apple TV: 1. Add a camera to the Apple TV. Some people would be uncomfortable with this. 2. Add an orientation base station to the Apple TV and add receivers to the headphones. This will increase weight, cost, and power consumption (battery weight). It's possible that Apple already added the sensors. Has anyone done a teardown to look for orientation signal receiver chips?