9 ms·
Turnout says far less about political views than you might think. Voter suppression is a common and effective tool used to keep a political party in power even
by Retric 6y ago
Turnout says far less about political views than you might think. Voter suppression is a common and effective tool used to keep a political party in power even as they loose popular support.
All it takes is realizing changing X rule like a deadline will help or hurt your party and then voting based on that rule. Eventually this can fail, which oddly enough tends to flip states so they can quickly go from solidly party A to solidly party B.
- abawany 6y agohttps://www.texastribune.org/2020/12/08/texas-ken-paxton-election-georgia/ https://www.texastribune.org/2020/12/08/texas-ken-paxton-ele... Having satisfactorily worked hard to make voting as difficult as possible in Texas, he wants to use the state's limited funds to sue other states that dared to improve their democracy. This is the government of Texas.
- gwright 6y agoI would find it much more interesting if you were to engage on the legal argument being made rather than this sort of perfunctory dismissal. Are you stating that as long as public officials are "daring to improve their democracy" that they are free to ignore Constitutional requirements that the legislature has plenary authority to proscribe the manor of selecting electors? Note: Setting aside the likelihood that any of the alleged unconstitutional actions resulted in a different electoral outcome, isn't it important that election law is established through the Constitutionally proscribed legislative process and not via executive and/or bureaucratic actions independent of the legislature?
- Frondo 6y agoWhat legal argument? Texas has no standing to sue Pennsylvania over what is an internal matter to Pennsylvania. Let's not pretend that this absurd lawsuit has any merit -- it's one in a long line of losing lawsuits (what are they up to, 50 out of 51 lost now?) by the current president to overturn an election result he didn't like.
- gwright 6y agoStanding might certainly a reason why Texas can't sue Pennsylvania in this case, but you've neatly avoided addressing the underlying argument that they are making that the election rules were not changed by the legislature in these states and those actions are unconstitutional. I'm interested in poking holes in that argument not avoiding it.
- Frondo 6y agoI'm not "avoiding" it -- it doesn't matter. What you're asking for is analogous to how to handle NTFS performance issues on a MacOS application.
- gwright 6y agoSetting aside standing and even setting aside any effect on this election, does it not matter for future elections that it be clear that the legislature can't be bypassed in these matters?
- Retric 6y agoThe legislature can clearly be bypassed by the courts. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harper_v._Virginia_State_Board_of_Elections https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harper_v._Virginia_State_Board... So, it’s a much more specific question you’re asking. It also had zero impact on this election, but that’s largely irrelevant to the question.
- gwright 6y agoI don't think that case is an example of the legislature being bypassed. That is an example of the legislature taking an unconstitutional action. The question in the Texas lawsuit doesn't challenge the actions of the legislature, it challenges the actions of the other officials.
- 6y ago
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- stjohnswarts 6y agoVoter supression is certainly an important point, but it seems like people have completely stopped feeling responsible for elections too. Even in Texas we had nearly 3 weeks of early voting. If you can't find a way in 3 weeks to go put in a vote I don't know how much more you can help someone. Texas democrats could have beaten Trump here if everyone would have shown up and voted rather than complaining and staying home.
- rayiner 6y agoWe just had a massive natural experiment in loosening voting laws that showed that “voter suppression” is less extensive than many people assume. Take Georgia for example. Turnout was up 20% compared to 2016. But the Black share of the electorate went down again, to the lowest levels since 2006: https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/11/17/upshot/georgia-precinct-shift-suburbs.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/11/17/upshot/georgi.... What flipped Georgia was white voters in the Atlanta collar suburbs—and 100,000 people who voted for Biden but a Republican (or not at all). And that’s exactly what you would expect from the data. Georgia is one of the few states in the country where Black voter registration rates are equal to registration rates for whites: https://www.kff.org/other/state-indicator/voting-and-voter-registration-as-a-share-of-the-voter-population-by-raceethnicity https://www.kff.org/other/state-indicator/voting-and-voter-r.... (California, by contrast, has a 12 point difference in Black-white registration rates.) In 2018, the Black voter turnout rate was actually 2 points higher than the white voter turnout rate in Georgia. It makes total sense that as you increase turnout, you’re going to see roughly the same demographics. Same thing in Texas. 87% of votes were cast by mail in ballot. Turn out was up almost 7 points compared to 2016. But Trump earned basically the same percentage of the vote as in 2016, with Biden gaining a few points from winning people who voted third party last time: https://www.texastribune.org/2020/11/04/texas-voter-turnout-democrats/ https://www.texastribune.org/2020/11/04/texas-voter-turnout-... Democrats have this idea that voter suppression is preventing more minorities from coming out (and voting Democrat). But what the data seems to suggest in Georgia and Texas is that people who want to vote are already voting. Making it easier to vote or having a high states election will increase turnout, but by dipping into a pool of lower propensity voters who don’t look all that different demographically than the people who were already voting.
- Retric 6y agoVoter suppression isn’t specifically targeted at minorities. That’s a common misconception, it’s tailored to individual states voting patterns. Overall turnout consistently favors Democrats which doesn’t win every state, but control doesn’t require every state. As to the extra voting in Texas. 2020 had an additional + 1205300 Republican votes and + 1381258 Democratic votes in a solid red state which just hit 1/2 of voting age population. That’s 46.6% Republican and 53.4% Democrat and means those extra votes very much favored Democrats. Project a 20% increase in turnout with that kind of margin and Texas is in dead even recount territory. Of course any election where Texas is that close Democrats have already won by such a margin as to make possibility flipping Texas largely irrelevant. Further, looking at these numbers it’s clear why targeted voter suppression becomes so significant.