3 ms·
I didn't mention any political parties though? I didn't say anything could be cut though? What are you on about?
by chrisseaton 6y ago
I didn't mention any political parties though? I didn't say anything could be cut though? What are you on about?
- mindslight 6y ago>> the cost to fix would be peanuts > If you fix them all they add up to not peanuts and then you don't have any money left The initial criticism is worthwhile in its original context (0.02% of the agency's budget). By scaling it up, you took it out of that context so that it runs up against worries about the total budget, implying a shortfall even though the argument is about the same 0.02%. The obvious answer to your comment is "well then it's easy to cut a little from $ELSEWHERE", which will inevitably devolve into overt zero-sum partisan bickering.
- chrisseaton 6y agoI think you're reading things I didn't write, there.
- mindslight 6y agoNo, I was just looking a step ahead. The only thing your original comment added was an appeal to destructive penny pinching that often accompanies popular fiscal conservatism. For context I'm personally against wasting money. But kneecapping an organization by tightening its purse strings such that it can't fulfill its function is itself a larger waste of money.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> But kneecapping an organization by tightening its purse strings I haven't seen anyone in this thread suggesting reducing their budget. You're coming out of nowhere arguing against things nobody said.
- mindslight 6y agoThis is what you started off saying: > But there are probably thousands of things that cost only peanuts and aren't a priority. If you fix them all they add up to not peanuts and then you don't have any money left I don't know if you're just trying to argue a technicality that you didn't "suggest" it, and merely condemned it. Or why you're moving the goalposts to "reduce their budget". But either way you're not addressing the core of what I actually said. Since it seems to have eluded you, I'll restate: 1. not spending 0.02% more to finish a job is foolish 2. multiplying a tiny percentage by the scale of the whole budget to imply some unreasonable burden is disingenuous 3. the real waste occurs at the scale of entire agencies (eg eliminate the DEA and save $2.1 billion and some of our freedom) 4. arguing about such deep cuts ends up inherently partisan.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> Or why you're moving the goalposts to "reduce their budget". Nobody mentioned this but you! It's entirely something you brought up and you're the only person with any opinion on it! I haven't expressed a single opinion on reducing their budget or what their budget should be! I haven't moved the goalposts to it because I didn't say anything about it! > arguing about deep cuts ends up inherently partisan You're the only one arguing about deep cuts, or any cuts at all! I haven't given any opinions on any cuts! I've said absolutely nothing about it! There's no competing opinions on this with which to argue! You're not arguing with me you're arguing with someone completely imagined in your head! If you think I've got some opinion try to see where I actually said that before replying again.
- mindslight 6y agoYou keep saying that I am imagining what I believe you said. From my perspective, this is gaslighting. I will paraphrase what I think you said (and the straightforward context/implication). Please tell me where my understanding goes awry. > But there are probably thousands of things that cost only peanuts and aren't a priority. There are many other items that similarly need fixing (across all federal agencies). Each may not cost a lot individually. > If you fix them all they add up to not peanuts But if they were all fixed (applying a universal standard), the total cost would end up being a lot (spending a lot is bad, regardless of how much has been fixed) > *and then you don't have any money left and you didn't even fix any priority tasks! The total budget should not be increased, so a policy of fixing small things would take away significant spending from other things that are more important.