4 ms·
It's troubling to me that censorship is being set up as the narrative savior of a free society, when in fact just the opposite is true.
by sneak 6y ago
It's troubling to me that censorship is being set up as the narrative savior of a free society, when in fact just the opposite is true.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ben_w 6y agoAny measure for success, when used as a target, becomes a bad measure. Freedom of speech is a measure of a free society, if you make freedom of speech the target and insist on maximising it without limit, then boring complicated truths are overwhelmed by simplistic emotionally engaging lies. I don’t know where to aim, exactly, only that the real target is whatever freedom of speech is for — call it X because I’m not confident I know what X is. To the extent freedom of speech and X are aligned, aiming for whatever X is will also enable as much free speech as possible.
- sneak 6y agoThis sounds to me like mental gymnastics to justify censorship on the grounds that lies are more popular than the truth, as if this is some new development that Facebook just recently made possible. Lies have always been more popular than the truth. Observe that billions of people are entirely convinced that there is an invisible and omniscient wizard residing in the sky, watching them. The majority of people believing false things is dangerous, to be sure. Appointing censors is a naive and harmful approach to solving that problem, counterintuitively. Uncensored communications tools are how we fix that issue, despite the fact that fearful people will look at some of the short term effects and foolishly conclude that it's making things worse, focusing on antivaxxers and the like while ignoring the rise in global literacy and scientific progress and achievement.
- ben_w 6y agoIt sounds like you’re aggressively agreeing with me, and the closest you get to disagreement is: > Appointing censors is a naive and harmful approach to solving that problem, counterintuitively. But even then I would happily accept even the part that it is “naive” to appoint censors (I am calling for something much more subtle). These two things are close, but not perfectly so. “Free speech = free society” has been a good approximation for most of history even despite a majority believing in falsehoods. But the difference is there. Facebook per se isn’t the problem, I think; I would blame everyone who uses A.I. on large populations, testing and refining what is most likely to be shared without consideration as it “sounds about right” while pushing a particular narrative (in Facebook’s case the goal is “money”; others, including those who use Facebook as their means for this testing, have political rather than financial agendas). Facebook is just one of many doing that, the A.I. genie is well out of the bottle, and conversely Facebook could exist without that A.I. optimising for something we don’t really want. However, despite that being the only point where I think you’re actively disagreeing with me, I disagree with your new point here: > look at some of the short term effects and foolishly conclude that it's making things worse, focusing on antivaxxers and the like while ignoring the rise in global literacy and scientific progress and achievement. These are separate dimensions of what I consider a good society. China is part of the rise in those two, yet lacks free speech. Does it lack all the things which free speech is a good proxy for? I don’t know; but it does lack free speech.
- XorNot 6y agoYou don't have the freedom of speech you describe on Hacker News at all.
- sneak 6y agoWhat did I describe, and where?
- gjulianm 6y agoThere are alternative solutions to censorship. Censorship would just be a patch, and not even enough for the problems Facebook and other social media is creating. The issue is that Facebook has completely changed the incentives for what type of speech gets the most exposure. Now the contents of the speech do not matter, nor the source, nor whether it is true or useful or anything. Instead the metric is how much "engagement" it can create. Facebook will, by design, show on your timeline a lie that creates comments before a truth that doesn't. And it will do this time and time again, and the effect of the repeated exposures to lies is that even if you don't believe them, you will start doubting. Society can't keep up with that. It isn't just that there are people with polarized opinions, it's that you have people with completely different views of reality. Propping up lies is incredibly easy, and doing the necessary research to disprove those lies and spread the result is orders of magnitude more difficult. It's impossible to keep up the rhythm. The solution is not censorship, the solution is to force these companies to change those incentives. Stop with the automatic suggestions to get more engagement, stop showing content to people who didn't explicitly subscribe to it, stop the uncontrolled spread of content of any type. We can live without viral memes, we can't without a functioning society.
- bondarchuk 6y agoThe most pessimistic and paranoid commentators saw this coming back when the "fake news" and "fact checking" narratives were being ramped up, and it seems they were right.
- jpttsn 6y agoYup, and it's interesting to ponder why this narrative gains ground. Especially if we take at face value the claims that undue influence has been exerted for the past few years to ruin free society.