3 ms·
I think this is a much more complicated topic than many are making it out to be. And this complication is why patents are weird. Like let's look at it. The arg
by godelski 6y ago
I think this is a much more complicated topic than many are making it out to be. And this complication is why patents are weird.
Like let's look at it. The argument here is that it was funded with public money so the data should be public. As a big OSS person I really like this idea. But who should the data be open to (and what data)? Germany?[0] (the funder) The EU? {North Korea,South Korea,Iran,Vietnam,China,Russia}?(the accused) The world? Public usually refers to the citizens of the country but can also colloquially mean "human."
Then we have to consider money (or resources, capital, whatever you want to call it. Time and effort was spent doing this and there was a loss of resources by some party). Is it fair for company A/Country A to spend a year or research time and money and Company B/Country B to steal that and make a profit through it because they can sell it for cheaper (i.e. B stole resources from A, that A spent time producing)? Do we know about how it is being produced? Are they vetted? There's all kinds of complications here that not only include resource recuperation (i.e. ignoring the capitalism component, which we can't because you can't just burn resources (capital) indefinitely) but there are also safety concerns.
Lots of companies decline to issue patents because they don't often protect their production rights. Often what happens is that the company produces a patent and 1) another company uses that knowledge to create something similar but distinct enough or 2) produces the same product in a country that does not respect the former country's patents. 1) is basically that student that copied your homework but made things unique enough that they technically weren't plagiarizing (but did they cheat?) and 2) is someone who copy pasted your assignment and turned it into a different professor. I don't think people feel great about either of these, but slightly better with 1. But you can also see a situation where the cheater turns in the assignment first and you get accused of cheating. The whole process is a mess!
Patents are difficult enough when you're operating in one country but get way more complex when you introduce other countries into the situation. I do think there needs to be major patent reform and personally I'd love to live in a world where all scientific advancements are available to anyone, but I'm not sure such a situation can exist until we advance to a post scarcity world. We're all familiar with OSS here and you'll always see people saying things like "Facebook is using that person's code, they should be a good guy and kick back a few grand for the free work." That's because we don't live in a post scarcity world. But in the mean time (until we get there) let's not trivialize the situation and try to view things from the situation we're in and how to advance things towards the dream situation.
[0] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-11-09/pfizer-vaccine-s-funding-came-from-berlin-not-washington https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-11-09/pfizer-va...