6 ms·
> The site is the work of a guy, "him", and "his" work. We don't have to guess and say "them" and "their" work. Assumptions are presumptuous and harmful. Every
by echelon 6y ago
> The site is the work of a guy, "him", and "his" work. We don't have to guess and say "them" and "their" work.
Assumptions are presumptuous and harmful. Everyone is a they/them until otherwise stated. These are extremely useful pronouns.
You're a they/them.
Calm down. You seem to be overly attached to regressive labels. I don't know what drives this in you, but the universe is burning and people just want to be happy. Your life is short; you're going to die and rot away. Is this really something to get worked up over?
In the future, when our descendants are all uploaded to computers or replaced by an AI overlord, people will be all sorts of genders. They won't be bound by yesterday's norms. Would you be a stuffy gender policeperson, or will you just let people be who they are?
- throwaway98797 6y ago“They” is historically understood to be plural. Some information fidelity is lost if “they” can mean multiple people and a person. Language is hard, so I understand the need for compromise. “Zee” could be used to avoid gender centric labeling while maintaining language clarity.
- moron4hire 6y agoThat is not true. Singular they has been in use as long as plural they. It has always been understood to be usable in either situation.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jeffreyrogers 6y agoI'm sure there are examples, but in common use it is understood to be plural and has been used that way in all writing for a long time.
- moron4hire 6y agoThat is not correct https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Singular_they#Usage https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Singular_they#Usage > They with a singular antecedent goes back to the Middle English of the 14th century... and has remained in common use for centuries...
- jeffreyrogers 6y ago> in common use it is understood to be plural What I said is correct. Prior to about 4-5 years ago you did not find people using they in the singular, hence "in common use".
- dragonwriter 6y ago> I’m sure there are examples, but in common use it is understood to be plural and has been used that way in all writing for a long time. It is grammatically plural, but it has been accepted for semantically singular use since long before the Victorian effort to impose Latin-inspired rules on English usage which failed to eradicate it despite intense effort. (Victorian prescriptivism did have some good effects — regularized spelling FTW — but trying to eradicate clear and useful usages like singular “they” was one of its less-well-considered, but fortunately also less-successful, efforts.)
- jeffreyrogers 6y ago> in common use it is understood to be plural Nothing in what you wrote contradicts what I stated. The man on the street thinks they is plural, and nearly all writing treats it that way. Historical examples excepted.
- pwinnski 6y agoHistorically understood to be plural by you. Actual-historically, from 1375, not so much. https://public.oed.com/blog/a-brief-history-of-singular-they/ https://public.oed.com/blog/a-brief-history-of-singular-they...
- kepler1 6y agoI'll share something with you. The level of consideration you have for people who are no more than 1% of the population is admirable. Very admirable, in comparison with the actual large problems that I'm sure you pay 0% attention to each day, and do make assumptions about. So very admirable that you go out of your way to bring this to the level of everyone having to select a pronoun in their dropdown menu because you feel morally superior for doing this. Extremely useful. I'm sure you live among people who are 50% transgendered and cannot tell the difference between an man and woman with every person you come across. Is it any wonder that most of the country feels you and such people are out of touch with the needs of the world, and vote in a backlash against you?
- echelon 6y agoYou're lashing out in anger. Calm yourself. It seems like you dislike trans folk. I'm not sure what they did to hurt you, but I suspect your fears and hate are the result of conditioning. What harm is it to use singular "they"? It avoids assumptions. It also avoids sexism. Do you want a world where all contributions are assumed to come from men? You've got a lot of fear and anger. Reflect on it. Let it go. I don't know if you're a Christian, but even if you aren't, remember that Jesus said to love one another first. It's one of the most important messages for the world. Love, not hate and fear.
- kepler1 6y agoI love how you go right ahead assuming, at the same time you preach against it. It's really respect worthy. I'm not Christian. I'm not religious. I'm not Republican. I'm not disliking trans people. I'm not afraid of any such issues. All wrong. Yet you were happy to assume all that? What I don't like is people who take on for themselves the cloak of righteous moral positioning on behalf of others, and force others to conform to their thinking because they believe they're right. Or worse, believe they're better. "They" is not singular. You know the person is a man. You want to neuter everyone's speech to fit your worldview for the benefit of a 1%. Strong opinions do not equal anger. And not everything in the world should be solved by just "can't we all get along and let people do what they feel is good". Opinions and attitudes such as you're showing are deserving of objection and being opinionated in the opposite direction.
- at_a_remove 6y ago>You're a they/them. Why on Earth are you trying to dictate someone else's pronouns?