8 ms·
Doesn't all regulation stifle innovation? If I wanted to sell a homes in a skyscraper made of papier-mâché, building codes would prevent me from doing that. Bu
by jrockway 16y ago
Doesn't all regulation stifle innovation? If I wanted to sell a homes in a skyscraper made of papier-mâché, building codes would prevent me from doing that. But that's not necessarily a bad thing: the first time someone leaves their soldering iron on while they're not using it, the building burns down and we have five hundred dead families on our hands. "Innovators" tend to think about the good aspects of their ideas rather than potential downsides, so the government has stepped in to prevent the downsides from being too bad.
In this case, the government is saying, "make any new innovative money transmission system you want, but keep $100,000 in an account so when you fuck up someone's paycheck, they can sue you and you can pay the damages you owe." Not too unreasonable.
Regulation is bad for businesses individually, but it's good for society in aggregate. Progress may be slowed, but it's still happening and happening with fewer horror stories along the way.
- potatolicious 16y agoI wouldn't go as far as to say all regulation stifles innovation. A completely unregulated market may very well stifle innovation also - i.e., when consumer trust of that market is so low as to discourage economic activity. That is a rather extreme case, though. I think the more relevant point is that all regulations have overhead - even ones that don't charge a $500K bond. This is something governments sometimes seem to forget. No matter how innocuous your regulation, every single one simply adds to the pile of overhead businesses must deal with, and every single regulation contributes towards preventing more businesses from competing in the market. The balance of regulation is a tough line to walk, to be sure.
- dpatru 16y agoAn unregulated market will spawn entities that provide the services it needs. This includes security and trust. Insurance companies, for example, are entities that people trust to protect them against loss. Rating agencies are entities that people trust to provide risk assessment. The difference between non-coercive (private) entities and government is that non-coercive entities adapt better. So, for example, if you're planning to transfer billions over many years with one bank, you'd want the bank to have all kinds of security. But if you just want a quick, cheap way to transfer 25 cents in a micro payment over the web, you probably don't care if the startup "bank" you use has a $500K bond.
- urbanjunkie 16y ago"An unregulated market will spawn entities that provide the services it needs. This includes security and trust. Insurance companies, for example, are entities that people trust to protect them against loss. Rating agencies are entities that people trust to provide risk assessment." Do you have any examples from reality where this has happened? Are insurance companies and ratings agencies really trusted agencies that would function even better in an unregulated market? I posit that with no regulation, these entities would become even more unscrupulous than they are now.
- hammock 16y agoWhy? The regulations erect great barriers to entry for would-be competitors, solidifying profits of the current market players and allowing them great latitude for slacking off and sub-par performance. We're seeing the same thing now with the money transmitters.
- randallsquared 16y agoDo you have any examples from reality where [an unregulated market spawning entities that provide trusted rating services] has happened? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Underwriters_Laboratories http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Underwriters_Laboratories http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Consumer_Reports http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Consumer_Reports
- tptacek 16y agoThe question was not whether unregulated markets spawn "trusted rating services". It's whether society could function with private rating services in lieu of regulation.
- hammock 16y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moving_the_goalposts#As_logical_fallacy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moving_the_goalposts#As_logical... Go back and read your exchange. It looks to me like he answered your question, and you're changing it now.
- Luff 16y agoRegulations can also be good for individual businesses, bad for their competitors and bad for society in aggregate.
- olalonde 16y agoNo I don't think most regulations are good for society in aggregate, including building codes. What if we had software codes to make sure we write secure software, would that be a good or a bad thing? Take this payments law for example. Its intended objectives are admirable but I don't believe it will accomplish them nor benefit consumers in the long run. By artificially imposing a high barrier to entry (licensing fee), the consequence will be to encourage the formation of monopolies. Furthermore, payment companies will have a lesser incentive to secure their service or build a reputation of trust since consumers will be led to believe that "all payment companies must be secure since they are all approved by the government". What was once an important competitive advantage will lose a lot of its importance. There are probably other perverse effects I could think of but my point is that things are much more complex than they might seem.
- tptacek 16y agoIt doesn't impose a large fee. It requires a bond. The details matter.
- olalonde 16y agoYou're right but in this case, the detail doesn't really matter. The point is you need a lot of capital to enter the market. Once you are licensed, nothing prevents you from committing a fraud except for the potential risk of losing your bond. This risk could be insignificant given a large amount of money to defraud. All this law does is guarantee that from now on, only rich people are allowed to commit fraud.
- tptacek 16y agoIs the bond too small? Is that what you're arguing with that second sentence? I can't follow.
- 18pfsmt 16y agoHis point is that the bond is too large, and that's _just_ for California. In the linked quora post, it was specifically pointed out that there are 43 other states where one has to do the exact_same_thing where the bonds vary from $10k-$1M. Edit: Check out PayPal's list: https://www.paypal-media.com/licenses https://www.paypal-media.com/licenses
- dpatru 16y agoGovernment regulation is in just about every case either not needed at all or better provided through non-coercive institutions. Since government innovates more slowly than private industries, government regulation tends to become outdated, going from common-sense prudence to arbitrary burden on innovation. For example, right now the Mississippi River in the US is flooding, destroying many homes. This is a huge loss partly because homes are very expensive. Maybe it would make sense to have some housing constructed of paper-mâché, not try so hard to resist disaster, but instead concentrate on making it cheap to rebuild. Government building codes prevent this kind of innovation. Regulation reflects a lack of creativity. It says, "There is no other way to do this." But maybe there is another way and the politicians just can't think of it. They shouldn't be allowed to limit other, more enlightened people. The above assumes that regulations are honestly designed to promote the public good, a dubious assumption. Often I suspect that regulation is designed to protect influential but inefficient businesses against competition.
- Retric 16y agoThat's an interesting thesis, but can you name one good building material that you can't actually use to build a house? People talk about regulation in the US like it's hindering any form of innovation, but there is surprisingly little terrible regulation that's actually enforced. Which is not to say you can't point to regulation that harms individuals but rather it's much harder to find things that harm society over the long term. PS: Not to side track to situation; we are talking about building materials and you can use a wide range of things including straw and dirt in the US so what's missing?
- dpatru 16y ago> can you name one good building material that you can't actually use to build a house? http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PKH0qoaXR88 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PKH0qoaXR88 Discusses how building codes hinder new and "natural" building methods. In particular, the speaker mentions that older codes have failed to keep up with better techniques for strawbale building. The deeper issue is not whether new materials can be used to meet code requirements, but whether new ideas of what constitutes a safe dwelling are allowed. Building codes are based on assumptions about what a dwelling should be like. For example, the floor should be relatively stiff. If a floor is too bouncy, it won't meet code even if it's strong enough to support the weight. Walls can't be too flimsy. The idea of a house that just safely collapses in a windstorm or floats away in a flood is, I suspect, outside of most building codes' conception of a safe building. The code focuses on the idea of a strong, permanent structure that will resist nature's forces. If houses were plants, the code would only recognize big trees. However, there are also grasses, which much cheaper to produce and also resistant to nature's forces in their own way (they bend). Yet building codes don't recognize structures that are inspired by grasses, only big immovable trees. I don't know if grass-like houses are a good idea or not, but I'm sure that if we expand our thinking we can come up with better shelters. The problem is that it's hard to innovate and government regulation only tends to make it harder.
- Duff 16y agoThis is true -- the hardcore capitalist would argue that the plaster industry has been hamstrung by the quaint requirements from building code to use wood, steel and concrete in construction. There's a give an take here... the government has a perceived duty to protect the citizenry against bad actors, that that introduces a bias against sudden change aka "innovation". "Innovation" isn't always good -- just like to some people, certain "freedom fighters" are "insurgents". On the other hand, there are entrenched business interests like Western Union (and payday lenders in "red" states) who use their influence to keep the status quo around, even if it hurts consumers. (ie. the poor and ignorant who spend $10 to send $100 to someone)
- hessenwolf 16y agoI think stifles competition is more concerning than stifling innovation per se.
- tptacek 16y agoThe money-moving startup that can't cough up $25k to post a bond isn't scaring PayPal or Western Union.
- daniel_solano 16y ago> Regulation is bad for businesses individually, but it's good for society in aggregate. Progress may be slowed, but it's still happening and happening with fewer horror stories along the way. This is not necessarily the case. Often times, regulation is put in place to address some high-profile case, but ignores the consequences of the regulation. Currently, infants less than two years of age can fly in an airplane without a separate ticket. Years ago, after some instances where such children were injured/killed in accidents, there was talk of forcing parents to buy separate tickets for infants and require them to use an approved child seat. However, had this regulation gone into effect, the extra cost of flying would have forced many families to drive instead of fly, resulting in a greater amount of injuries/deaths.
- lhnn 16y agoPeople should have full information.. I should know if the building I move into is made from plaster of paris. However, if I still want to move into it... I shouldn't be passing on my genes.
- VladRussian 16y ago>Doesn't all regulation stifle innovation? there are regulations and there are regulations. >"make any new innovative money transmission system you want, but keep $100,000 in an account so when you fuck up someone's paycheck, just for example, a reasonable regulation would just limit the per-transaction(or per-month per-person, etc, ...) amount to, lets say, $100 for unlicensed/unbonded companies. On the other side, the regulation that have the same $500K bond for any company is just very favorable for big established players. The $500K is nothing for AMEX or PayPal, and provides virtually no coverage for the risks these companies presents to consumers. Ie. if any of these companies fucks up the paychecks in their system, the $500K would be just a drop in the bucket. Even current banking regulation is designed way much better - basically it forces to keep reserves as percentage of the liability amount.
- vacri 16y agoNope. Sometimes regulation spurs innovation, forcing businesses to go from "business as usual" to "how do we deal with this?". Air pollution regulations in California helped drive a lot of innovation around cleaning up car exhausts, for example. Without that restriction, movement in that area would have been very slow.