5 ms·
>they typically refer to things like mail-in voting as "fraud" to begin with Not "fraud." Illegal votes. In fact, there is a case brought to the Supreme Court
by hammock 6y ago
>they typically refer to things like mail-in voting as "fraud" to begin with
Not "fraud." Illegal votes. In fact, there is a case brought to the Supreme Court by Texas and 17 other states (36% of the United States) alleging this exact thing: that many mail-in votes were illegal, due to unconstitutional rule changes which allowed them to take place[1]. That's not ok to talk about on YouTube?
[1]If you don't know what I'm talking about, just say so and I'll point you to a non-partisan, levelheaded explanation of the argument.
- cortesoft 6y agoYes, this is the argument... and the courts keep rejecting it. As the rulings keep pointing out, you can't tell people they can vote one way, and then challenge it after they have already voted. It doesn't matter if it might be against some rules; the time to challenge was before people voted.
- logicslave 6y agoLook if 20 states are claiming it, its not news that you can censor. You can censor half the government
- ekianjo 6y agoThe courts keep rejecting it because they dont want to take responsibility and see the country in riots. As simple as that.
- jcranmer 6y agoCourts can't reject a case because they don't want to hear it (except for SCOTUS, although Thomas and Alito would argue they don't have that right for original jurisdiction). In order to reject a case, the case has to be lacking in merit or procedurally deficient. That so many of the cases have been rejected due to their procedural deficiencies should be in an indication of the quality of the legal teams pressing the issues. (Note that rejecting for procedural deficiencies doesn't mean that the court approves of the merits of the case, it just means that the court also doesn't want to decide the merits. Although if you piss it off hard enough, they will also go own to berate you on why your claims lack merit in addition to enumerating procedural deficiencies).
- GreenHeuristics 6y agoIf you challenge it before hand you have no damages to base a case on.
- cpdwighthertzog 6y agoI haven't heard of this argument, could you point me to an explanation?
- jcranmer 6y agoThe rough gist of the argument is that only legislatures are empowered to choose the method of selection of electors, and therefore governors (like Texas's governor) or courts (as in North Carolina) that order changes to election procedure render the entire count of the election invalid. (You'll note that the examples I cite are not states that Texas is suing, and that should give you some indication of the likelihood of success.) [Side note: that's one of the arguments. The actual brief is kind of a legally incoherent mess, so it kind of hops around from argument to argument a bit; the other main argument, which most of the amici seem to want to focus on, is that PA's Supreme Court improperly adjudicated PA law's propriety under the PA Constitution, and therefore Texas has right to settle that dispute in front of SCOTUS, despite SCOTUS dismissing an appeal alleging exactly that just yesterday.]
- mike00632 6y ago1) You should cite where the federal government has authority over state-run elections. 2) You should also explain more clearly why you think it could be rational to discount the decisions of state courts which rule on the laws passed by the state legislature on the basis that they aren't the state legislature... That is like saying the Supreme Court shouldn't have a say over how Federal laws are applied. It's their entire job. And all this is ignoring the idea that the legal system ought to represent the democratic will of the people and the institutional processes they put in place, whether it's via upholding the laws of the legislature or the vote.
- jcranmer 6y agoJust to be clear, I believe that Texas' argument here is complete and total bullshit, and I do eagerly await seeing the reply brief for an epic teardown of the arguments, as SCOTUS likely will deny the leave to file without explanation of why it is doing so.
- quadrifoliate 6y ago> Texas and 17 other states...that's not ok to talk about on YouTube? Firstly, this is a false equivalence. The kind of videos I am talking about are not ones discussing some frivolous lawsuit, they are the ones by wild-eyed zealots ranting about the Constitution that end up hatching plots to kidnap the Governor of their State [1]. The sort of videos that lead to people shooting up a pizza parlor because they believe it's the center of a Satanic organization [2]. But leaving that aside for a moment, restricting what's okay to talk about on YouTube is, by definition, YouTube's problem. They can restrict videos uploaded on the platform to be exclusively people wearing pink furry suits if they want. Senators can ask YouTube to try and stop running videos peddling conspiracy theories on their platform, because they believe YouTube (despite the large number of complaints about them) is generally speaking, a responsible and fairminded platform; and they expect that YouTube is broadly trying to do the right thing – not be political, but also crack down on unreasonable crackpot theories being peddled on its platform. Asking this of a less fair-minded source (say the vidoes on a Stormfront website) would be pointless, which is why the Senators don't do so. You will notice that the Senators aren't asking the creators of Gab to crack down on crackpot theories on their platform either. ----------------------------- [1] https://www.reuters.com/article/us-michigan-whitmer/militia-members-others-charged-in-plot-to-kidnap-michigan-governor-she-says-trump-complicit-idUSKBN26T2ZF https://www.reuters.com/article/us-michigan-whitmer/militia-... [2] https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2017/06/22/533941689/pizzagate-gunman-sentenced-to-4-years-in-prison https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2017/06/22/533941689...
- oceanplexian 6y agoI don’t really understand the argument that taking away free speech will somehow prevent acts of violence. Violence is illegal regardless of if you saw it in a YouTube video or not. As a matter of great irony to folks in the tech industry, this same argument was being used in the 1990s to ban violent video games. Of course it failed, because it was a terrible idea and was based on debunked science.
- quadrifoliate 6y ago> I don’t really understand the argument that taking away free speech will somehow prevent acts of violence. No one is taking away free speech in this case, that's where I think people are talking past each other. Isn't not allowing videos on your platform also a form of freedom of speech? The senators are simply urging YouTube to exercise their freedom of speech to run fact-checked, non-crackpot videos on their platform. Why do you want to force YouTube to carry videos of bizarre conspiracy theorists on their (private) platform? If the Senators ordered YouTube (or indeed, Fox News) to suppress specific videos, that would indeed be taking away free speech.
- adamsea 6y ago[EDIT: I choose to use strong language because it's important to speak the truth. Simplicity and clarity, combined with honesty, always are friends of truth. Sometimes you gotta say that the emperor has no clothes, and that shit does indeed stink. And this is shit that stinks.] > In fact, there is a case brought to the Supreme Court by Texas and 17 other states ... How do I put this delicately? That case is bullshit. Texas knows it, those 17 states know it, the Supreme Court knows it, and every single lawyer in the United States knows it. And now you know it. The Supreme Court will probably, like it did to the Pennsylvania Republicans, issue an order consisting of a single sentence rejecting their application: "The application for injunctive relief presented to Justice Alito and by him referred to the Court is denied." https://www.supremecourt.gov/orders/courtorders/120820zr_bq7d.pdf https://www.supremecourt.gov/orders/courtorders/120820zr_bq7...
- pstuart 6y agoIt's QAnon all the way down.
- adamsea 6y agoIndeed. I miss when it was turtles all the way down :):).
- pstuart 6y agoWhat I miss is the ability to discuss policy matters as an intellectual endeavor, rather than the tribal warfare that exists today.
- adamsea 6y agoLet’s do it - I love a good intellectual conversation! Examining what facts we have it’s very clear that the Republican Party has put forth a number of specious lawsuits with no grounds - all of which have been vehemently rejected by every court in the land - and that the goal of these lawsuits is either to overturn the legitimate election results and/or undermine people’s faith in the election. Many or most Republican politicians know the lawsuits will fail and are on board because they know they have to keep their base riled up in Georgia to win those Senate runoff elections. And also because Trump still has a vise-grip on the Republican base, so these politicians have made the calculation that they’d rather do what Trump wants (so they can win re-election) than reaffirm what is America’s most fundamental small-d democratic process: voting for our president, having our leader be elected by the people. Considering how fundamental voting is to a democracy, I don’t think it’s unreasonable to call an attempt to undermine the electoral process itself seditious. It’s not very patriotic to put the success of your own political party ahead of the good of the country. Both sides do it a lot but in this specific case it’s clearly the Republicans and it’s a pretty egregious breach of faith of our social contract. In America we expect our elected officials to respect the rules of the game, and acknowledge an electoral loss. Do you agree that these lawsuits are un-patriotic and seditious? If not, why? I look forward to your reasoned, cogent, and rational response so we can have a nice intellectual discussion about policy. Please don’t share evidence or whatnot which the courts have already examined and rejected - it doesn’t seem like a very good use of time to cover old ground, unless of course you wish to disagree with the decision of the courts. Be careful what you wish for - you just might get it! ;) ———- My point, of course, is that not all of our political conflict is blind “tribal warfare” where blame can be equally distributed between the two sides. There really are some important issues where one side is wrong, and where it’s important to fight for what’s right. That’s not to say all partisan conflict is good and necessary. But I do think the facts show that (and I don’t deny the many flaws of the Democratic Party) the Republican Party has embraced obstruction as a technique to achieve and maintain power and continues to inch closer to “If I can’t have it, well then nobody can.” And that they’ve embraced a figure who is very comfortable with undermining democracy itself and would love to become an authoritarian leader.
- mullingitover 6y ago> In fact, there is a case brought to the Supreme Court by Texas and 17 other states (36% of the United States) alleging this exact thing This is incorrect. The other states' attorneys general, partisan elected officials that they are, filed amicus briefs. They didn't join the suit and aren't speaking for their states. The actual precedent that this case would set would be nightmarish for every state. Nobody wants this, it's a stunt. This suit is going to be immediately rejected by the SC just like all the other frivolous lawsuits. The best way of predicting the future is to look at the past, and the past 50+ lawsuits have been dead on arrival.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoThen the media are speaking inaccurately. I have never heard them mention that these are amicus briefs. All they say is "joining". I'm not saying that you're wrong. I'm saying that the media do a deplorable job of reporting accurately.
- mullingitover 6y agoEven Fox News says it accurately. Headline: "Missouri, 16 other states file brief supporting Texas suit to delay presidential elector appointment" (emphasis added) An amicus brief is also known as a 'brief.' [1] https://www.foxnews.com/politics/missouri-16-other-states-file-brief-supporting-texas-suit-to-delay-presidential-elector-appointment https://www.foxnews.com/politics/missouri-16-other-states-fi...
- mike00632 6y ago"... unconstitutional..." A reminder that states are sovereign and don't run their elections according to the Federal Constitution. This whole idea that states can't determine the course of their elections because it's "unconstitutional" is farcical.
- programmarchy 6y agoIf states were sovereign, then they could secede, and we already settled that issue. The U.S. Constitution is the law of the land; see the Supremacy Clause.
- mike00632 6y agoThey are sovereign on this matter. There are no laws in the Constitution to micromanage the state elections (that's where the "Supremacy Clause" would come up). This simply isn't a matter of the US Constitution.
- beezle 6y agoYou do know of course that the governor of Texas expanded early voting by personal proclomation, right? I suppose other states which did not have early voting, or a shorter window, can now claim TX has created substantial illegal votes by similar 'equal protection' arguments. Likewise, I believe one of the states that filed amicus briefs allowed counting of ballots days longer than did PA.