4 ms·
> Adblockers currently only work by having full access to every tab, iframe, page, etc. What happens when an adblocker is sold and the new owner secretly instal
by sneak 6y ago
> Adblockers currently only work by having full access to every tab, iframe, page, etc. What happens when an adblocker is sold and the new owner secretly installs spyware to steal all of your passwords and cookies?
Perhaps installing something (A) on Monday should not give the developer/publisher the right or ability to arbitrarily exec B on your machine on Tuesday.
No-interaction updates are the problem here. They amount to a remote code exec vulnerability, exploited just as you describe.
- jefftk 6y agoAn ad blocker that did not auto update would quickly go stale. Removing updating support for extensions would be even less popular! (Disclosure: I work for Google, speaking only for myself)
- sneak 6y agoThe logic in an ad blocker rarely needs to be updated, only the non-executable filter lists.
- jefftk 6y agoIf you have automatically updating data the extension can be an interpreter, which can be asked to do anything.
- sneak 6y agoWell, sure, but it seems like extensions that download remote code are being explicitly banned by Google per TFA. I can't imagine that they intend that to extend to even non-executable tabular data.
- zamadatix 6y agoIt's an unrealistic expectation that the user is going to do anything other than click "allow" the 273rd time you ask if the extension they installed 5 years ago should be allowed to update.
- sneak 6y agoThe only expectation that I expressed is that installing program A on Monday is not automatic consent to automatically downloading and running a different program B on Tuesday, which I think is a wholly realistic one. It seems you believe that I was indicating that the user should be presented with prompts to update, when I said no such thing.
- yonixw 6y agoPlease give your alternative to manual update, instead of leaving us hanging...
- userbinator 6y agoPrecisely. Google essentially introduced this problem themselves with silent updates --- that and perhaps the rest of the software industry that wants to turn everything into a service... The normalisation of silent change is one of the worst things to have happened to software in the last decade.