4 ms·
>You can buy a Raspberry pi for 30$,and run whatever you want on it. For those in lower income nations this is an absolute game changer. Except that decent Ras
by ChuckNorris89 6y ago
>You can buy a Raspberry pi for 30$,and run whatever you want on it. For those in lower income nations this is an absolute game changer.
Except that decent RaspberyPI configs that could replace PCs cost around $60-70(In EU) and once you add a display, peripherals and a decent microSD card(which is still smaller, slower and less reliable than even a budget SSD) and you're looking at over $100 and for that kind of cash, a second hand X86 notebook(old beaten up Dell/Lenovo with an i5, 8GB RAM and 128GB SSD) gives you way more power and flexibility with what you can boot, install and do with it, it's not even a competition. Not to mention it comes with a built in battery so you can carry it to school unlike a PI, and before someone sniggers and shows me a link with a Raspberry PI based notebook just to contradict me, ask yourselves if you would actually use that as a productivity daily driver for work and play vs a X86 laptop.
Sorry, even in developing nations, second hand notebooks/PCs are a way better deal in every way as a personal computer than a PI which is why PIs have never taken off as PCs and are still stuck in the hacker, tinkerer, learning, embedded, automation niches.
>Phones need to sorta be closed, who wants a null pointer exception to lock the dialer UI in an emergency ?
Why do they need to be closed? Having closed source software is no guarantee of quality nor security.
>Of course if you really want to, you can buy one of those open phones and program your own dialer from scratch, not a very good idea for the typical user though
By wanting more openness we don't mean reinventing the wheel and coding open source dialers from scratch, we mean we need Apple and Google to not lock their hardware to their appstores so we(companies, users, banks, developers and even governments) don't become prisoners to their walled gardens which is basically the current situation.
- cesarb 6y ago> and once you add a display, and peripherals you're looking at over $100 I believe the basic idea of the Raspberry Pi is that everyone already has the display (a television), so the only peripherals you need are the power supply, keyboard, mouse, and HDMI cable, which together should be around USD 15 or even less (from a quick search for local prices here then converting to USD).
- ChuckNorris89 6y ago>I believe the basic idea of the Raspberry Pi is that everyone already has the display (a television) Sounds like a pretty poor assumption to me. In EU at least, over half the people I know own no television(TV tax is huge here and excluding boomers, nobody watches it anyway because Netflix) and if we assume all families in developing nations own a TV in the household then it would be difficult to do any productive type of work on it as the TV would probably be used a lot for, you know, watching TV and other entertainment rather than having it reserved just as a tool. Good luck writing your homework on your TV while your dad wants to watch his game and your mom her show. Even in developing nations, second hand PCs are such affordable commodities that they're a no brainer.
- anthk 6y agoTV tax it's just for the UK.
- ChuckNorris89 6y agoHow are you so certain it's only in the UK? It's definitely a thing here in Germany and Austria, and a relatively expensive one at that for just possessing a TV, and I'll bet my hat it's a thing in most EU countries.
- anthk 6y agoNot in Spain.
- ChuckNorris89 6y agoLucky you. Still, it's not a UK only tax, as you originally claimed.
- vidarh 6y agoThey're not so lucky. In Spain the public broadcasters are paid from government grants from general taxation, so any tax payer pays towards it whether or not they have a TV and watch it. In any case, you're right, most of Europe has TV licenses of some kind or other [1] Thought notably in the UK, you can certainly own a TV without paying TV license [2] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Television_licence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Television_licence [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Television_licensing_in_the_United_Kingdom#When_a_TV_licence_is_not_required https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Television_licensing_in_the_Un...
- kevin_thibedeau 6y agoLinux desktops used to run with 4MiB of RAM on a 33MHz processor. You don't need the ultimate best to have a usable computer.
- ChuckNorris89 6y agoOK, sure, "we got to the moon with 4Mhz" but try watching youtube, editng photos and google docs with that configuration. What you probably mean by usable computer is either an embedded system or some ssh server but what most people actually do with computers is access the web and the modern web is so bloated that without fast hardware and proper software it becomes a pain to do anything remotely productive or fun. That's why the PI is not yet a good mainstream PC. It's too slow sometimes and has too many gotchas that the users who are not tinkerers won't put up with.
- kevin_thibedeau 6y agoYou can run X11 with a non-compositing window manager on very low performance hardware.
- ChuckNorris89 6y agoBut will it run modern web pages and youtube?
- pjmlp 6y agoTo be fair, YouTube doesn't run on Linux anyway, it crawls, unless you happen the have the magical combination of proper drivers.
- ChuckNorris89 6y agoMy point exactly. How can we expect tiny cheap linux computers like the PI to replace PCs for the average joe if they can't even run Youtube? Unless the hardware powers datacenters or mobile/IoT devices, HW manufacturers don't even bother supporting linux with drivers.