5 ms·
Emulating film ought to be on the way out by now. Nobody still uses photographic film end to end. Somebody in Hollywood tried to edit physical film last year, a
by Animats 6y ago
Emulating film ought to be on the way out by now. Nobody still uses photographic film end to end. Somebody in Hollywood tried to edit physical film last year, and she had to call in favors just to get blank leader and film cement. Trying to emulate film is like making sepia-toned pictures.
The industry has been through this before. With the end of silent films. With the end of showing an orchestra if the film had music. (That's credited to Irving Thalberg). With the end of editorial geography. (That ended with Jean-Luc Godard's "Breathless" in 1960). The industry got over those, and they'll get over 24FPS and film grain.
- ancientworldnow 6y agoThere are reasons for favoring 24fps and grain even into a digital era. Studies are still ongoing on how brains interpret different frame rates and how they effect the suspension of disbelief. Clean grain dramatically increases the acutance of an image and additionally helps to prevent compression banding issues for cleaner, better looking videos (as long as delivery compression is done properly). There's basically nothing that you see on TV or in cinema that hasn't had grain added. It makes such a huge difference that oftentimes actual film grain is removed, color and vfx are done and applied, and then digital grain is put back on because the image improves so much. Even many video games add subtle grain (not the over the top grain settings) because of how it improves things. Film's natural grain is the gold standard here and it's definitely not going away.
- kedbear 6y agoMany productions do not use grain. Roger Deakins for example does not use grain on any of his digitally shot films - so everything since ‘In Time’. I do like grain personally on the right project and used in the right way. It’s another creative aesthetic tool.
- telotortium 6y agoWhat is "editorial geography"?
- Animats 6y agoThere's a nice example of this in "When the Shooting Stops, the Cutting Begins", (Rosenblum, 1986.) His example goes roughly like this: Bogart is in his apartment. His phone rings. We see a shot of the phone ringing. He walks to the phone, picks it up, and talks briefly. He opens the door of his apartment and leaves. We see a shot of him in the hall. We see a shot of him going down the front steps and getting into a car. A shot of him driving the car. A shot of him parking the car in front of an apartment building, getting out, looking up at the tall building, and grimacing. A shot of him in the lobby pushing an elevator button, getting into the elevator, and of the doors closing. A shot of the elevator indicator moving upward (a cliche of the 1930s). A shot of the elevator doors opening on an upper floor, Bogart getting out of the elevator, walking to a door, and ringing the doorbell. Lauren Bacall opens the door, and he goes inside. That's editorial geography. Nobody does that any more. Today, one would cut from answering the phone to inside the destination apartment. But at one time, a film that left out too much geography would cause the audience to lose track. See this documentary on the French New Wave, which shows how that era ended.[1] [1] https://youtu.be/0R7R0JHvvgo?t=191 https://youtu.be/0R7R0JHvvgo?t=191
- telotortium 6y agoThanks!