5 ms·
> if you give your secret sauce away for free, and it gets popular enough, cloud providers will inevitably spin up competitive services using your very own code
by fsflover 6y ago
> if you give your secret sauce away for free, and it gets popular enough, cloud providers will inevitably spin up competitive services using your very own code against you.
For some reason, the author never mentioned AGPL. What's wrong with using this license if you want to defend your open-source business model?
- brandmeyer 6y agoIt doesn't help with the revenue problem, it only helps ensure that any feature additions flow back upstream.
- fsflover 6y agoAny examples where it was a problem?
- brandmeyer 6y agoThe article gave a couple of (in)famous examples...
- fsflover 6y agoI just was thinking that AGPL would defend against companies like Microsoft who avoid (A)GPL at all costs.
- hannob 6y agoAGPL doesn't allow you to say "I want AWS to pay me if they use my software". As long as AWS abides the rules of the AGPL they can use your software as much as they like and create offerings based on it.
- GordonS 6y agoIt's not only about money though, it's also about megacorps extending the code but keeping that code to themselves, not contributing back.
- brandmeyer 6y agoAGPL does help with this. An early example was when Google's search interface answered unit conversion queries using GNU Units. They fixed a bug internally and didn't flow the bug back upstream. Since they weren't distributing Units, but were only executing it as a service, their behavior was strictly conforming to the letter of the GPL. The failure to respect the spirit of the GPL was a factor in AGPL's development. AGPL code is strictly forbidden for use inside the company now, partially because they consider private modifications to open-source software to be a competitive advantage.
- wmf 6y agoThis is debated. Some people say that AWS will never touch AGPL software which accomplishes the goal of not getting AWSed while remaining OSI certified.
- chipotle_coyote 6y agoAWS specifically might not, but I can say with some certainty that cloud providers can host AGPL software. It's not impossible that Compose (the now IBM-owned cloud database hosting company) pulled in more revenue from RethinkDB than RethinkDB, Inc., did.
- wmf 6y agoYeah, it's a matter of risk. Rightly or wrongly you could get hit with a lawsuit that says "we have infected your entire control plane; open-source it or die" and every cloud provider has to weigh that for themselves.
- smichel17 6y agoTo be fair, thigh, when the cloud provider has deeper pockets than the developer of the AGPL'd software, that means something different.
- shp0ngle 6y agoCan AWS abide by the rules of AGPL though? If they don't opensource their modifications and their whole AWS system?
- joejoebags 6y agoI'm not super familiar with AGPL and how it might address this issue, but I would love to be enlightened.
- wmf 6y agoCloud providers and enterprises are afraid of AGPL being "super-viral" so they'll either pay for the non-AGPL version or not touch the software.
- rocky1138 6y agoOr follow the license and provide their changes for maintainers to merge upstream, making the original project better. Isn't that the point of GPL licenses to begin with?