3 ms·
I like your project, but I think the HDR halo effect [1] in your after photos is a little too pronounced. [1] - https://www.trentsizemore.com/2013/02/23/the-ha
by Jackim 6y ago
I like your project, but I think the HDR halo effect [1] in your after photos is a little too pronounced.
[1] - https://www.trentsizemore.com/2013/02/23/the-halo-effect-bad-hdr/ https://www.trentsizemore.com/2013/02/23/the-halo-effect-bad...
- CarVac 6y agoI overcooked the samples a bit just to make the effect more noticeable. I usually edit my photos much less strongly than that. Also, the appropriate size halos vary depending on the display size. If you're viewing on a phone, the radius needs to be larger to not be noticeable. If I print them out A3+, though, the halos fade away and my brain interprets them as contrast in the original scene. Should I adjust my samples?
- mromanuk 6y agoOr you can try showing a a sample per device, maybe that work.
- CarVac 6y agoI'd really like that but I'm no web dev and it's probably challenging to do with the static site generator I'm using (Zola).
- joshspankit 6y ago“Halo a little too pronounced? Click here to see an image adjusted for your device” > Second page/popup/whatever > “I’m viewing on: iPhone, desktop, HDR, etc” > show appropriate image. Points being: Don’t complicate the view for most visitors, but let the pros know that they are right to ask.
- joshspankit 6y agoThere are ways to automatically show the right image, but the people who care typically get thrown off when “automagic” replaces choice
- Jackim 6y agoI'm viewing on my desktop. The ones that really stood out to me as having halos were https://filmulator.org/images/photos/IMG_0866-output-small.jpg https://filmulator.org/images/photos/IMG_0866-output-small.j... and https://filmulator.org/images/photos/P6220039_rCnnq8S-output-small.jpg https://filmulator.org/images/photos/P6220039_rCnnq8S-output... Not sure what the solution is. Just thought I'd add my thoughts!