6 ms·
Remember with NOAA and NWS you always have GOP pressure originating from Accuweather, which really wants to be a the gatekeeper for this data. Over the years t
by Spooky23 6y ago
Remember with NOAA and NWS you always have GOP pressure originating from Accuweather, which really wants to be a the gatekeeper for this data.
Over the years they have attacked the NWS web properties in particular (Rick Santorum was their attack dog a few years back) as their business of selling graphics to TV stations has declined along with traditional TV.
- lotsofpulp 6y agohttps://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2018-06-14/trump-s-pick-to-lead-weather-agency-spent-30-years-fighting-it https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2018-06-14/trump-s-p...
- warkdarrior 6y ago> The NWS was giving away forecasts on its website, radio stations, and elsewhere, when businesses such as AccuWeather charged its clients for theirs—never mind that AccuWeather relied on the service’s free data to formulate its own predictions. Santorum agreed that commercial weather companies deserved protection. Corruption at its finest.
- e40 6y agoI don't care who you voted for, this should make every American really, really mad.
- falcolas 6y agoWell, not if you don't understand how hard accurate weather forecsts are to get, or why a private entity couldn't do better. After all, that's why the news shows have weathermen, right?! And if the NOAA goes away, the government becomes smaller, and their taxes go down, right? :/ EDIT: Dear downvoters - while this is not my opinion, this is how people think, what people believe. Dismiss it at your own risk.
- jschwartzi 6y agoNWS is an amazing resource for pre-trip planning for a variety of different people. I frequently consult it for weather forecasts prior to hiking. I'm not sure a company like Accuweather could provide me with access to such great forecasts or sensor data as NWS does given how reliant they are on NWS data themselves. The other problem here is that Accuweather charges huge fees for access to their forecasts and I'm not sure that I, as a private citizen, could afford that. So my choices go from pay a little bit of tax to get access to high-quality, reliable weather forecasts and warnings, to being totally unable to get access to this information without paying exorbitant fee. Or alternatively just not knowing these things and having to pay higher insurance costs for my ignorance. This is a really good example of how making government smaller makes a lot of peoples' lives much crappier.
- 2trill2spill 6y agoWhy would you pay for Accuweather forecasts? You can use their website for free, they just have a bunch of dumb ads. Although I agree I like NWS way more than Accuweather or weather.com, etc, and I would be sad if NWS were forced to take it down.
- jfrunyon 6y agoNo. The news shows have weathermen so that they have a presentable face on the data they get from the NWS.
- krapp 6y agoSome weather forecasters are just "presentable faces." But some are actual meteorologists who try to put effort into interpreting that data. I used to work at a tv station and the Actual Meteorologists were very particular about not being confused with the "weather people."
- jfrunyon 6y agoYes, you're right, I over-simplified. Many of them are (or have) meteorologists. To give the data itself a pretty face (interpretation). But that's not the primary reason that news stations hire "weather people". If it was, they would just contract out to some other company.
- throw0101a 6y ago> I don't care who you voted for, this should make every American really, really mad. There exists a certain group of people that think private sector and The Market™ should handle many/most/all things. Do you want to guess which political party those people tend to associate with? Also, should we be more or less mad about this than someone trying to overturn fair elections like is happening now? Do you want to guess which political party is trying to do that? Do you want to guess if it's the same political party which believes in The Market™? So you may not think it matters who people voted for, and that this should be a universal feeling… but that's not what reality is. Do you know what other things should have universal consensus? * Taking a pandemic seriously. * Climate change.
- bearjaws 6y agoBoth sides!!111/s
- rhizome 6y agoFirst, there's no way to compare the election stuff with this weather thing. Sometimes different things happen at the same time for different reasons. >There exists a certain group of people that think private sector and The Market™ should handle many/most/all things I think the Accuweather problem is worse, much worse. What has happened is that NOAA & NWS had been happily supplying data to..whoever..when some people decided to create a commercial service with the same data. Then they hired disgraced Jesus-freak Santorum to play lobbyist and try to kill the NOAA/NWS public services. Note that Accuweather is not going to fly their own satelites, they just want you to be locked out.[1] That's right: if a private company decides to commercialize something the government is already doing, using the same government services that that government function is using, then the government should stop doing the thing and let the private company have the market.[2][3] This is a continuation of the Republican principle of privatizing profits and socializing risk, as well as colonizing publicly-funded resources. It's classic pulling-the-ladder-up. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Weather_Service_Duties_Act_of_2005 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Weather_Service_Dutie... 2. https://www.cnn.com/2017/10/14/politics/noaa-nominee-accuweather/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2017/10/14/politics/noaa-nominee-accuwea... 3. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2018-06-14/trump-s-pick-to-lead-weather-agency-spent-30-years-fighting-it https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2018-06-14/trump-s-p...
- JPKab 6y agoI'm not arguing with this view, but I want to emphasize, that as someone who once worked in the Federal sector in numerous different agencies, that they waste tremendous amounts of money on things that have nothing to do with their core mission. The Pentagon is obviously horrendous, but other agencies that I expected to be better stewards of their dollars (EPA, DoE, IRS, and yes, NOAA) were horrifically wasteful, on dozens of fronts. The hiring is always a problem, even when there isn't a hiring freeze, but they don't fire enough lazy people, which demotivates hard workers who end up bailing for the private sector. As taxpayers, we should be furious at the GOP for the Accuweather bullshit, but we also need to be furious at any government agency which tolerates the level of fraud, waste, and abuse that most of these agencies perpertrate. As a person who happens to want universal healthcare like the NHS in Britain, it's infuriating to me that these agencies tolerate such constant mediocrity in their ranks (mixed in with the talented of course!!!) and are so bad with their spending efficiency. Bezos had something to say about the Seattle city government last year: "They don't have a revenue problem, they have a spending efficiency problem." It seems like we always get political about this, with one side wanting to "starve the beast" (as if government is this evil beast), and the other side just always letting them get away with the excuse that they need more revenue. Where are the people who BELIEVE in government that will demand that it be efficient? Edit: I love how people think that because corporations are inefficient, they assume that all organizations are equally ad inefficient as the US Federal Govt. The rate at which people are involuntarily terminated in the Fed Gov is far, far too low, because incompetence is routinely tolerated where it wouldn't otherwise be anywhere else. Why? Not because a person's supervisor in the Fed doesn't recognize the incompetence, but because the firing process is so difficult that they don't want to or can't expend the energy to do so. If you want government to have a bigger role in people's lives, but are so delusional as to not recognize how bad it is, then you aren't furthering your cause. The FDA still hasn't approved the Pfizer vaccine, while the NHS already did. Pfizer is an American company. That's a national embarrassment.
- cratermoon 6y agoNone of those inefficiencies are unique to government agencies. They all happen in the private sector two but you don't hear about them because corporations are not subject to an open records act. And that "oh but the free market will ensure inefficient companies fail" response some are about the write is total bs. Companies fail for all kinds of reasons, inefficiency is just one of several things and not always deadly to a corporation.
- ars 6y agoExcept that Obama reduced funding and Trump increased funding. So this is not exactly the way you're portraying. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25376087 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25376087 And that bill you mentioned failed because the GOP did not support it. It was just the one congressman that wanted it. No one else agreed to join him. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Weather_Service_Duties_Act_of_2005 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Weather_Service_Dut...
- makomk 6y agoErrm, AccuWeather is one of the companies complaining about this proposal. From the article: "Jonathan Porter, a vice president and general manager at the private forecasting firm AccuWeather, warns that the agency’s proposed solution would harm the timeliness and accuracy of forecasts and severe weather warnings. He said the collection, processing and distribution of weather information are the agency’s “most important services.”" Apparently not getting all that NWS weather data for free and then being abl to use it in their commercial weather forecasts would put a bit of a dent in their business model. Actually, I think commercial organisations like AccuWeather probably be the main ones affected; ordinary end users aren't going to be requesting large quantities of data.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- cptskippy 6y agoSo NOAA and the NWS are playing 3D Chess against AccuWeather whose been loddying against them for years? Now, unless AccuWeather wants to start paying for the data they'll need to start lobbying for them... I love it.
- JPKab 6y agoLol. So basically, AccuWeather wants to have their cake and eat it too. What's the nature of their lobbying? Are they basically trying to defund any kind of front-end, consumer facing services from the NWS/NOAA, while keeping the back-end data sources available for them to feed their own consumer facing services? Hilarious if that's the specific scenario.
- cameldrv 6y agoThat is the specific scenario. They've lobbied for the NWS to not run any public facing services, but still collect all of the data, run the models, and put the GRIB files up, but then stop there so that Accuweather can monetize it.