4 ms·
One book I found really interesting on this theme is "Confronting Managerialism: How the Business Elite and Their Schools Threw Our Lives Out of Balance": https
by wpietri 6y ago
One book I found really interesting on this theme is "Confronting Managerialism: How the Business Elite and Their Schools Threw Our Lives Out of Balance": https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00A76WZ96/ https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00A76WZ96/
Core to their point is that managers have basically become a caste. They define managerialism as "what occurs when a special group, called management, ensconces itself systemically in an organization and deprives owners and employees of their decision-making power (including the distribution of emoluments) and justifies that takeover on the grounds of the managing group's education and exclusive possession of the codified bodies of knowledge and know-how necessary to the efficient running of the organization."
It had a lot of resonance for me because engineers think of optimization fundamentally differently than MBAs do. When I want to make something better, I tend to optimize for increasing value and/or lowering cost. MBAs tend tend to optimize for profit and things that drive profit. Which you would think wouldn't be all that different, but it becomes really obvious when you look at how private equity can destroy a company over time. E.g., Simmons Mattress: https://www.nytimes.com/2009/10/05/business/economy/05simmons.html https://www.nytimes.com/2009/10/05/business/economy/05simmon...
- P_I_Staker 6y agoYeah, this is something I've noticed too. IMO defacto caste system(s) have formed in the US. The way we view management in the US is toxic.
- analog31 6y agoSomething interesting has struck me about this thread. In almost every HN thread about higher education, there is a very strong if not prevailing view, that advanced degrees are primarily a form of empty credentialing or signaling. Yet a search for those terms in this thread yields almost no hits. I wonder if what's missing here is a deeper dive into what MBA's actually learn in business school, if anything. Sure, they learn something. There are certain kinds of data gathering or processing tasks that I would assign to an MBA. But I've known several people who have gotten MBA's after getting advanced degrees in the sciences or engineering. They all expressed that the work was time consuming, but not intellectually demanding for someone who is basically literate and comfortable with arithmetic. Their MBA "capstone" projects were nowhere near as meaty as their MS or PhD theses. A perusal of the flagship Harvard Business Review supports this notion. Supporting your idea, I've noted in the past (probably here in HN) that the people who value the MBA degree the most are other MBA's. The "problem" with the MBA might have nothing to do with the actual content of the degree, but the formation of an insular tribe that develops a shared language and culture with a life of its own. People of real intellectual distinction may be a minority within that tribe, thus its effect may be as simple as a dumbing down of management. If I've noticed one intellectual trait held in common by the MBA's, it's the ability to speak in a language that avoids any mention of the human impact of their actions. A sort of learned sociopathy if you will. "Never ascribe to malice that which can be adequately explained by stupidity."
- wpietri 6y ago> I wonder if what's missing here is a deeper dive into what MBA's actually learn in business school, if anything. A friend with an aerospace engineering degree said there was only one thing in his MBA program that he couldn't have figured out with a little thought. That was the principle of comparative advantage. He said what made it worth it was the great network that he built.
- thewileyone 6y agoI can agree with this. Before I got my MBA, my perspective was always from the pure technical solution; thinking about the business wasn't as natural. Getting MBA gave me the business perspective of the companies and clients I've worked for. Now, I don't have to squeeze out the extra thinking.
- justinclift 6y ago> A sort of learned sociopathy if you will. Maybe a good description for Ivy League MBA degrees? :)