3 ms·
I think a lot of the evidence is marginal. Low vitamin D levels are an indicator of frailty, so all the observational evidence may be showing something other t
by mlyle 6y ago
I think a lot of the evidence is marginal. Low vitamin D levels are an indicator of frailty, so all the observational evidence may be showing something other than a causal relationship between vitamin D levels and COVID outcomes.
IV vitamin D seemed to be beneficial in early COVID-19 patients in one randomized trial, which is the best evidence of a causal relationship we have between vitamin D and prevention of severe COVID. Attempts at giving oral vitamin D after diagnosis showed no benefit, but wouldn't really be expected to, either.
There's probably some protective effect, but it's also probably much smaller than most are estimating. That said, taking a small to moderate dose of vitamin D is likely to do more good than harm to people for other reasons, and may provide a small margin of protection against severe COVID. Further, it's cheap and easy to do.
Since March, I've been taking a multivitamin that includes a moderate amount of D.
- skybrian 6y agoDid you mean "more good than harm?"
- mlyle 6y agoYah, I edited and fixed on re-read. Pretty stupid for me to be saying the opposite of what I mean. :D Really eager downvotes on my comment, too, today.
- colordrops 6y agoThe irony is always lost in these threads criticizing scientific studies by providing vague anonymous opinions.
- mlyle 6y agoIf you're saying I'm criticizing studies, I've done nothing of the kind. I've attempted to contextualize and summarize the evidence. Also, I'm not anonymous; my name is on the comment.