5 ms·
He wrote that nearly 100 years ago. With an additional century's experience, I think it's clearer that teaching media literacy just isn't enough. One reason is
by wpietri 6y ago
He wrote that nearly 100 years ago. With an additional century's experience, I think it's clearer that teaching media literacy just isn't enough.
One reason is the bullshit asymmetry principal: "The amount of energy needed to refute bullshit is an order of magnitude bigger than to produce it." Another is that liars get a lot more practice in selling their lie than people do in analyzing and refuting a particular lie. A third is that people who live on their lies usually have a much stronger incentive; if I blow $10 on a stupid purchase due to lying ads, I'm out $10, but the liar is making a living. And that's before we even get to the asymmetry in mass communication, where a liar can reach millions. Or the modern micro-targeting era, where lies can be tuned to the audience and hidden from debunkers. Or the way the whole idea of truth can be weakened by authoritarian behavior and mass disinformation.
So we really can't expect individuals to keep up on their own. As much as I love cynical skepticism, it's not enough these days.
- meekmind 6y agoRespectfully disagree. > media literacy just isn't enough How would we know? It's not really taught. As you pointed out later, it's not just "media literacy," it's "thinking for yourself," "critical thinking," "skepticism," "reasoning." Very little of that is taught because the educational institutions who would be responsible for teaching it have curriculums that cannot withstand it. Hand-waving to students that "u shuld do critical thinking" is not sufficient to actually teach critical thinking. Also our educational institutions totally ignore the distribution of intelligence in the population. The curriculum is dumbed down to the lowest common denominator which does an incredible disservice to high (or even average) intelligence individuals. > The amount of energy needed to refute bullshit is an order of magnitude bigger than to produce it. This is true, to an extent. But, that's what journalism is supposed to solve. Instead of spending 1000 hours researching some issue as an individual, have 100 journalists spend 10 hours researching it and collaborate on the reporting. Sadly, we have very little actual journalism anymore, which I'll explain next.. > people who live on their lies usually have a much stronger incentive This, I totally agree with. Journalism has failed because it was bought out by corporate interests who have a vested interest in a particular narrative. If not through advertising, but by buying the media companies directly. Further, if you give a "journalist" a choice between working for 10 hours to tell the truth or working for 1 hour to tell a lie, getting paid the same amount either way, the outcome is obvious. Moreover, declining educational standards, and especially lack of critical thinking skills, has led to a deadening of the public palette. The market is not incentivizing actual journalism because objectivity is hard, opposes too many special interests, and the public (at large) doesn't have a taste for it. The only takeaway from this ought to be obvious. We can't rely on the institutions and corporations who created this problem to solve it. Clearly they're leading us to "thought police" and censorship. I think, however, the lights should be turned on and the public at large should get a crash course in critical thinking.
- UncleMeat 6y ago> It's not really taught. It is. This is one of the major outcomes of a strong history curriculum. Interpreting sources and narratives. Every single major university offers a four year degree that is basically nothing but this sort of thing. And engineers consistently yell and scream that it isn't real education.
- meekmind 6y agoThat's a fair point, however we don't reach university until after 12 years of compulsory state-run education in the U.S. By that time, many developmental windows have been missed, a persons personality is already solidified. University is too late for these fundamentals, which IMHO ought to be taught in primary school. I think we horribly underestimate the ability of children to do this. Which I attribute to the assembly-line education that appeals to the lowest common denominator.
- rualca 6y ago> University is too late for these fundamentals, which IMHO ought to be taught in primary school. There are so many fundamentals that are skipped throughout compulsory education. Stuff like basic taxes and home economics and labour law, which is the kind of stuff we all have to endure throughout our lives. School is not designed from the point of view of the citizen. It's designed from the point of view of the elites running the nation.
- notahacker 6y agoI'd add that the UK history curriculum taught us about interpreting sources from the age of 11. Which also goes to show that teaching has its limits. (I'm not sure how much this has been eroded since 2010 by the Gove reforms aimed at teaching history as chronology)
- kortilla 6y agoIt shouldn’t take 4 years to learn those skills though. Just the fundamentals of identifying what the biases of the authors and institutions are is something that should be taught for a year in high school. It’s not complex and doesn’t require 4 years of classes, but it does require practice and it’s better to start early before you develop a bunch of political views and ideological blind spots.
- abernard1 6y ago> Or the way the whole idea of truth can be weakened by authoritarian behavior and mass disinformation. So... YouTube. YouTube is the arbiter of truth we should accept? Does that sound any less creepy to you? That a handful of people whose management is headquartered in a few zip codes in San Francisco can determine what people are allowed to talk about?
- wpietri 6y agoI don't think YouTube has to be the arbiter of truth. Or of what people are allowed to talk about. But I think they definitely should be the arbiter of what they're comfortable supporting on their platform. As you're proving right now, they are far from the only platform.
- sillysaurusx 6y agoShould twitter remove posts like this? https://twitter.com/Timcast/status/1337043496230932483 https://twitter.com/Timcast/status/1337043496230932483 "Four people who received Pfizer's vaccine developed Bell's palsy, a form of temporary facial paralysis" The trouble is, this one's a bit different than a slippery slope argument. We'll have to decide whether we want to allow fringe news at all. If YouTube announced tomorrow that they would ban opposition to the new vaccine, would that feel as comfortable?
- wpietri 6y agoI think it's a reasonable choice for a platform to label, deamplify, or even ban content that is both clearly false and clearly dangerous. Do you think that tweet is both false and dangerous?
- sillysaurusx 6y agoI think it's probably false. I don't think information is dangerous, no. Do you think people should be able to make up their own minds? Unfortunately, all of those actions you mention run contrary to that premise.
- kunfuu 6y agoHere is my heavily biased take. People need to teach analytic philosophy, scientific methodology, logical empiricism, social-psychological dynamics, journalism, jurisprudence, and perhaps a version of initiative (e.g. initiative to try doing journalistic investigation or playing an impartial judge) in middle schools for every student. I'm not sure if it is too much to ask from folks, but progress doesn't come easy anyway.
- swiley 6y agoSo we should just give up on democracy because most people are too stupid to understand it. That makes a lot of sense.
- wpietri 6y agoThat is pretty much the opposite of my point.