6 ms·
> So, the cost to fix would be peanuts, but it's "not a priority" But there are probably thousands of things that cost only peanuts and aren't a priority. If y
by chrisseaton 6y ago
> So, the cost to fix would be peanuts, but it's "not a priority"
But there are probably thousands of things that cost only peanuts and aren't a priority. If you fix them all they add up to not peanuts and then you don't have any money left and you didn't even fix any priority tasks!
- Naac 6y agoBut out of those thousand things only this one made the news no? Doesn't it deserve some extra priority?
- falcolas 6y agoServing the public should always be a priority for a government institution. In the case of the weather, disseminating the forecasts is just as critical as making the forecasts in the first place. These forecasts directly affect everything from air travel to crop planting/harvesting to sea travel. They are critical for our economic (and citizen's) ongoing health. And the internet, for better or worse, is the primary means of dissemination for the NOAA. Failing in this is failing at one of their greatest duties, IMO.
- yetihehe 6y agoInstead, government institutions which are funded by government, now serve government as their main client. Public, which pays government, not institutions, is not a priority. Effectively government became an entity which is not serving the public but only itself.
- Retric 6y agoThe “problem” is if NOAA directly provides data to the general public then an entire ecosystem of companies that simply gather NOAA data and pass it along to the public suddenly lose money. Those companies then try very hard to limit distribution of NOAA data by NOAA while maximizing the government spending on accurate forecasts. It’s got nothing to do with government supporting it’s self and 100% to do with legislated corruption that’s dependent on public officials playing their role.
- 2trill2spill 6y agoNOAA already provides the data to the general public, its all there, so I'm not sure about the "if" in your first sentence.
- Retric 6y agoIt’s possible to get NOAA data directly, but in terms of actual use it’s very low, because of ‘poor’ execution. That’s working as intended.
- falcolas 6y agoGiven that General Aviation uses NOAA weather data, that alone makes the NOAA data more useful than almost any other source. They also provide data to our fishing and ocean transport ships. And, it's been available to the public via the internet for at least two decades I know of at nws.noaa.gov (which now redirects to weather.gov). NOAA's data is a stupidly valuable resource, even discounting the resellers.
- 2trill2spill 6y agoYou can just go to national weather service site which uses NOAA data and it's quite human friendly[1]. Also I don't understand how you can call the raw data not very useful, when it's literally the backbone of weather forecasting in this country. Every weather forecasting app uses the raw NOAA data, its there for you to use as well[2]. The hardest part of using the raw data is the learning curve related to meteorological programing, not getting access to the data. [1]: https://forecast.weather.gov/MapClick.php?lat=40.76031000000006&lon=-111.88821999999999#.X9K8O8JME5k https://forecast.weather.gov/MapClick.php?lat=40.76031000000... [2]: https://www.ncei.noaa.gov/data/global-forecast-system/access/grid-004-0.5-degree/forecast/202012/20201208/ https://www.ncei.noaa.gov/data/global-forecast-system/access...
- Retric 6y agoBy use I am referring to people directly using NOAA or other government apps/websites to directly access it without intermediates. Other companies repacking that same data bring very little to the table. It’s the same issue where the IRS could in theory cheaply provide a user friendly tax prep software for ~1$ per taxpayer. However, tax prep software manufacturers have a massive incentive to avoid that. Further, they are going to lobby heavily for the issue which impacts themselves where most people don’t care about losing out in ~50$ per year.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- kurthr 6y agoI think you need to consider whether it is the public who should be served in the free market or well connected lobbyists who have been highly paid to corrupt the executive branch. The NWS will not serve the public with what they trivially could so that a private corporation can make (more) money filling that niche and continue supporting politicians and their friend's lifestyle. That is the crony-capitalist way and corporate first amendment rights to spend money any way they want shall not be abridged (by this Supreme Court). Stolen from a parallel thread: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2018-06-14/trump-s-pick-to-lead-weather-agency-spent-30-years-fighting-it https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2018-06-14/trump-s-p...
- jfrunyon 6y agoWe're not discussing serving the public, we're discussing serving for-profit companies who make money off of the NWS's data. Those are the only people this policy change would affect, not you or me going to the NWS website.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dismalpedigree 6y agoThis. Accuweather and weather.com have literally leeched all the data they can get from NOAA and then they resell it at a tidy profit. This change does not affect the general public but does affect the big players.
- brootstrap 6y agoI was on the call. my work uses these data and we needed to know how things were changing. Not only external users but also some internal apps n such. One guy from a GIS section talked up and was like, hey is this going to affect the maps on water.weather.gov and other sites? The head dude was like, yup it is. So even internal agencies are getting affected by it. Overall tho yes. Some large players take the data here , process it, and resell at larger value. Some might call it a value add. Accuweather is shit tho so dont ever go to them for anything
- mindslight 6y agoGreat way to drag the conversation into partisan territory of bickering over what can be obviously cut, and away from focusing on our shared problem of inappropriate penny pinching undermining services entirely!
- chrisseaton 6y agoI didn't mention any political parties though? I didn't say anything could be cut though? What are you on about?
- mindslight 6y ago>> the cost to fix would be peanuts > If you fix them all they add up to not peanuts and then you don't have any money left The initial criticism is worthwhile in its original context (0.02% of the agency's budget). By scaling it up, you took it out of that context so that it runs up against worries about the total budget, implying a shortfall even though the argument is about the same 0.02%. The obvious answer to your comment is "well then it's easy to cut a little from $ELSEWHERE", which will inevitably devolve into overt zero-sum partisan bickering.
- chrisseaton 6y agoI think you're reading things I didn't write, there.
- mindslight 6y agoNo, I was just looking a step ahead. The only thing your original comment added was an appeal to destructive penny pinching that often accompanies popular fiscal conservatism. For context I'm personally against wasting money. But kneecapping an organization by tightening its purse strings such that it can't fulfill its function is itself a larger waste of money.
- chrisseaton 6y ago
- _jal 6y agoBecause if there is one thing we know, government agencies are never captured and always have priorities well-aligned with the constituencies they serve. I do understand that the peanut gallery normally has very skewed, ignorant views of what complex agencies do. I also understand if you don't question, audit, and occasionally yell at them, they go bad and (at best) stop serving the people they're supposed to.