10 ms·
There shouldn't be any private data to steal. We grant these companies patents so they can be open about their tech. If they have secret data, that really oug
by londons_explore 6y ago
There shouldn't be any private data to steal.
We grant these companies patents so they can be open about their tech.
If they have secret data, that really ought to be a reason to withdraw their patent.
- sho_hn 6y ago> There shouldn't be any private data to steal. Vaccines require the running of clinical trials during development and approval. Trial data was not stolen in this case (according to the companies), but obviously this is private "vaccine data".
- lodovic 6y agoThe article specifically states "we are unaware that any study participants have been identified through the data being accessed". The breached data concerns "confidential information about the vaccine and its mechanism of action, its efficiency, its risks & known possible side effects and any unique aspects such as handling guidelines". What strikes me is the fact that this information is confidential at all.
- willis936 6y agoPerhaps this was an NSA job.
- sho_hn 6y agoI know, this was exactly of my point: I felt that OP didn't read the article, and it didn't occur to them that "vaccine data" could also refer to personal information in their blanket dismissal. In this concrete case it wasn't the case, but that all "vaccine data" should be open is certainly privacy nonsense. Once you introduce that definition I agree.
- a1369209993 6y ago> > There shouldn't be any private data to steal. For technical information (how to make the vaccine) this means it's not private. For personal (including medical) information about clinical trial participants this means Pfizer-Biontech should not have the information in the first place.
- dpwm 6y agoI came here to say the same thing. There have also been many stories recently about bad state actors trying to gain access to research, citing only UK / US state. It is interesting to see South Korea included in the list of countries. Such stories to me do not seem to survive the slightest bit of critical thought, and yet the same stories keep getting pushed repeatedly. The only potential negative I can foresee for the public is that if there were an abundance of data available publicly, funded anti-vaxxers may be able to misrepresent them – but I still think the benefits would outweigh such downsides. In any case, public faith is rather lower than many would have hoped.
- inglor_cz 6y agoOne kind of private data that strikes me as necessary and vulnerable at the same time is private data (including medical history) of people who took part in the trials.
- joejohnson 6y agoWhich the article states very clearly was not the data stolen.
- refurb 6y agoYes, but we're discussing the grandparent comment which says "nothing should be secret".
- tertius 6y agoYes, within the context of what was stolen. "Nothing of what was stolen should be secret." was the statement referred to.
- refurb 6y agoBut we don’t know what was stolen, so it infers nothing should be secret (with the exception of personal data from the clinical trial).
- a1369209993 6y ago"Personal data from the clinical trial" should not be present in the first place. To use a more obvious example, your bank account information should in fact be secret, but that does not invalidate the claim that Pfizer-Biontech shouldn't have any private data to steal, because they should not have that data.
- refurb 6y agoThis data was stolen from the EU drug regulator. You're saying the gov't shouldn't have patient level data from clinical trials? How do they evaluate the drug?!? And Pfizer-BioNTech is running the trials and analyzing the data. Why wouldn't they have that data? Are you suggesting they try to get their drug approved without it? I'm so confused.
- cnorthwood 6y agoI don't think it's unreasonable to keep the personal details of trial participants secret, for example
- dpwm 6y agoApparently this is not what has been breached. From the article: > no BioNTech or Pfizer systems have been breached in connection with this incident and we are unaware that any study participants have been identified through the data being accessed
- idclip 6y agoI find it interesting that you argued for hiding this kind of information, while not knowing what was stolen. Yes, your argument is trivially true, how does it help us move forward?
- vntok 6y agoThe grand-parent commenter wrote "If they have secret data, that really ought to be a reason to withdraw their patent.". The parent commenter helpfully explained how such statement is trivially false, in that there is value in keeping some data secret even though patents are involved.
- idclip 6y agoI see it - there is something there. Ill read it again and inspect my own reactions to it. Thank you! I mean that
- crispyporkbites 6y agoDo they need to collect this information in the first place?
- rad_gruchalski 6y agoIs it being collected?
- ngcc_hk 6y agoAre they patented yet? Or at least could china patent in its system like those trademark in basket thing. (Seems the approach of chinese and western is a bit different. Hence if they patent not along their approach we know.) As said good luck to humanity.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- pulse7 6y agoParents cover only one part of the whole story. The rest are "business secrets" which are allowed to be secret...
- wegs 6y agoWhich is an abuse of the intent of the patent system. The deal with patents was transparency in return for a short-term monopoly. If we get one and not the other, it's a bum deal.
- eastendguy 6y agoSo just because a company has a patent on "X", say some very specific mRNA stuff, it has to disclose all its other non-patentable production secrets? That seems unreasonable.
- RugnirViking 6y agoA patent isn't "this stuff exists and it's ours now", it's protection of the process of creating it. What other production secrets are there? If a patent can't be replicated using only public information, it shouldn't be valid
- _visgean 6y agothere can be a lot of business related information e.g. what exact machines with what configuration they use to produce this vaccine.
- rfrey 6y agoIf you can’t make something without knowing the exact machines or their configuration, that info should be in the patent for it to be valid.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoAnything can be called 'business related information' EU patent office says a patent must provide enough information to be reproduceable by a competent proffeshional - that's the whole point of a patent, to be usefull after it expires. It is not there to list things the company would lile to protect. https://www.epo.org/law-practice/legal-texts/html/caselaw/2019/e/clr_i_e_2.htm https://www.epo.org/law-practice/legal-texts/html/caselaw/20...
- refurb 6y agoNo, that’s not a reasonable take at all. The patent itself should provide a clear description of the technology and enough detail to replicate it. It doesn’t require disclosure of every small detail that isn’t relevant to actually executing the technology, like say quotes from suppliers for glass vials.
- cptskippy 6y ago> We grant these companies patents so they can be open about their tech. No. Hard no. A patent is used to grant some exclusivity to the patent holder because it assumes the patented thing can be readily duplicated. The idea is that they want the patent holder to have time to profit from their idea before it can be copied and undercut. It has nothing to do with being open or sharing. If a patent is for a tool, there is no requirement that the patent cover things like how to manufacture said tool. If the patent is for a process, there's no obligation that you provided details on the exact application of the process and it's intended purpose.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoThat is absolutely wrong. See European Patent Office - key consideration is that a patent shall enable the invention to be reproduced by a competent proffeshional. If that is not the case, you can strike down the patent in court. That is the whole point of patents. https://www.epo.org/law-practice/legal-texts/html/caselaw/2019/e/clr_i_e_2.htm https://www.epo.org/law-practice/legal-texts/html/caselaw/20...
- cptskippy 6y agoIt doesn't however require you to disclose exactly how to reproduce it or how to do it cheaply or affordably. That information can be kept as a trade secret. Part of the reason for patents is that someone else could devise a method of reproducing your patent cheaper or more affordably and undercut you.
- bluGill 6y agoIn particular the tools to make the things are separately patentable. It is common to make something useful in the lab, and then a few years latter patent manufacturing tools that enable you to make it. It isn't unheard of for a competitor to find a better way to produce something than you and then you cross license each others patents so both of you can produce the thing but nobody else. (before attempting this consult a lawyer - the rules of when you can make something patented are complex)
- agilob 6y ago>We grant these companies patents so they can be open about their tech. We also have EU wide law that protects these companies from lawsuits for side effects, instead the company, a governments gets sued.
- tertius 6y agoWe have the same in the U.S. https://www.hrsa.gov/vaccine-compensation/index.html https://www.hrsa.gov/vaccine-compensation/index.html
- GuB-42 6y agoResearch data that could help others fight the pandemic should not be secret. But personal data should be. And data about business processes have no reason to be accessible. Work data can be misleading too. Imagine you are working on a software project, there is a massive bug in your code, you know it is there and you intend to work on it before release. Now, imagine a competitor, trying to do the same and trying to get some advance, he steals your code, but he doesn't know about the bug and releases his own software based on it. You don't want that to happen with a vaccine...
- LordDragonfang 6y ago>Imagine you are working on a software project, there is a massive bug in your code, you know it is there and you intend to work on it before release. If only we could design a method to openly share the source data, perhaps even with a way to track those bugs. Alas, it's totally impossible for humans to collaborate like that.
- GuB-42 6y agoYes, I know about GitHub and the like. But working in collaboration is always a hassle, you spend a lot of energy in reporting and getting people to agree. So what you usually do it to do your work locally, maybe have your own TODO list, and when you are done, you clean up your work and make a nice commit. Sometimes you can't even do that, you have to send it to an integrator who then assigns your work to a reviewer and write a test, and... lots of stuff. What you see on GitHub tends to lag significantly behind what is actually being worked on. In fact, a lot of developers tend to dislike messy histories. They take great care of squashing and rebasing so that the history looks like a nice, linear, well documented process. This is not reality, reality is "forgot to add file", "removed debug trace", "fixed merge didn't compile". Now back to the spying. Imagine you are working on an open source project, with a bug tracker, continuous integration, and all the bells and whistles of a modern collaborative platform. Because you don't want to show others the ugly truth of actual development work, if can take a few days before the thing you are working with appears on the platform, if not weeks. Now imagine a rogue actor who doesn't like to collaborate and really wants to get an edge. Instead of getting the nice, clean version from the main repository, he goes to the main developer computer and copies his workspace, and then rush to release something before the next nice commit hits the mainline. That's the idea behind such hacks: try to copy a work in progress, not understanding what went behind it, and, by limiting collaborative effort and testing, try to get something out as fast as possible.
- eloff 6y agoThat seems unreasonable in a world where not all countries respect US patents. Secrecy is a protection from having to compete with generic products made "illegally" in those countries. You can block imports of the generic into the US - but that gets harder to control in the rest of the world. And people can still import the generic for personal use as I understand it.
- saurik 6y agoThis is an argument for trying to keep something secret instead of filing for a patent, not what to do given the existence of a patent.
- eloff 6y agoParents are hardly an idealized system working properly. I don't see why you can't do both. Defense in depth. The OP's argument is a theoretical argument that's only good in an idealized world that doesn't exist.
- romwell 6y ago>I don't see why you can't do both. Because we shouldn't allow people to have their pie and eat it too, at our expense.
- Nullabillity 6y agoSure, I'll take Pfizer's meds and keep my money. Defense in depth.
- deeviant 6y agoExcept the US didn't "grant" Pfizer anything, nor made any arrangement in regards to IP. Trump only made a deal for some of the first couple batches and that's it. What should have happened, is what you are saying. But that's not how it went down and it seems, not how this world works.
- nabla9 6y agoPatents are already open information. What you argue is that there should be no trade secretes.
- nitrogen 6y agoI think what they are arguing is that you should only get one or the other -- that there should be no trade secrets required to put a patent into practice after it expires.
- nabla9 6y agoBut that's what you get. After patent is granted, it becomes public knowledge and stays public knowledge (not when it expires). Patent's are just the top of the iceberg. Lots of research and methods related to covid-19 is not patented.
- nitrogen 6y agoLots of research and methods related to covid-19 is not patented. That's the problem. Patents aren't useful to the public because they don't describe enough to make a useful product when combined with public knowledge. The monopoly granted is supposed to be in exchange for expanding the public knowledge after expiry, but if most of the knowledge is kept secret, then the patent system isn't striking the bargain it was meant to strike.
- wittyreference 6y agoYou say that as though having a patent in Country X protects you from IP theft by country Y. When the bad actors and the good-faith actors participate in the same market, and regulations protect good-faith actors only in a submarket, ... uh... of course there's secret data.
- godelski 6y agoI think this is a much more complicated topic than many are making it out to be. And this complication is why patents are weird. Like let's look at it. The argument here is that it was funded with public money so the data should be public. As a big OSS person I really like this idea. But who should the data be open to (and what data)? Germany?[0] (the funder) The EU? {North Korea,South Korea,Iran,Vietnam,China,Russia}?(the accused) The world? Public usually refers to the citizens of the country but can also colloquially mean "human." Then we have to consider money (or resources, capital, whatever you want to call it. Time and effort was spent doing this and there was a loss of resources by some party). Is it fair for company A/Country A to spend a year or research time and money and Company B/Country B to steal that and make a profit through it because they can sell it for cheaper (i.e. B stole resources from A, that A spent time producing)? Do we know about how it is being produced? Are they vetted? There's all kinds of complications here that not only include resource recuperation (i.e. ignoring the capitalism component, which we can't because you can't just burn resources (capital) indefinitely) but there are also safety concerns. Lots of companies decline to issue patents because they don't often protect their production rights. Often what happens is that the company produces a patent and 1) another company uses that knowledge to create something similar but distinct enough or 2) produces the same product in a country that does not respect the former country's patents. 1) is basically that student that copied your homework but made things unique enough that they technically weren't plagiarizing (but did they cheat?) and 2) is someone who copy pasted your assignment and turned it into a different professor. I don't think people feel great about either of these, but slightly better with 1. But you can also see a situation where the cheater turns in the assignment first and you get accused of cheating. The whole process is a mess! Patents are difficult enough when you're operating in one country but get way more complex when you introduce other countries into the situation. I do think there needs to be major patent reform and personally I'd love to live in a world where all scientific advancements are available to anyone, but I'm not sure such a situation can exist until we advance to a post scarcity world. We're all familiar with OSS here and you'll always see people saying things like "Facebook is using that person's code, they should be a good guy and kick back a few grand for the free work." That's because we don't live in a post scarcity world. But in the mean time (until we get there) let's not trivialize the situation and try to view things from the situation we're in and how to advance things towards the dream situation. [0] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-11-09/pfizer-vaccine-s-funding-came-from-berlin-not-washington https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-11-09/pfizer-va...