4 ms·
We've done this song and dance 1000 times: Someone says "DDG is bad" or "DDG is good" and all of the replies are basically "No, DDG is <opposite>". Let's try s
by phendrenad2 6y ago
We've done this song and dance 1000 times: Someone says "DDG is bad" or "DDG is good" and all of the replies are basically "No, DDG is <opposite>".
Let's try something new: Let's give examples. I'll go first:
Let's say I have a nebulous recollection that there is a wifi module with "NRF" in the model number. If I search for `nrf wifi` on both Google and DDG, which do you think provides better results?
Let's look at the top URL hits from both (this is in an incognito window, with ublock origin on!):
Google:
1) nordicsemi.com (the manufacturer) homepage
2) <manufacturer website> press release
3) <manufacturer website> random Q & A page
4) arduino.stackoverflow.com (question about how to use it)
5) Some blog (someone's guide to using it)
6) nrf.com (National Retail Federation) conference category: wifi and bluetooth analytics (unrelated result, but I can imagine someone going to this conference might google the exact same thing, good thing Google knows to show it...
--- A random box showing questions relevant to the device ---
7) arduino.cc (question about how to use it)
8) <electronics blog site A> (someone's guide to using it)
9) <electronics blog site A> (another page on using it)
10) <electronic parts retail site A> (sells it)
DDG:
1) <electronics blog site A> (someone's guide to using it)
2) <electronics blog site B> (someone's guide to using it)
3) <electronic parts retail site C> (someone's guide to using it)
4) <electronics blog site D> (someone's guide to using it)
5) <electronics blog site E> (someone's guide to using it)
6) <electronics blog site F> (another guide to using it)
7) <electronics blog site G> (someone's guide to using it)
8) arduino.cc (question about how to use it)
9) <manufacturer website> random Q & A page
10) <manufacturer website> another random Q & A page
As you can see, Google seems to prefer authoritative sources (the manufacturer, the conference that coincidentally has the same name and category), while DDG seems to prefer blogs and how-to guides. I won't say which is better, that's entirely subjective.
- bmn__ 6y agoYou found what you're looking for on the first page and on the first try for both. IMO that's a resounding success.
- huhtenberg 6y agoNot in 2020. A simple keyword match, even if weighted, is no longer enough. The engine needs to grok the context of a query. Chances of someone's using a generic query to find a blog instead of a vendor's site are basically zero.
- mswann 6y agoAs you said it depends on the context, I agree, but thus the chances someone's using a generic query to find vendor independent resources like blogs are not zero. With regard to the given example "nrf wifi", I'd prefer DDG's results as I usually know the manufacturer of the hardware I work with but often search for solutions to problems in context of that hardware. Furthermore depending on familiarity with domain names it's possible to deduce the manufacturer's website from GP's 9th result on DDG.
- kkoncevicius 6y agoHere is an interesting one: search for 'reddit conspiracy' on DDG and Google. DDG: /r/conspiracy at the top of the list - first result Google: nowhere to be seen Makes me wonder what else they are not showing.
- dorgo 6y agoMaybe it's just a joke by Google? Showing a reddit conspiracy ( no results for /r/conspiracy ) if somebody searchs for 'reddit conspiracy'.
- kkoncevicius 6y agoThat would be funny, but there are other examples like that. Pick any community towards the "right" and you will probably get the same result. i.e. search 'reddit dark enlightenment' Again first result on DDG, no result on Google.
- speedgoose 6y agoI checked Wikipedia : https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_Enlightenment https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_Enlightenment It's a bit more than "towards the right" IMHO. I don't mind this reddit community being ignored by Google Search.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- kkoncevicius 6y agoWell, another one - 'donald trump reddit'.
- speedgoose 6y ago
- dorgo 6y ago>Let's try something new: Let's give examples. Maybe better: Let's make (or find) a benchmark for web search.
- prox 6y agoSo here is an interesting one, I’d just searched import plugins for Wordpress, and the top result from Google is a 5 year old review website, while DDG gives me one from this year. The latter being more relevant to my search.