12 ms·
Europe has some successful international projects like CERN or Airbus. Besides, what are the other options? Europe is in this strange place where collectively
by mrtksn 6y ago
Europe has some successful international projects like CERN or Airbus. Besides, what are the other options?
Europe is in this strange place where collectively account for enormous wealth and power but individually no country is a match to the big boys like USA/China when simultaneously are super unoptimised due to cultural/lingual differences.
The younger Europeans I met were all very eager to learn English, so who knows, maybe as the UK is out of the EU the English language can become the lingua franca with less resistance as it is no ones language(Well, there are the Irish but it's a small country).
At the end of the day, those large Eurpoean projects bring a lot of good. Be it political or simply keeping some talent in Europe. I am also hopeful for some competition from the UK :) Since the collapse of the USSR, finally there's a competition.
- aledalgrande 6y agoTotally agree. Want to add another European project to the list: ESA.
- tcgv 6y agoWhich, among other projects, created / operates GALILEO, the European GPS :)
- TacticalCoder 6y ago> Europe has some successful international projects like CERN or Airbus. Besides, what are the other options? If we have to go back to mentioning Airbus (1970) and CERN (1954) to find successful European projects, I think this show how big of a serious problem there is in Europe no!? P.S: a lot of the young in Europe are learning english because they want to get the f--- out the EU as soon as they can. I'm european and I'm raising my kid in a british college since years for that very reason.
- norwegianwhale 6y agoIf there ever is a promising project from europe (a.1) it bootstraps / gets venture capital (a.2) Leaves after 2 years for the US / gets acquired and the fiscal headquarter moves to Delaware (Stripe) (b) Gets absorbed by an old blue chip, like Siemens, Telefonica, and dies a slow death. (c) Becomes highly stymied by bureaucracy, and the initial momentum wanes without winning much market share (Zalando, Deliveroo, Idealista). It's called the market of lemons problem. Only the least productive projects want to have their hands tied and financed by the government.
- Apocryphon 6y agoSounds like what happens in Canada, too. One wonders if this is a global phenomenon.
- dependsontheq 6y agoUBERs total funding was 25 Billion, that might not be the best example but funding on this scale is not possible in Europe. The core limit is the market size (every EU market needs specific teams) and the funding.
- mlyle 6y agoEurope's done big multinational technical-political things many times to varying levels of success. Don't forget Gaileo, Arianespace, Airbus's parent EADS, the ESA, etc. They tend to not be super capital efficient, but the sheer amount of wealth and resources tend to make things that are priorities not completely fail. > P.S: a lot of the young in Europe are learning english because they want to get the f--- out the EU as soon as they can. I'm european and I'm raising my kid in a british college since years for that very reason. What factors make you want to get out? As an American who's spent a lot of time in both the US and Continental Europe (and elsewhere) I don't see any terrific suck.
- tristor 6y ago> What factors make you want to get out? As an American who's spent a lot of time in both the US and Continental Europe (and elsewhere) I don't see any terrific suck. At the risk of speaking out of turn, I've traveled extensively outside the US and befriended a lot of folks and had discussions on this topic with them. I would summarize my findings as such: 1. Economic Mobility: In Europe economic mobility, on average, is actually better than the US. But, for those who are educated and driven, economic mobility in the US is much much much higher. Average person may up their income by $10k/yr in PPP or more in Europe from young adulthood to adult-hood, average person in the US tends to stay flat. But driven, intelligent people with degrees in the US can double or triple their income from young adulthood to adulthood, and this simply doesn't happen in Europe. The tech industry is a major factor in this, where senior-level positions in non-FAANG companies can make upwards of $150k/yr in the US, and the PPP equivalent European salary is around half of that. 2. Lifestyle goals: In Europe, it is very hard to be successful as a young person outside of major metro areas. This is somewhat true for the US as well, and while business cultures are different in different areas, it's easier (pre-COVID) to work remotely for a US-based company vs a EU-based company, but usually requires working US timezone hours or relocating to the US. Additionally, Americans tend to lead faster paced public lives, but slower paced private lives, and the reverse tends to be the case for Europeans. Everybody has their own lifestyle preferences, and lifestyle also is a major factor in intra-EU movements as well (I have friends who moved from Belgium to Portugal for instance, due to lifestyle. Friends that moved from Germany to Spain, etc.) 3. Freedom: The US is more diverse and free in some aspects. There's a lot of nuance here, but while you obviously have a lot of history, linguistic, and food diversity in the EU, there's significant similarities in cultural expectations, especially in professional work environments once you enter the middle class. The US is a LOT more free in regards to one's behavior, lifestyle choices, and personal life when you are in the middle class, compared to Europe. This is probably more obvious in the UK than anywhere else, where class hallmarks are as direct as how you speak to someone verbally, where in the US it's possible to have a pronounced Southern accent and still be solidly middle class in a professional environment, even though that's not considered as high-brow as a West-coast accent would be. Europe is in many ways more diverse overall, but not really in the middle class and above environments. Also some people just want to be free to do whatever they want on their own property without anyone nosing in, and this is antithetical to the European communal mindset which is very often enforced legally through direct government regulation.
- mrtksn 6y agoNot at all, those are simply the biggest ones that would be recognised by Americans. Another recognisable project would be the Erasmus program or interrail, or ESA(remember the cute spacecraft philae, yep that was not NASA but ESA https://twitter.com/philae2014?lang=en https://twitter.com/philae2014?lang=en). EU has tons of projects with smaller or even larger scale, usually in areas that are not supposed to yield profit but has large impact to trade and life quality of the citizens, preserve peace and food security. Mostly boring stuff, EU is not a for profit company that will design the next iPhone, it's this organisation that does the stiff that individual countries or companies are not willing to do or simply cannot do but it needs to be done.
- norwegianwhale 6y ago> Erasmus program or interrail By which upper middle class kids get a free year of holidays abroad at the taxpayer's expense. No results expected. Finishing studies, getting a job and family formation can be postponed to early thirties. Our young generations are having so much success in the job market, housing, and family wise.
- mrtksn 6y ago>By which upper middle class kids get a free year of holidays abroad at the taxpayer's expense. No results expected. I don't know why you would say that. Me, my brother and a lot of people I know benefited from these programs and we are not even a middle class. Now we do better but back then the times were tough. Frankly, a semester abroad with Erasmus is more of partying and networking than studying but people keep these connections and the poorer people who could have never been able to afford it can actually afford it. Many times, poor people stay poor because they lack networking and perspective. Erasmus is a fantastic program, especially for the disadvantaged students, at least they know what's out there and know some people.
- zepearl 6y agoI fully agree - travelling and doing something in foreign countries together with people that come from different backgrounds & religions & nations completely demolishes prejudices, helps to learn to adapt and to respect other people and to develop the mindset needed to try to understand how other people think and behave, etc... . 25 years later I'm still using stuff that I learned during that period. I'm rarely totally in favour or against something but in this case I can see only positive things.
- iruoy 6y agoThis is BS. English proficiency is very high in The Netherlands and Scandinavia, but people there are not lining up to emigrate. According to you, who wants to leave and why? P.S. Raising your kids in a British college? As in a school in Britain?
- mrtksn 6y agoI don't know why OP is so bitter and wants to emigrate but in general, English is not about moving to another place but doing business beyond local. The Netherlands and Scandinavia accounts for the most of the European global tech output and this is not because Spaniards don't know how to code. The Dutch and people in the Scandinavian countries are so proficient in English that they do products like the Americans. Knowing English that well makes it possible to understand the global popular culture and think in global scale when doing startups.
- romanoderoma 6y ago> English is not about moving to another place but doing business beyond local. There are "only" 379 million people speaking English as a native language. But there are 1.2 billion people speaking English as a second language, which means that there are more people speaking English that do not actually speak "proper" English, than people speaking it because they were born with it. The outcome is that > About 75% of the world's 1.2 billion English speakers are non-native speakers. However, while non-native speakers often understand each other well in English, many native speakers are bad at making themselves understood by non-native speakers. > "Often you have a [room] full of people from different countries communicating in English and all understanding each other, and then suddenly the American or Brit walks into the room and nobody can understand them"
- 6510 6y agoAs a dutch subject I have to agree. When Americans talk about social security and healthcare they seem to attempt to do it (read "fail") from a purely selfish angle. What seems like a complete lack of empathy born out of a selfish culture where no one has your back is really just my linguistic shortcommerings. Jokes aside (not really) Its pretty funny if you think about it. Europe wants to build a cute union that nurtures the citizens into a bunch of weaklings while team America wants their country to be this big hungry monster that hunts you down and eats you. Clearly non of this is right but migrating from the US to the EU would seem the best experience.
- bserge 6y agoYeah, probably should've learned Mandarin then. North America doesn't look all that appealing nowadays.
- nmlnn 6y ago/s
- mschuetz 6y ago> P.S: a lot of the young in Europe are learning english because they want to get the f--- out the EU as soon as they can. This is absolutely not true. English is tought in most schools simply because it's used worldwide. Also, most of the people I know are very happy to live here, and most who may have wanted to emmigrate to the US lost any desire to do so after the four years of Trump.
- mamon 6y agoMy experience is exactly the opposite: I was eager to emigrate during Trump term in the office, despite him making it difficult. Now that Biden has won, I know that emigration should become much easier, but it also became pointless.
- jason0597 6y agoWhy is immigration to the US pointless now that Biden won?
- mamon 6y agoBecause Trump was all about "business", America's prosperity. Biden is all about things I personally don't care about, like anti-COVID measures, or fighting global warming, which will very likely destroy US economically. Emigrating to a country that's on a brink of the worst crisis in its history is indeed pointless.
- jason0597 6y agoWhy do you not care about anti-COVID measures or fighting global warming? Those are serious issues that need to be addressed, no?
- mamon 6y agoThe worst consequence of COVID will be thousands of people dying from other disease, because healthcare system focused on COVID neglected them, and the economic depression caused by lockdowns. The worst consequence of global warming will be economic depression caused by pushing expensive and ineffective, but low-carbon technologies on us. In both cases we would be better off doing nothing.
- haerra 6y agoWell this makes no sense. I mean, good luck with your decisions, but Europe is wast, and there are certainly places where someone could prosper.
- yeahforsureman 6y agoNot my experience. Away from some parts of Eastern and Southern Europe for lack of opportunities, but generally out of EU, no. And anyway, if your kid goes to college, he or she is very likely to be of legal age and have, like, opinions of their own. Yet you make it sound like you're raising cattle for yourself or something.
- filoleg 6y ago>you make it sound like you're raising cattle for yourself or something To me, it sounds more like they identified common trends and desires within young people in Europe, determined those desires to be beneficial/making sense, and are trying to give their kid the prep needed to execute on those desires in the future, in case the kid decides that this is what they want to do. Sounds pretty normal to me, I would only raise an alarm if the parent commenter was just pushing this against the child's wishes. But just giving the prep needed is not in itself wrong. Especially when it comes to something as useful as english language, which will serve the kid very well even if they decide to spend the rest of their life in EU. P.S. Yes, I wish I got more english prep when I was a kid, because doing it all in my late teens was not the most pleasant experience on earth, because at that point in life you got tons of other worries that every other teenager has, on top of worrying about english (college entrance exams/standardized testing, schoolwork, etc.).
- ddeville 6y agoNot sure that is what they meant but in some European countries (France being an example), college means middle school rather than university.
- romanoderoma 6y ago> they want to get the f--- out the EU as soon as they can. Not in the EU I was born and raised.
- gostsamo 6y agoSorry, but you are trying to speak on my behalf and I strongly disagree. I learn english for various reasons but leaving the EU is not one of them. The EU has lots of faults and I won't deny it, but so does any other place. So what? One day I might leave to retire on a caribbean island, but it won't be out of bitterness. If you don't feel the same way, be honest and don't project it on others.
- boudin 6y agoI'm european, know people from many european and non european countries, i know absolutly nobody who want to leave the eu. Young people learn english because it's taught in school, not because they're caught in nasty political bullsh*t that tries to put every nation against each other.
- rgblambda 6y ago>>the English language can become the lingua franca with less resistance as it is no ones language(Well, there are the Irish but it's a small country). Malta also has English as an official language, though again, it's an even smaller country. On the other hand, in neither Ireland or Malta is English the "first" official language.
- rorykoehler 6y agoEvery country should make English their second official language like Ireland and Malta.
- mrtksn 6y agoThat would be fantastic, like choosing English from the menu when your native language is not supported in the app.
- romanoderoma 6y agoEnglish isn't an official EU language anymore, the only country that chose it was UK. https://www.politico.eu/article/english-will-not-be-an-official-eu-language-after-brexit-senior-mep/ https://www.politico.eu/article/english-will-not-be-an-offic...
- silon42 6y agoShould use US/EU English instead.
- m000 6y agoDo you have any references of English actually being phased-out in EU? The Politico article was written just a few days after the Brexit referendum, and 4 years later I can only take it for empty sabre-rattling.
- dragonelite 6y agoEither make french or german the language of diplomacy wouldn't be the first time in history that was done.
- BostonEnginerd 6y agoEurope has actually been rather successful with IMEC, their semiconductor research organization.
- jankeymeulen 6y agoEurope? Imec was founded and is funded by the Flanders region of Belgium.
- kdkeyser 6y agoThe issue is that it hasn't translated into local production fabs. Which means that the semiconductor ecosystems in Belgium is still really small. IMEC's research mainly benefits companies like Intel, Samsung, TSMC. The only relatively local link is ASML.
- BostonEnginerd 6y agoYou're right that it hasn't translated into advanced "More Moore" logic, but Europe does have some leading technology in the "More than Moore" space - power electronics, image sensors, etc. Staying up to date on leading edge logic is crazy expensive.
- Bayart 6y ago>maybe as the UK is out of the EU the English language can become the lingua franca I hope I die before that ever happens.
- toyg 6y agoIt is already effectively thus in practical terms, sorry to disappoint you. Any time two random Europeans meet and do not speak each other’s language, the first option they’ll reach for is basic English. There are very, very few localized exceptions (some Eastern Europeans will reach for German).
- bloak 6y agoThat's not quite correct as stated. People usually try the local language first, if they can speak it at all. At that point they don't even know what each other's languages are. So two British people meeting for the first time in Germany may well start off by speaking German to each other. I've seen that happen a few times. But I've also seen a German speak bad English to someone just because they looked foreign. They were foreign, but having lived in German for a while they could speak German better than they could English, and after a while they politely pointed this out. It was a bit embarrassing. It is definitely better to try the local language first.
- rowland66 6y ago>> Besides, what are the other options? How about fund university research in related technology, reduce regulation that inhibits free enterprise, open financial markets to support capital formation, lower taxes on capital gains, enforce anti-trust regulation, and cross your fingers and hope some comes from it in 20 years. You could also spend trillions of dollars on a high tech military industrial complex. That helps also. This is not going to do it.
- neolog 6y ago> lower taxes on capital gains How does that help semiconductor development?
- deepnotderp 6y agoMore investment capital available since semi is a capital hungry industry. Don't believe me? Just ask Robert Noyce, who lobbied for this for US semiconductor revival against Japan.
- jansan 6y ago*> maybe as the UK is out of the EU the English language can become the lingua franca with less resistance as it is no ones language(Well, there are the Irish but it's a small country). I have not looked at it this way, but maybe you are right and this is the big chance for the EU. It would make the EU so much more efficient.
- akie 6y ago> ... maybe as the UK is out of the EU the English language can become the lingua franca with less resistance as it is no ones language I mean, this is never going to happen. Name one country in history that completely switched language without external pressure (invasion or colonisation).
- mrtksn 6y agoIt's not about switching languages but making a language the default when people don't have the same native language. So instead of dealing 24 languages, EU can make English the default for everything international. Local stuff will continue with the local language but all the international dealings can be conducted in English. That's pretty much the standart on the internet and the younger generations are already used to it. If a website, an app or a game doesn't support your language you simply use English and it's all good. From the admin side it'a also good, many people who are not native English speakers who want to build projects for the global audience would simply start with English as a base language and localise from there. It works fine for the most international thing we have: The Internet. Should work fine for the EU too.
- Yaggo 6y agoEU will probably never give English any kind of official status of "linqua franca", because Germany/France/Spain/Italy etc. big countries with long cultural history just won't accept it. Smaller nations are much more flexible because they always have had to. That being said, English is already unofficial common language between most Europeans. E.g. it's very common for Finns and Swedes to communicate in English, despite Swedish being one the official(!) languages in Finland (also taught in elementary school), simply because many Finns have much stronger English than Swedish skills (and Swedes speak typically more neutral (clear) English than native speakers). Actually, because English is native language only in UK, that makes it excellent lingua franca for the rest: when both parties speak it as 2nd langauge, the communication is more easily kept in the same level (i.e. not speaking too fast, using exotic words, etc). That's just how the world works nowadays, e.g. in tech English vocabulary is extremely pervasive. Even in Finnish every-day talk in tech related areas we often use direct loan words from English ("Finglish"). Personally I think the only downside of English is its irregular prononcing, i.e. relatively weak correlation between written and spoken language.
- haspok 6y ago> The younger Europeans I met were all very eager to learn English... English IS the lingua franca in Europe, right now, at this moment, no question about it. Even the in remotest parts Generation Z and younger speak and understand a little bit, it is only the older folks who still remember the EU with borders are reluctant to speack anything else other than their own language. And there are more and more people picking up a third language as they move around within the EU. English is well suited for this lingua franca thing because at the beginner-to-mid level the syntax is simple, and you can get by with a few hundred words, much better than in other languages. Also there is a common pronounciation that is different for everyone (and reflects the mother tongue of the speaker heavily), but again, people speak slowly enough that it is possible to understand what they are trying to say. Which cannot be said about the native speakers (coming from the UK, mostly), so the UK leaving us might actually improve the situation. No more awkward meetings where 20 people understand each other reasonably well, but not the single UK representative... (true story)
- dmch-1 6y agoTo be honest, the most disadvantaged are the native English speakers. Nobody understands them.
- mmc4444 6y ago> No more awkward meetings where 20 people understand each other reasonably well, but not the single UK representative... (true story) I'm confused by this. Are you saying that the native English speaker in the room was the one having difficulty understanding what the other non-native speakers were saying?
- Out_of_Characte 6y agoThis is generally true, native english speakers are usually less equipped to understand weird accents while non-native speakers are used to conversing with non-native speakers. non-native speakers are by definition bilingual which might help.
- DoingIsLearning 6y ago
- piokoch 6y agoThat's very true. Europe is in a very difficult position now. RCEP agreement has just happened (it will take 1-2 years to ratify it by all countries), but it is a huge step towards Asia economic dominance. Next, China is sponsoring actively similar agreement for African countries. Africa is a potentially huge market and has a lot of natural resources. It seems that Europe totally drop the ball here, the only thing they have done was to destabilize some of the African countries in the name of supporting democracy - this failed miserably everywhere, new rulers were equally undemocratic and often even more hostile towards Europe. The same with US, they totally gave up Africa, they could not to come up with something else than mumbling about democracy and trying to impose some post-colonial trade deals. China is playing this game much, much better and, whatever I think of them, they have actually something substantial (investments other than digging diamonds and cobalt) to offer. Europe will loose Asian and African market, India is building up its economy fast as well, so soon Europe will not have anything to sell over there too. Europe lags behind US for a long time in all aspects (education, innovation). This only means marginalization and the role of destination for cheap crap that cannot be sold on other markets. It seems that UK politicians sort of noticed that, that's why they decided to cut ties with EU without much fear (brexit without any agreement) as they count on their influence and position in Commonwealth countries, what will give them backdoor access to developing markets and be part of the global economy. Europe leaders really need to wake up. Stop concentrating on immaterial issues, push for more competitive economy, lower taxes, less regulations, development of innovative companies in a natural way, not buy being financed from some EU founds - this just does not work, as this creates companies that are good in acquiring those funds, not creating market value. Common market should be available for all EU countries, not only (still) the richest ones - "innovations" like 2014/67/UE directive are not helping - this one hit less developed EU countries - it forces companies to pay local wages for workers who are delegated to work in other country. As a result the truck driver from Poland has to earn the same money as the driver in France, Holland, Germany, depending where the truck is in the given moment of time. This makes new EU countries companies less competitive. And nobody cared that it violates EU treaties and the rules of "free movement of goods and services". Stop internal fighting with anyone who dares to have different views or elect government that EU bureaucracy does not like (Italy a few years ago, today Poland and Hungary). There are very noble ideas like reduction of CO2, this is important, but maybe Europe just can't afford being the leader in that effort if the rest of the World just does not really care? Europe need sources of clean and cheap energy. What the biggest EU economy does? Nord Stream 2, to buy gas from Russia. Is it helping? Not really. Why can't Europe start spending funds on innovations in nuclear and fusion energy reactors? I don't see any leaders that Europe used to have who could push Europe in the right direction, unfortunately. I am waiting for someone who would just say: hey, maybe moving whole "The European Parliament" every month from Brussels to Strasbourg and back does not make any sense and it costs a lot of money that can be spent better.
- redis_mlc 6y ago> Europe has some successful international projects like CERN or Airbus. Besides, what are the other options? Those are vanity money pits with colossal losses. The A380 alone lost over $50 billion. > Europe is in this strange place where collectively account for enormous wealth and power What century was that? Certainly not the 21st century.
- MrBuddyCasino 6y ago> Besides, what are the other options? 1. competitive capitalism: see US 2. competitive state-orchestrated capitalism: see China, Taiwan, Korea, Singapore Although the Chinese model doesn't seem to be too successful with regards to chip fabbing, their efforts are behind schedule.