8 ms·
Google Chief Apologizes for A.I. Researcher’s Dismissal
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deanCommie 6y ago> Pichai said, “We need to accept responsibility for the fact that a prominent Black, female leader with immense talent left Google unhappily.” The best way to accept responsibility would be to start with accepting that she didn't leave, but was pushed out. No matter how many times people say "you can't expect to act like she did and keep her job", it doesn't change the fact that a lot of company rules have selective enforcement, and HR will always find a way to be in the right when they push you out for being a nuissance to the company.
- idclip 6y agoNot sure why ppl are downvoting you. Its as if they don't experience with on the job bullying.
- 0xy 6y agoI would immediately seek to fire any employee who gave me an unreasonable set of demands with a resignation threat attached to them. If you can't negotiate calmly in business, you simply won't last long. If you come to the negotiating table with a bazooka then it's a bad look that reflects bad on you.
- ashtonkem 6y agoRight, but that would be a firing; you even said so. Google wants to have it both ways, to be rid of her and pretend that she quit.
- 0xy 6y agoShe offered to resign if explosive conditions weren't met, and Google said we accept your resignation. I was speaking generally. If you offer to resign, you must be willing to walk away immediately. Imagine negotiating with a used car salesman, exclaiming "I'll walk away right now if you don't sell me this car for $X", they call your bluff and then you refuse to walk away. You've lost. You cannot make threats and expect no repercussions, I don't know why that is even suggested.
- ashtonkem 6y ago> If you offer to resign, you must be willing to walk away immediately. Of course. But Google has to call that bluff first. They short circuited the process of actually refusing her demands and asking for that resignation letter. If instead they found the ultimatum so offensive that they deemed her worth firing, they should say that. Pretending that she quit without declining her ultimatum and demanding her resignation reeks of bad office politics and bad crisis management. > You cannot make threats and expect no repercussions, I don't know why that is even suggested I’m not sure why you’re implying that I suggested that. I did not.
- 0xy 6y agoAccepting the resignation explicitly declines the ultimatum. Again, negotiating with a bazooka is a bad move. It's a highly emotions-driven action from someone who's more angry and upset than they are determined to enact change. The most effective negotiation involves zero explosive ultimatums. >If instead they found the ultimatum so offensive that they deemed her worth firing, they should say that Saying anything opens them up to lawsuits and social media smearing (especially from this individual, who was already in a habit of slandering her colleagues on Twitter).
- worker767424 6y ago> especially from this individual And that's why you take away their corporate email access immediately.
- throw-away_42 6y agoNo, he didn't apologize for the dismissal. Parse the sentence. The "this" in "I'm sorry for this" is not for the dismissal, but for the reaction to it: "I’ve heard the reaction to Dr. Gebru’s departure loud and clear: it seeded doubts and led some in our community to question their place at Google. I want to say how sorry I am for that, and I accept the responsibility of working to restore your trust." That is the only use of "sorry" or "apology" in the entire memo.
- ardit33 6y agoit is unfortunate, but NYT is starting to read like a tabloid newspaper...
- texasbigdata 6y agoDid we just get older or did it really degrade that much? Same for WSJ in early 2000s and arguably slightly Economist now.
- ashtonkem 6y agoThe issue with the WSJ is the editorial board and the obvious mutual contempt between them and the news side. It’s not uncommon for the editorial board to run whackadoodle stuff that ends up being ripped to pieces by the news staff. NYT in my eyes appears to be of quite low quality, but I don’t have enough history with them to figure out if this is a new trend or not.
- convery 6y agoSo, an employee sends an ultimatum to their superiors, is denied and their resignation accepted. Media creates articles claiming the employee was fired because of their race/sex and the company is pressured to apologize for accepting their resignation. Got to love identity-politics.. EDIT: Including this line from the previous NYT article as some seem to be confused: "The company responded to her email, she said, by saying it could not meet her demands and that her resignation was accepted immediately" - https://www.nytimes.com/2020/12/03/technology/google-researcher-timnit-gebru.html?action=click&module=RelatedLinks&pgtype=Article https://www.nytimes.com/2020/12/03/technology/google-researc...
- fatbird 6y agoSeveral white, male researchers at Google told stories of their own ultimatums that lead to a series of discussions with management and ultimately accommodation for them. But the black woman does the same and is fired. What's different in Gebru's case?
- ikRwS3Nb6Y 6y agoThat would of course depend entirely on what the actual ultimatums were, the leverage and value each individual commanded within google, and to a lesser extent their history with the company. The phrasing of your comment strongly implies you think her race or gender was a factor, which I think is a very odd conclusion to jump to if you don't have detailed information about all of the above. Do you?
- fatbird 6y agoI think it's a very reasonable conclusion, as do the white men who offered their stories of their own ultimatums in solidarity with her. Why would you think that it would depend entirely on the ultimatums and the circumstances of each, when we have a long history of racism and sexism, both systemic and individual; when we have a deep body of scholarship on things like unconscious bias and its effect on hiring, job decisions, promotions and punishment; when we have decades of experience successfully mitigating or eliminating the influences of sexism and racism in job actions, and seen the corresponding effects disappear? Really, we know that racism and sexism exist and have impacts even at places like Google. So when we have a case where the differences with other similar cases are the race and sex of the individual, it would be odd not to conclude that race and sex were probably strong, if not determining, factors.
- ALittleLight 6y agoAs I understand this saga, Gebru wrote a paper portraying language models and Google negatively. They asked her to change it, she refused to (assuming this), Gebru wrote an email to a wide audience with a series of unprofessional complaints and made an ultimatum to her higher-ups, the ultimatum was declined and rather than work on an end date Gebru was terminated immediately. Unless I'm missing something it hardly seems outrageous.
- fatbird 6y agoShe wasn't asked to change it, and she didn't refuse. She was summoned to a meeting where she was informed that the paper must be retracted by her, due to substantive feedback that was provided anonymously, that would not be provided to her. She ask to be given the feedback and a chance to address it so that the publication process could continue. After some discussion, she was told her manager would be allowed to read her the feedback, but she wouldn't be provided a copy; regardless, the paper must be retracted. She was not given an opportunity to edit the paper based on the feedback. This was the cause of her email to the list. Google hasn't disputed any of these details.
- ALittleLight 6y agoJeff Dean's document makes it sound like they aren't opposed to Gebru's paper in principle, but are opposed to it without what they consider missing context. "A cross functional team then reviewed the paper as part of our regular process and the authors were informed that it didn’t meet our bar for publication and were given feedback about why. It ignored too much relevant research — for example, it talked about the environmental impact of large models, but disregarded subsequent research showing much greater efficiencies. Similarly, it raised concerns about bias in language models, but didn’t take into account recent research to mitigate these issues. We acknowledge that the authors were extremely disappointed with the decision that Megan and I ultimately made, especially as they’d already submitted the paper. " And: "But the paper itself had some important gaps that prevented us from being comfortable putting Google affiliation on it. For example, it didn’t include important findings on how models can be made more efficient and actually reduce overall environmental impact, and it didn’t take into account some recent work at Google and elsewhere on mitigating bias in language models. Highlighting risks without pointing out methods for researchers and developers to understand and mitigate those risks misses the mark on helping with these problems. As always, feedback on paper drafts generally makes them stronger when they ultimately appear." I'd be surprised, having read this, if Gebru and coauthors made the requested adjustments, the paper wouldn't have been approved by Google. That's my intuition at least, maybe I'm off. https://docs.google.com/document/d/1f2kYWDXwhzYnq8ebVtuk9CqQqz7ScqxhSIxeYGrWjK0/edit?usp=drivesdk https://docs.google.com/document/d/1f2kYWDXwhzYnq8ebVtuk9CqQ...
- vfclists 6y agoIs there a right wing bias to HN? She didn't resign. She wanted to have a discussion on her difference with the company and would agree to a date of resignation that would give her working colleagues time to adjust or takeover her responsibilities or whatever if they couldn't agree. When a company arbitrarily sets the date of "resignation" without informing the party involved that is a dismissal. What are the exact reasons Google stated for her dismissal?
- monoideism 6y ago> she wanted to have a discussion on her difference with the company and would agree to a date of resignation that would give her working colleagues time to adjust or takeover her responsibilities or whatever if they couldn't agree. Unless one is an absolute moron at corporate politics, they'd realize that's a de facto resignation.
- kepler1 6y agoWhen you have a disagreement with your manager, do you broadcast it all over the company intranet with ultimatums attached? Some people are smart, but not wise.
- worker767424 6y agoHN has definitely been less sympathetic to her (or apologizing for Google) than most media outlets, but I don't see how that stance is necessarily "right wing." > What are the exact reasons Google stated for her dismissal? She sent and email saying she'd resign. > and would agree to a date of resignation that would give her working colleagues time to adjust or takeover her responsibilities or whatever if they couldn't agree. She sent an inappropriately critical email to too wide of an audience. This isn't someone you give another two weeks of email access to. I'll grant you that it's not 100% clear it's a "resignation," but in a way, it doesn't matter; neither she nor Google wanted to continue their relationship. Complain about Google all you want when you leave, but don't send an email threatening to resign and act surprised when you don't have a job any more.
- vfclists 6y ago
- kepler1 6y agoI guess one of the lessons that will be taken away, among looking-for-bias inclined people will be: "Never attribute to bad judgment and rash decision making what can be explained by race."