4 ms·
Aluminum is not better than plastic. Neither is plastic better than Aluminum. What matters quality and usage. Planes[1] without aluminum? Ouch. Cars[2] withou
by ho_schi 6y ago
Aluminum is not better than plastic. Neither is plastic better than Aluminum. What matters quality and usage.
Planes[1] without aluminum? Ouch.
Cars[2] without plastic? Ouch.
I prefer ThinkPads because the use high quality plastic chassis and keyboards. Polycarbonate, ABS or whatever doesn't matter to me. Inside the use also magnesium and aluminum. High quality plastics are better when used with skin contact, especially regarding the keyboard and mouse. I regret that phones made with polycarbonate are gone, removable back cover, Qi without glass at back and they don't shatter when you drop them like the 800 $/€ stuff from Apple or Samsung. What I don't want on my lap is a MacBook. When it get hot, that not comfortable.
TLDR
What looks good in first sight isn't good to use or in long term durability.
[1] Actually they use a lot composite material within modern planes like the B747-8, B787, A350 and so on :)
[2] Excepting the original Audi A2, a great piece of aluminum :)
PS: I've seen people buying keyboards and mice made of aluminium. I cannot imagine something more uncomfortable.
- OldHand2018 6y agoPlastic does have issues though - my wife's ThinkPad had a small piece of plastic holding the battery break. If the battery moved a little too much, the computer would shut down. So she sent it in for service. When she got the computer back, they had replaced the entire bottom of the computer, plus replaced the battery. Great, right? Except now the bottom of the computer is a different color than the top of the computer, and the battery is a 3rd color! It's ridiculous, but that's the thing you get with plastic. UV light changes the color over time.