6 ms·
Apple is a mega-monopoly. They control all ingress onto their platform. Nothing gets on that they don't want. Then they proceed to control the economic activi
by echelon 6y ago
Apple is a mega-monopoly.
They control all ingress onto their platform. Nothing gets on that they don't want.
Then they proceed to control the economic activity of everyone in the Apple ecosystem.
You literally cannot do business with Apple customers.
This is as bad as Standard Oil.
- draw_down 6y agoNay
- st1x7 6y agoMonopoly doesn't mean what you suggest - it's different from a locked-down ecosystem. Every monopoly dispute comes down to defining the market in question. Whether the market is phones, tablets, smartwatches or personal computers, Apple's market share comes nowhere near close to being a monopoly.
- inopinatus 6y agoThat is flatly incorrect. The market in question is the $150 billion mobile applications market, of which Apple controls 60% worldwide, well above the threshold for regulatory attention in many jurisdictions. The jurisprudence varies regionally on what "enough market power" means, before you may be accused of having abused it, but (for example) in Europe this starts at around 40%.
- st1x7 6y agoAgain, it depends on how you define the market. They have fewer devices, fewer apps, fewer app downloads, and more revenue. You just picked the one that they have the biggest share in. And even 60% of revenue isn't enough to determine a monopoly depending on other market dynamics.
- inopinatus 6y agoThere are no goalposts to move around here in some PR flack's hapless dream of muddying the issue. The market in question is the mobile applications market. It is one that is separately analyzed, well reported, clearly delineated, demonstrably an arena of choice, and significant to the consumer. This makes it difficult to ignore on any taxonomic basis of irrelevance. No threshold is itself enough, since there's no strict liability; generally speaking, it's not unlawful to have market power, it's unlawful to abuse it. Any regulatory or private action has to make a qualified case. But as far as thresholds go: that 60%, plus Apple's contractual requirement for market participants to actively mislead the consumer, is pretty terminal.
- st1x7 6y ago> There are no goalposts to move around here in some PR flack's hapless dream of muddying the issue. It's specifically about the goalposts, that's my entire point. It's not as straightforward and clear-cut as you're suggesting. Even saying something like "mobile applications market" doesn't make it clear whether we're talking about number of users, revenue, number of apps, number of app downloads, which mobile devices and so on.
- inopinatus 6y agoMarketplaces are quantified by economic value, there being no other universal unit. There's an arrogance in tech that we can make up definitions to suit ourselves. I guess it's related to the fallacy that the law is some kind of programming language.
- st1x7 6y ago> Marketplaces are quantified by economic value So if Apple had 100% of all phone users and 100% of all apps but the apps were entirely free, that wouldn't be a monopoly? > there being no other universal unit. I suggested a number of other units above. > There's an arrogance in tech that we can make up definitions to suit ourselves. The question of defining the market is the basis of how the decision is made in court and the biggest point of argument between the legal teams. This isn't about tech arrogance. I also feel like this back-and-forth isn't constructuve so I'll stop here.
- jbverschoor 6y agoBut the apps are not just mobile anymore. They are macOS apps, which happen to run on iOS
- deeeeplearning 6y agoSo If I sell 1 app for $101 Billion do I now have a Monopoly on the mobile app market since I will have >40% of the revenue?
- inopinatus 6y agoI think the considered response to that must be, "Good luck with your startup".
- deeeeplearning 6y agoIt's a legitimate question highlighting the absurdity of defining a monopoly by revenue.
- inopinatus 6y agoSince you cannot sell an app for that much money, it is not a legitimate question, and there is no reductio ad absurdum. Therefore it is a joke question. If you could sell one app for that much money, and real money or genuinely equivalent value is actually exchanged, then other apps would be worth similar amounts, and the entire segment would simply rescale to be quintillions of dollars; alternatively, if you or others were unable to repeat the sale, then the market has a weird transient spike one quarter, then goes back to normal, and everyone discounts the outlier as a Spiders Georg. Notwithstanding which, sure, monopolies are indeed not defined by revenue, they are defined by market control, which is enabled by market share, which is quantified by value (there being no other universal measure), i.e. by sales i.e. revenue, which is why it's part of the consideration but you still need some qualification to support the quantification. Such as, by way of painfully topical example, Apple successfully forcing other market participants to actively mislead the consumer or withdraw products, which is not merely a naked display of market power but also an egregious misuse thereof.
- deeeeplearning 6y ago>and there is no reductio ad absurdum Hate to break it to you but there is and I showed it which is why you made this salty reply. Certainly in the US there is no major Anti-Trust case which revolved around revenue as a measure of monopoly. Not Microsoft, not ATT and not Standard Oil.
- turbinerneiter 6y agoMonopoly is not defined by market share.
- frereubu 6y agoMonopoly (n) (an organization or group that has) complete control of something, especially an area of business, so that others have no share https://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/monopoly https://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/monopoly
- reaperducer 6y agoRolling out a dictionary definition works in seventh grade debate class, not in a court of law. Amazingly, hundreds of very thick books about what legally defines a monopoly are not the same as a single sentence from a web site.
- echelon 6y agoLet's let the Department of Justice decide.
- frereubu 6y agoI don't think you needed the snark. I was responding directly to the comment which says that a monopoly is not defined by market share. But that is exactly what a monopoly is defined as - it's the "mono" part in the word. If what the parent comment was talking about is not a monopoly, then they could have said that and pointed out what it is instead.
- mthoms 6y agoThe snark was uncalled for indeed. But keep in mind that there are legal definitions of some things, and those often differ greatly from the colloquial definitions we use from day-to-day.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- UShouldBWorking 6y agoExactly. You can't have a monopoly on stupidity. If idiots want to pay extra to buy into a walled garden nothing should stop them. Apple customers pay for lack of functionality and to signal to others how much money they have. A FAR cry from a monopoly.
- ardy42 6y ago> Every monopoly dispute comes down to defining the market in question. Whether the market is phones, tablets, smartwatches or personal computers, Apple's market share comes nowhere near close to being a monopoly. Exactly, which is why it's in no way clear that "Apple's market share comes nowhere near close to being a monopoly." If you defined Standard Oil's market as "fuels," it wasn't a monopoly because it was competing against coal and wood. If you defined AT&T's market as "communication services," it wasn't a monopoly because it was competing against TV, Radio, and the Post Office. And if you defined Apple's market as "3rd party software distribution, in general," you'd get the same result, but maybe not if its market is "3rd party software distribution for ~45% of all American phone users." Since the advent of antitrust law, every monopolist has a definition of its market that magically makes it not a monopoly and obscures its anticompetitive behavior; but that's not the definition we should use to judge them.
- johncolanduoni 6y agoI think there’s a pretty clear difference between “3rd party smartphone software distribution” and “3rd party smartphone software distribution for ~45% of all American phone users, and I get to pick which users, and coincidentally I only pick Apple users”. You’re the one stacking the deck in that instance, not Apple.
- chipotle_coyote 6y agoSure, but I think there's a tendency to try and make this seem way more clear-cut in either direction than it really is, e.g., Apple clearly {is | is not} guilty of antitrust violation by using their position as platform owner to dictate what applications and services are legally allowed on their platform. There's very little precedence in computing history for this other than game consoles, and it's not super crazy to ask whether that's a model that should apply to smartphones and tablets. (To me, that seems to be actually be a fundamental question, and I don't think I have an answer.)
- ardy42 6y ago> I think there’s a pretty clear difference between “3rd party smartphone software distribution” and “3rd party smartphone software distribution for ~45% of all American phone users, and I get to pick which users, and coincidentally I only pick Apple users”. You’re the one stacking the deck in that instance, not Apple. Not really, if you look at it from the perspective of software developers. If an Android developer no longer wants to be a customer of the Play Store (or gets rejected by them), they can go to a 3rd party app store or tell their users to sideload. An iOS developer has no options besides Apple: they either stick with them or essentially `rm -rf AllMyIOsInvestment/`.
- fossuser 6y agoI thought it was a step beyond that? Market dominance paired with leveraging that dominance in a way that hurts consumers. If it’s levered in a way that doesn’t hurt consumers, that may be hyper competitive and other businesses may not like it, but that’s not a monopoly abuse. At least that’s my layman’s understanding of the law. Apple’s behavior is arguably good for most users (restricting tracking/spying). I don’t think Apple’s behavior meets that consumer harm standard.
- kbenson 6y agoThat's why I like to use the "anti-competitive" terminology when I talk about this. Anti-competitive behavior is the problem, a monopoly is a specific very problematic example of anti-competitive behavior, but it's that it's anti-competitive that makes it a problem. Apple may not be a monopoly. They've definitely set up the ecosystem to be anti-competitive. Whether that's harmful to consumers (which is what matters) is debatable. I tend to think it's harmful, but they've done such a complete job of locking it down that it's hard to even compare without having to change a lot or things, since they control and exclude others from the hardware all the way up to sales transactions for services, and everything in between. That said, the fact that Apple was able to quickly cut their fees from 30% to 15% for some developers just because of growing public sentiment seems to indicate that competition is not working well to normalize these app store fees, and that likely means developers and by extension users are paying more because of that.
- toiletfuneral 6y agodude just buy an android. I really don't understand all this hyperbole on this subject. Somehow everyone on HN decided to become democratic socialist only when it pertains to App Store commissions lmao
- actuator 6y agoArgument in bad taste. You probably wouldn't get to use an iPhone today if antitrust hadn't reeled in Microsoft. Remember, MS bundling IE is nothing compared to the tightly coupled ecosystems of today.
- frereubu 6y ago"You literally cannot do business with Apple customers." This sounds rather hyperbolic. Sure, if you want to do business with customers through Apple's platform then you need to abide by their terms, but you can do business with them. On the surface it feels a bit like complaining that you can't do business with customers through Stripe, because Stripe has Ts&Cs that you need to abide by. Apple's situation is more complex, but I think the underlying reasoning on this specific point is the same isn't it?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- monocasa 6y agoI can drop Stripe as quickly as I can add another payment processor to my codebase and still have access to the same market. I can't do the same with Apple.
- frereubu 6y agoTrue, which is what I meant why I said the Apple situation is more complex. I was responding more to the phrase "you literally cannot do business with Apple customers."
- willis936 6y agoSure: by selling them software for Windows on your own website.
- echelon 6y agoThey won't be Apple customers. Apple customers will be on MacOS, which pretty soon will be signing binaries and denying anything not sold from the app store. Apple customers are under lock and key. You can't reach them without paying the Apple tax or obeying the arbitrary Apple platform rules.
- 6y ago
- AlexandrB 6y ago> They control all ingress onto their platform. Nothing gets on that they don't want. > Then they proceed to control the economic activity of everyone in the Apple ecosystem. > You literally cannot do business with Apple customers. This describes every brick & mortar store ever and just about every gaming console since the NES. I'm not sure what differentiates Apple from Nintendo or Target here.
- maxwell 6y agoWhere's this trillion dollar brick & mortar store? NTDOY's market cap is two orders lower than AAPL and their impact on the worldwide software application market is comparably quite small. TGT is also under $100B and they have essentially no impact on the software application market. What makes Apple different? Their size and market power. How much of the world economy is now dependent on their devices and services?
- AlexandrB 6y ago> Where's this trillion dollar brick & mortar store? Amazon.com Edit: Actually I wish Amazon exercised the kind of control that Apple does so I wouldn't have to guess if the phone charger I bought will set my house on fire.
- maxwell 6y ago"Brick & mortar" == physical stores. Amazon.com takes in hundreds of billions from online stores, tens from physical: https://www.visualcapitalist.com/amazon-revenue-model-2020 https://www.visualcapitalist.com/amazon-revenue-model-2020 https://www.amazon.com/find-your-store/b/?node=17608448011 https://www.amazon.com/find-your-store/b/?node=17608448011
- Spivak 6y agoWalmart, Target? I mean if you want your goods in Target you also have to follow their rules and use their payment system.
- Spivak 6y agoI mean there's nothing stopping me from creating a physical analog to this. I buy a space and set up stalls for businesses to set up shop. The conditions for being part of this market are: * You have to use my payment system. * I get 30% of your gross revenue. * You have to follow my guidelines about what you can and can't sell and how you're allowed to sell it. * You can't, while you're at the market, advertise how customers can reach you outside the market. I'm not about to just let you use my space as an advertising channel for free. And in this hypothetical universe my customers love it! They do all their shopping here. I can both see how businesses that don't want to follow my rules would feel super frustrated but those rules are what makes my market worth coming to. My rules basically boil down to "fuck you pay me" and treat my customers well.
- reaperducer 6y agoI buy a space and set up stalls for businesses to set up shop. The conditions for being part of this market are: This exact thing exists. From bazaars to food courts to antiques centers. There are hundreds of thousands of these situations around the world. But for some reason because "it's on the interwebs!" it's supposed to be magically different.
- ustolemyname 6y agoTo have this analogy encompass the full situation, you're also a residential landlord who owns 50% of all residential housing in the US. Your tenants are only allowed to have things in their home that came from the market you control. Things bought in the market also cannot be placed in housing you do not control. You argue you don't have a monopoly because your tenants can always move, even though most of their possessions cannot be moved to other housing. Reasoning by analogy is bad, but I think it's important to note that most people's phones are their digital home. It is not a low friction situation to just "shop elsewhere" for a single product when it wouldn't be compatible with your home.
- Spivak 6y agoThis is where I think the disconnect is. I see the entire iOS device as Apple's marketplace and so the housing analogy doesn't make sense to me. The app is your stall where you're allowed to sell things and conduct business. I'm not saying it's low friction at all. Hell I would try to make my hypothetical market as high-friction as possible by having a prepaid high-cost membership fee, as many exclusives as I could find, and lots of benefits and services tied to it. This just seems like business.
- CubsFan1060 6y agoAnd as a customer, I'm super happy about this. You can't charge me a subscription that I can't figure out how to cancel. You have a much harder time slipping in "features" that abuse my privacy. You don't get my email address or my information unless I want you to. I am guaranteed that this is all true on any iPhone I pick up. You might even say I'm paying them to protect me from your poor business practices.
- wavefunction 6y agoI wouldn't say that in this context which is an entirely voluntary proposition.
- TedDoesntTalk 6y agoBut that is exactly what PayPal pioneered and still does. So why can’t I use PayPal to buy iOS apps? (There are other problems with PayPal, so if that bothers you, replace X with PayPal that has the same privacy and subscription management features)
- inopinatus 6y agoThis mindset is the basis of half the dystopian fiction on my bookshelves, and Aldous Huxley wasn't even the first.
- echelon 6y ago> You can't charge me a subscription that I can't figure out how to cancel. This we need to regulate. This is what our lawmakers should be doing. Apple isn't doing this out of their own generosity. They're trying to get a slice of the pie. It's also why they shut down mobile advertising IDs, which on the surface sounds delightful. Ultimately that's more commerce going through Apple rails. More pie. Apple is strong-arming here to put more people in their walled garden. The government should craft legislation to protect privacy and should stop the "pretend privacy" game Apple is playing. Apple doesn't care about you, otherwise you wouldn't have to pay extra for a phone charger and they wouldn't squash 3rd party repair shops. > You don't get my email address or my information unless I want you to. This prevents businesses from establishing their own, hard-earned relationships with customers. Apple has your email and sends you promotional material all the time. Do you send those to trash? > slipping in "features" that abuse my privacy Apple already abuses your privacy, and if you don't see it you're being naive. They track which apps are running on Mac, and they recently caused an outage doing so. This is part of their push to ultimately lock down that platform behind an App Store. They do the same on iPhone. They know your location, your files, your chat history. You trust them. Mark Zuckerberg had a quote for that. Sorry for the privacy-invading Giphy/Facebook link, but Apple is literally this: http://gph.is/XJxIL3 http://gph.is/XJxIL3
- ancorevard 6y agoExcept that customers loves and trust them. Trust is the key. People can not trust thousands of random companies/developers. Trust is built up over time through a relationship. Without Apple, most of these transactions would not take place. This trust, App Store etc., has been built up and cannot be transferred automatically to another party.