4 ms·
It would be very nice if an open CPU ISA, which can be implemented by everyone, like RISC-V, would be more widespread. Sadly, RISC-V is not a good candidate fo
by adrian_b 6y ago
It would be very nice if an open CPU ISA, which can be implemented by everyone, like RISC-V, would be more widespread.
Sadly, RISC-V is not a good candidate for that. It is an excellent ISA for student implementation projects, but not for real work.
RISC-V is praised only by people who have very little or no experience with different CPU ISAs and with the history of their evolution.
RISC-V sucks more than even the ugliest ISA, x86. At least from the huge x86 ISA it is possible to extract a subset composed mostly of more recently introduced instructions, which can be considered as a decent ISA, except for the weird encoding, with many prefix bytes, which is needed for backward compatibility.
The 64-bit ARMv8 ISA is an example of a good ISA, but its future is clouded by the NVIDIA acquisition.
- yjftsjthsd-h 6y ago> RISC-V is praised only by people who have very little or no experience with different CPU ISAs and with the history of their evolution. I'm having trouble actually digging up the reference right now, but I've been told that it was specifically built out of decades of industry experience in what works in building processors/ISAs. > RISC-V sucks more than even the ugliest ISA, x86. How so? > At least from the huge x86 ISA it is possible to extract a subset composed mostly of more recently introduced instructions, which can be considered as a decent ISA, except for the weird encoding, with many prefix bytes, which is needed for backward compatibility. So, exactly like RISC-V base + extensions?