4 ms·
The medium is the message. In some domains, slow and clunky feels like gravitas and reliability. Enterprise software. Enterprise recruiting software. AWS has a
by graderjs 6y ago
The medium is the message. In some domains, slow and clunky feels like gravitas and reliability. Enterprise software. Enterprise recruiting software. AWS has a pretty slow, and clunky dashboard. AdSense is clunky. A lot of the biggest companies' flagship apps have a very bland "bureaucratic" look and feel. You may find it hard to believe, but Zuck wanted facebook to look like a government database for a long time, where you type in someone's name and see details about them. Engineers will probably scoff at these notions, because it seems to suggest that underlying their "real" engineering concerns, are implicit aesthetics they would neither say they agree with nor be aware of, but it's real. If you're deep in the medium, maybe you don't even see it as a medium anymore, and you don't realize its quirks.
- bassman9000 6y agoSlow and clunky is also unreliable, it's did it go through?, did I click on that? Is it loading, or is my connection having troubles? Is the browser again? Some of the ugliest Gov and Gov adjacent pages (e.g. tax collectors, some DMVs) are fast and prompt zero second guessing. They just work.
- graderjs 6y agoThe slow and clunky I referenced don't have "loading semantics" issues, they all show loaders, action statuses, and many indicate connectivity and save progress for multipage sagas. But you are right that slow and clunky can be unreliable, but so can slick and snappy. Tho, neither of them have to be. In some domains, slick and snappy can feel insubstantial and off-key. It's interesting that the pages you reference are "consumer" products, not enterprise, so that's inline with how I think this goes. I think basically we're talking about orthogonal kinds of slow and clunky, yours is more the engineering focus of how it works, and mine is, like I said in the parent comment, about the aesthetics and the medium in a domain.
- BadInformatics 6y agoI have never seen anyone in government or big corporate (including management and HR) put down a site for being too fast to load or react. I've seen plenty of instances where they've railed on one for being sluggish or unresponsive...certainly aesthetics are important for a subset of enterprise users (namely those who have to drink/act like they've drunk the kool-aid), but most folks aren't idiots and can definitely feel when something is objectively slow.
- graderjs 6y agoI get if you feel that aesthetics are a deliberate adoption only of those kool aid drinkers and "idiots", but that viewpoint probably just contributes to how you can't see that aesthetics and medium are a thing, that people expect but are unaware of. Because you wouldn't want to see yourself as a kool aid drinker or idiot, right. Meaning you're blind to it's effects, which I'm not saying makes you say idiot. This dynamic happens everywhere. It's similar to how people choose familiarity, over what "objectively" is better. What you said matches what I'm saying about it. People can tell when something is slow and clunky, or slick and snappy, and while they may praise, or rail, it doesn't mean they will think slick and snappy works better, or feel more comfortable using it. This is why those big softwares don't violate your implicit expectations that they are slow and clunky. Another thing is just because people complain (about their enterprise software, or country, or house, or romantic partner) does not mean they would switch. And just because they praise your slick and snappy startup enterprise app doesn't mean it will solve their problem better, doesn't mean they'll feel more comfortable using it, and doesn't mean they'll buy it.
- BadInformatics 6y agoI think my point emphasized aesthetics too much to the detriment of the main argument, so let me rephrase: aesthetics are also important if you want a of majority enterprise users to enjoy using your product (ask anyone who has had to deal with SAP). There will always be a few who love the brutalist or "power user" UI, but I think we're in agreement that visual appearance does matter. With all that out of the way, the example I _wanted_ to raise above (but neglected to, apologies) with the "kool-aid" drinkers is that corporate users are absolutely aware of how fast and responsive something is _in addition_ to how it looks. I think many folks have been in a screen share or training session where the presenter has to awkwardly wait for an application they're "selling" to load or respond to input. Is the presenter oblivious to this latency? I'd say they are even more aware given the audience, if not flustered. That was the thrust of "people are not idiots". WRT why people continue to use this software, I think you underestimate the impact of top-level purchasing/procurement and the captive enterprise audience. Those making purchasing decisions are less likely to use software after the sales demo and thus are not exposed to any UX or latency issues. Again. there is no idiocy or mal-intent here either, it's just an artifact of how bigcos operate.
- symlinkk 6y agoThis is a joke right? You really think they have someone spending all day writing while loops to slow down page load times?
- johnghanks 6y agoThis is a joke right? You really think the OP is suggesting they have someone spending all day writing while loops to slow down page load times?
- appletrotter 6y agoNo, they deprioritize performance, as a feature.
- graderjs 6y agoThis is definitely not a joke, but yours is, right. There's plenty of ways to end up with slow and clunky without "writing while loops" haha... This is how i really feel it is.
- cmckn 6y agoI don’t know if I agree with you, but I think an example of what you’re describing is the TurboTax web UI. You’re shown multiple “loading screens” where things like “We’re looking everything over!” are said to the user. The user is given the impression that some kind of heavy lifting is happening, when that probably isn’t the case. For Intuit, it’s a marketing thing. I don’t think that is GCP’s problem, though.
- runawaybottle 6y agoTurboTax is a marvel of user experience. Taxes are dreaded, and their app literally psychologically calms you down, deliberately tries to ease you. Those are people that get what problem they are solving.
- zzleeper 6y agoTurbotax created the problem they are solving. Filing taxes in other countries is much less stressful and a lot simpler.