4 ms·
What I've seen is a good explanation for is why so many low population counties are doing so badly. Take South Dakota. South Dakota has 19 (out of 66) countie
by tzs 6y ago
What I've seen is a good explanation for is why so many low population counties are doing so badly.
Take South Dakota.
South Dakota has 19 (out of 66) counties with daily cases per 100k over 100. Here are their populations in units of 1000 people: 5.9, 2.8, 7.1, 1.9, 23, 2.1, 5.4, 5.4, 5.4, 28, 9.3, 6.4, 2.9, 2.9, 2.2, 2.2, 4.4, 3.8, 8.4. The first 5 of those have daily cases over 150 (and the top 3 are 560, 244, 217).
57 counties have daily cases over 50.
One county (population 0.9k) has 0. Here are the rest under 50: 20.8, 24.0, 25.6, 31.3, 31.9, 43.0, 44.8, 49.7. Populations in k are 1.4, 2.4, 1.3, 3.2, 6.7, 4.2, 5.6, 2.3.
Their biggest counties are in the middle. The 10 counties with population of 20k or more have daily cases of 99.4, 87.4, 84.8, 85.7, 64.8, 71.6, 123.9, 90.1, 189.1, and 68.6. (Populations in k: 190, 110, 61, 39, 35, 28, 28, 26, 23, 20).
Compare to Washington (picked because I live there, so use it as a reference). We've got 9 counties under 20 new cases per 100k, 17 from 20 to 50, and 13 from 50 to 94.1.
Our biggest counties (pop. in k: 2300, 900, 820) have daily cases of 22.5, 34.9, and 31.1. I'm in a county with 270k people, and we are hitting new highs now of 19.6 daily cases per 100k, which would make us the second best county in the state if we were in South Dakota.
Rural areas are supposed to be where you go to escape a pandemic. How do you turn rural areas into places that are hardest hit?
- jrs235 6y ago> How do you turn rural areas into places that are hardest hit? By acting like it isn't a big deal and not taking it seriously at all and therefore taking little to no precautions.
- stolenmerch 6y agoThat's largely not true. Most of these states have similar restrictions and mask mandates and public compliance as the rest of the country. California is doing no better than Iowa right now. https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/us/states-reopen-map-coronavirus.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/us/states-reopen-ma...
- stolenmerch 6y agoIt also depends on what metric is used to determine "hardest hit". ICU headroom used in Washington is about the same or higher than many states in Middle America.
- TMWNN 6y ago>Rural areas are supposed to be where you go to escape a pandemic. How do you turn rural areas into places that are hardest hit? Density doesn't matter much for a virus as infectious as SARS-CoV-2. Very few people live in the mountains or on farms and only come into town every six months. In retrospect I think everyone should have taken the Swedish approach (the one the UK was following until the scary Imperial College projection came out), and plan on everyone catching the disease sooner or later.
- gumby 6y ago> In retrospect I think everyone should have taken the Swedish approach Sweden is now backing out of that plan. Also, there’s a gradient of response to the virus: some people die, some people survive but suffer long term symptoms/damage and some people appear to simply go back to normal. These survivors are not distributed (by age, other comorbidities) the way fatalities are.
- TMWNN 6y ago>Sweden is now backing out of that plan. If you read Hacker News for any length of time, each week there will be multiple "Sweden proves its strategy worked" articles competing with multiple "Sweden's strategy proven to have failed" articles. >Also, there’s a gradient of response to the virus: some people die, some people survive but suffer long term symptoms/damage and some people appear to simply go back to normal. These survivors are not distributed (by age, other comorbidities) the way fatalities are. One thing I have not yet seen on Hacker News or anywhere else is convincing evidence that such "long-term symptoms/damage" are substantially greater in number or intensity[1] than for any other respiratory disease that can occasionally kill, especially given how novel (wording intentional) SARS-CoV-19 is. [1] Except a somewhat higher percentage of fatalities than the flu, depending on whether you define death as a long-term symptom
- gumby 6y agoI didn't assert "proven to have failed" I said they are backing out of their plan. I'm sorry the only articles I could find for you are behind a paywall or from secondary sources, but here's a WSJ article on the topic https://archive.is/OGN9Q#selection-2811.75-2811.130 https://archive.is/OGN9Q#selection-2811.75-2811.130 and FT: https://archive.is/56yQu https://archive.is/56yQu Schools are closed, and the PM gave an address telling people how dangerous the virus is that was deliberately scheduled at the same time as Tegnell's regular address. I don't have hard data on the consequential tail of infection and would be interested to see it. What I commented on is the false binary characterization of "it kills old people, everyone else is fine." Even if that were true, pushing grannie out on the ice floe has rarely been an acceptable strategy and if it does become an accepted decision criterion I look forward to the many other optimizations it would unlock.