5 ms·
No I don't think most regulations are good for society in aggregate, including building codes. What if we had software codes to make sure we write secure softwa
by olalonde 16y ago
No I don't think most regulations are good for society in aggregate, including building codes. What if we had software codes to make sure we write secure software, would that be a good or a bad thing?
Take this payments law for example. Its intended objectives are admirable but I don't believe it will accomplish them nor benefit consumers in the long run.
By artificially imposing a high barrier to entry (licensing fee), the consequence will be to encourage the formation of monopolies.
Furthermore, payment companies will have a lesser incentive to secure their service or build a reputation of trust since consumers will be led to believe that "all payment companies must be secure since they are all approved by the government". What was once an important competitive advantage will lose a lot of its importance.
There are probably other perverse effects I could think of but my point is that things are much more complex than they might seem.
- tptacek 16y agoIt doesn't impose a large fee. It requires a bond. The details matter.
- olalonde 16y agoYou're right but in this case, the detail doesn't really matter. The point is you need a lot of capital to enter the market. Once you are licensed, nothing prevents you from committing a fraud except for the potential risk of losing your bond. This risk could be insignificant given a large amount of money to defraud. All this law does is guarantee that from now on, only rich people are allowed to commit fraud.
- tptacek 16y agoIs the bond too small? Is that what you're arguing with that second sentence? I can't follow.
- 18pfsmt 16y agoHis point is that the bond is too large, and that's _just_ for California. In the linked quora post, it was specifically pointed out that there are 43 other states where one has to do the exact_same_thing where the bonds vary from $10k-$1M. Edit: Check out PayPal's list: https://www.paypal-media.com/licenses https://www.paypal-media.com/licenses
- tptacek 16y agoYou don't actually have to pay the $500k. A new business with no history (good or bad) might pay $25k to post a licensing bond. I don't have anything to say about the 43 other states that want bonds to conduct money transfers in them, but some of the coverage here seems a tad breathless.
- 18pfsmt 16y agotptacek: Perhaps it is breathless, but I think many of us find it interesting. States noticeably absent from Paypal's licenses: New Mexico, South Carolina, Georgia (heavy banking industry), Rhode Island, New York (heavy banking industry), and Nevada (heavy gambling). I might put together a spreadsheet this evening if I have time.
- olalonde 16y agoWhat I mean is that this law which is intended to prevent fraud does nothing of the sort. All it does is guarantee that the people who commit fraud were able to pay the bond. What's the point? If they do commit a fraud, they'll probably steal much more than the value of the bond anyways. All this regulation really does is stifle competition, I'd eliminate it altogether.
- tptacek 16y agoThe risk that the bond mitigates is not that your money transfer enterprise is a criminal conspiracy. It is that you are incompetent. The concern is that after the first or second instance in which you lose a 5-figure sum of money for a client, you'll pack up and leave town. I think we can agree that's a far more likely scenario than premeditated fraud. Incidentally: $500k is the floor of the bond value needed. It scales up to $7MM with transaction volume. Personally, I think they should uncap it altogether.
- jonknee 16y ago> All this law does is guarantee that from now on, only rich people are allowed to commit fraud. So you're fighting for the little guy to be able to commit fraud too? FWIW the rich guy is not just risking losing the bond, but also going to jail. That's the threat, the bond is just so customers can get paid.
- olalonde 16y ago> So you're fighting for the little guy to be able to commit fraud too? Absolutely. Given that this regulation doesn't help with fraud, why not at least encourage competition.
- tptacek 16y agoWhy require bonds for anything? Bonds aren't going to keep construction companies from committing fraud. They won't keep movers from making off with people's goods, or folding up shop when they get in traffic accidents. For that matter, why require millions of dollars of insurance coverage to work on infrastructure projects? It won't keep me from committing fraud, if that's my real goal.
- olalonde 16y agoI have nothing against private insurance. I have something against laws which make it mandatory. I think people should be free to decide for themselves what risk they are willing to take. For instance, the choice to do business with a relatively unknown payment service which offers low transaction fees or great customer support, at the risk of losing money.
- tptacek 16y agoI have a hard time getting too worked up about the prospect of squelching the money transfer company that can't afford 1/10th of 1 FTE to post a bond. That same company can't afford to secure their software (software security for a money transfer application is almost certainly more expensive than the cost of a 500k surety bond). Meanwhile, if you're against basically all licensing and bonding, you're naturally going to be against this one too. Personally, I think that if we're going to require bonds to move furniture, it seems sane to require a bond to move cash.
- tzs 16y ago> No I don't think most regulations are good for society in aggregate, including building codes. Nearly every large earthquake proves you wrong on building codes. Compare deaths for a given magnitude quake in areas with strong building codes vs. areas with weak or no building codes.
- olalonde 16y agoThat's not the point. Alcohol prohibition reduces alcohol related deaths. Doesn't make alcohol prohibition a good thing for society.
- tzs 16y agoAlcohol has some societal benefits. Some people find it pleasurable, it helps some people overcome anxiety in social situations, and it helps programmers cope with the horrors of programming in Java. I don't see what societal benefits structurally unsound buildings provide.