3 ms·
> no real gains on consent, which is a big part of the regulatory effort and this specific case Consent is regulated under the GDPR and the majority of consent
by Nextgrid 6y ago
> no real gains on consent, which is a big part of the regulatory effort and this specific case
Consent is regulated under the GDPR and the majority of consent banners/popups you see today are not compliant. For example, the regulation explicitly mandates that pre-ticked checkboxes are not compliant and that it must be as easy to accept than to decline.
According to the article, this fine is for a breach of the ePrivacy rules (which is the earlier - and somewhat stupid - "cookie law") which exclusively cares about cookies as opposed to the broader goal of the GDPR. On the plus side, enforcement of ePrivacy might suggest that we'll see enforcement of the GDPR too, and that's great news.
- dalbasal 6y agoUltimately compliance is defined by precedent, and by example. Both are being established here, in this case. So, good point about the actual act their being charged under. Either way though, the concept of consent is similar in the GDPR. It is notable that GDPR makes more effort to define consent better, and implicitly deals with the fact that choice and such are important. How that translates into enforcement/compliance... I guess we'll see. I think we both agree that none of these recent legislative changes (also in the US and elsewhere) have given us much improvement on consent, so far. You just might be more optimistic than me on prospects. I think the problem is a hard one, at least within our current normative frames. A regulator has very few nearby examples to draw on, for an enforceable model of consent. They need a binary, but a broader concept of consent isn't very amenable to that.
- cromulent 6y agoThe interaction between the "cookie law" and GDPR is a bit complex, and maybe things will become clearer after a few court cases. For example, the recent clarification said: "The GDPR does not allow controllers to offer pre-ticked boxes or opt-out constructions that require an intervention from the data subject to prevent agreement (for example ‘opt-out boxes’)." But of course that applies to PII, not all cookies, and so if you have generic analytics cookies that do not result in PII then this does not apply. I think. https://edpb.europa.eu/sites/edpb/files/files/file1/edpb_guidelines_202005_consent_en.pdf https://edpb.europa.eu/sites/edpb/files/files/file1/edpb_gui...