3 ms·
YouTube’s Content ID Discourages Fair Use and Dictates What We See Online
- Lammy 6y agoWhy is this attacking YouTube alone instead of the copyright system itself?
- advisedwang 6y agoContent ID goes much beyond what copyright law requires Google to do. Google could simply have no such system and allow rightsholders to find matches on their own, and go through the DMCA process. Content ID is Google proactively acting in the interests of rightsholders over YouTube creators, presumably so they can have cosy partnerships for music, TV etc.
- Lammy 6y agoYes, which they would not be so compelled to do without the copyright Sword of Damocles hanging over their head.
- anshumankmr 6y agoBut that is preventing Google from being sued into oblivion by the thr record companies, isn't it?
- jazzyjackson 6y agoHow much would it cost to just buy all the record companies I wonder
- advisedwang 6y agoNo, if Google (merely) complied with the DMCA - waiting until notified by a rightsholder and the taking content down - they couldn't be sued.
- GauntletWizard 6y agoThey could still be sued. It would be found to have no standing... but the record labels could and would drag that out for as long as possible, and cost millions in legal fees in the meantime. Google should fight it. It's good for them in the long run, and it's good for society long and short. But they've taken the easier path.
- harshitaneja 6y agoTom Scott has a great video on this topic. https://youtu.be/1Jwo5qc78QU https://youtu.be/1Jwo5qc78QU
- dredmorbius 6y agoQuite good. Submitted to HN but no traction: https://hn.algolia.com/?q=YouTube%27s+Copyright+System+Isn%27t+Broken.+The+World%27s+Is https://hn.algolia.com/?q=YouTube%27s+Copyright+System+Isn%2....
- harshitaneja 6y agoAh. Would have loved to participate in a nuanced discussion on this topic.
- dredmorbius 6y agoYou could submit it again yourself ;-)
- kevincox 6y agoI think the worst part of YouTube's implementation is that your video can stay up, with the revenue going to someone else without you having any control over it. Most videos get a huge portion of their profit in the first day, so this means that you basically loose a week or month of your income. I think it is very reasonable to argue that this is effectively YouTube allowing someone to steal the fruits of your labour. Even if the claim is dropped after a week the damage has been done. Most of your audience has seen the video and their ad revenue went to some company who made a likely incorrect claim. It seems like there should be an option to choose an automated response to the Content ID claim. For example if the Claimer tries to take the ad revenue immediately make the video private. This way when the process is over at least you have a chance to earn money for your hard work when you release the video. Of course YouTube is "in the right" here, you agree that they can take all of your ad revenue. They made this system which has some advantages over the base rules, but there are some huge disadvantages. At the end of the day I wish more people would publish to other platforms as well. But free unlimited video hosting with built-in promotion and monetization is a pretty sweet deal at the end of the day, even with its quirks.