7 ms·
> some impartial account of what really happened We do see students, even at the college level, claiming that the high quality academic writing they are assign
by UncleMeat 6y ago
> some impartial account of what really happened
We do see students, even at the college level, claiming that the high quality academic writing they are assigned in curricula is "liberal indoctrination". This method does not function because even the most well researched academic study of these topics can be simply rejected out of hand by students who have been fed lies about the very structure of education.
- throwaway262 6y ago"Cornell University announced this week that its faculty has voted to change the name of the English department as part of a broader campaign to eradicate “structural forms” of racism at the university. The department will now be referred to as the “department of literatures in English.”"[0] When the same people who draft the curricula are responsible for ridiculous stunts like the one above, it's hard not to be sympathetic to the students who reject them out of hand. [0] https://campusreform.org/article?id=16112 https://campusreform.org/article?id=16112
- freeone3000 6y agoAs opposed to the department of linguistics in English? Or to avoid the implication that they study the literature of and by English people? If it had been named the "department of literature in English" to begin with, would you support a name change to "The English Department"?
- mike00632 6y agoIt's weird that we have people on the right calling for the death of gay people yet you find this objectionable. If this represents the tyranny of liberal hegemony then I'll gladly take it.
- ntsplnkv2 6y agoI can't understand at all what the problem with that is. "Ridiculous stunts?" They changed the name. So what? This is your example?
- admiralspoo 6y agoPhD here. Indeed a lot of academic curricula are indoctrination and mostly useless bullshit. The Humanities are quite out of touch with reality. My advice to students is to pay lip service and keep quiet.
- yters 6y agoComp Eng PhD here. I even see bias in comp sci publications. No field is bias free.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- megablast 6y agoWhat does you having a PhD have anything to do with everything else you said??
- refurb 6y agoA PhD would likely be very familiar with academic publications.
- XorNot 6y agoA PhD would be very familiar with publications...in whatever field they studied. Which they notably omit. PhD's are not generalists.
- iandev 6y agoA PhD would imply first hand experience of academia. I don't think they're using it to signal any particular level of intelligence.
- UncleMeat 6y agoPhD here as well. My advice is to learn as much as possible from experts who study their fields for a living while you have access to them.
- rayiner 6y agoThat’s because, outside certain fields where research can be verified objectively, it very often is a liberal take on whatever is being researched. A vanishingly small number of academics have conservative, or even moderate views. In fields where you can’t objectively analyze the arguments that are being made, liberal assumptions and viewpoints get baked into the research. Even when there is a numeric component, the numbers are viewed from the perspective of liberal assumptions about causation and significance. I got into an argument the other day with a political science professor about colonization. It was completely unrecognizable to me as someone who is from a former British colony and whose father spent a lifetime working on bread and butter issues affecting the developing world, such as maternal health. (I explained the academic concept of “decolonization” to my father. He thought it was the political process of devolving governance from colonial powers to native governments. I said, no, what they mean by that now is removing colonial influences and culture from the country. My dad’s response was “why the hell would you want to do that?”)
- anigbrowl 6y agoThe answer, which is surely obvious to a person of your intellect, is that people wish to disentangle themselves from the institutions which gave rise to colonialism in the first place and have perpetuated it in indirect fashion, eg by the reification of private property and the legal infrastructure surrounding its disposition.
- screye 6y agoIt is true isn't it ? It is not indoctrination, in that it comes from a sincere place. However, it does tend to construct a story that is reviewed and conceived entirely by liberals. This is by the very nature of academic research and the people who inhabit it. Especially in non-STEM fields where truth is a very subjective matter. A clearer example is Economics, where people from certain schools of thought will actively consider what is taught at other schools as indoctrination. People can't even agree on the core axioms of their field. We are already seeing a lot of weakly researched topics being pushed around as truths, because believing otherwise does not align with the political goals of the institution.
- travisoneill1 6y agoThe problem here is that parts of college (any department that ends in "studies") are liberal indoctrination. So this is the college's job to fix before criticizing the students.