4 ms·
Yes, yes we are at an inflection point. But maybe not the kind you are thinking of. There will never be a commercial tokamak power plant. There has never, at a
by ncmncm 6y ago
Yes, yes we are at an inflection point. But maybe not the kind you are thinking of.
There will never be a commercial tokamak power plant. There has never, at any time, been any reasonable expectation of getting practical, commercial power from magnetic-confinement hot-neutron fusion.
Renewables, with practical energy storage, will always be much, much cheaper than fusion could ever have been, even if it could be made into a workable idea. Any practical fusion plant would have to absolutely huge -- an order of magnitude bigger than the biggest fission plant. Then, it would destroy its most expensive parts with neutron flux in short order. To continue using it, it would have be be rebuilt, frequently, and at even more ruinous expense, using robots.
"Break-even" is nowhere near enough to get practical power out, because the energy extraction process must be so inefficient, with two stages of heat exchange before you get a working fluid you can run through your turbine.
Tokamak fusion research is, first, foremost, and always, a jobs program to maintain a population of high-neutron-flux physicists as a population to draw upon for weapons work. Actual useful power has never been the point, or any sort of practical goal.
Thus, the burgeoning hype is meant to counter the dawning realization that the whole program always was, still is, and can only ever be a shuck. They need enough billions poured into the project to make it politically self-sustaining, where no amount of failure can ever threaten its funding, because so much has already been sunk that it would be too embarrassing to admit failure.
As it is, to ever actually break even, all the fusion plants that could be built would have to operate for decades just to pay back all the money that has already been sunk, without any commercial construction, before even starting to pay back any of the actual (huge) construction costs. But the only way to keep them operating would be via enormous public subsidies, because they could never compete on a level field with solar and wind. So, the longer they were operated, the deeper in the hole they would get.
- willis936 6y ago>”Break-even" is nowhere near enough to get practical power out, because the energy extraction process must be so inefficient, with two stages of heat exchange before you get a working fluid you can run through your turbine. Correction: break-even is most of the way to a working plant. A “burning fusion plasma” is one that self heats. The plant requires very little power when the plasma is supplying most of its own heating. Keep the confining coils cool, keep the control systems (correction coils and heaters) running, and watch as the heat comes in. Q = 1 is the balance point. The distance (in terms of lawson criterion) between Q = 0.5 and 1 is much larger than Q = 1 and infinity, Also, two stages of heat exchange are not needed and not a killer for power generation regardless. A liquid lithium wall blanket operates as tritium breeder and coolant. Run the lithium through a heat exchanger to boil water. Watch as the turbine spins. Very similar to PWRs.
- joncrane 6y agoLiquid lithium wall blanket? I've heard the use of Lithium as a tritium breeder (which is important, assuming we're committed to duterium-tritium fusion), but never as a liquid. it makes sense though because in that case you don't have to completely disassemble the tokamak and replace the neutron blanket every few years(?). But again the technology to completely coat the inside of the tokamak in an even layer of liquid lithium has got to be daunting. What goes between the lithium and the plasma?
- willis936 6y agoBeryllium coated tungsten and a copper-tungsten weave. This is still a hot area of research. It will be part of the research done at ITER and DTT (Divertor Tokamak Test facility).
- pfdietz 6y agoThe Achilles Heel of fusion is low volumetric power density. This is because all the energy has to go through the first wall, which has limited area compared to the surfaces of fuel pins in a fission reactor. So, there's been effort to try to maximize the power/area at the first wall. One part of that is the power that directly strikes the surface (ions, electrons, photons). The capacity to carry away this heat is limited by the strength of the wall material and its thermal conductivity, a fact that was pointed out by Pfirsch and Schmitter in the 1980s. https://pure.mpg.de/rest/items/item_2131865_1/component/file_2131864/content https://pure.mpg.de/rest/items/item_2131865_1/component/file... (see section 4.1.1) One could raise this limit by doing away with a solid wall (with its limits on thermal conductivity and stress) and instead using a liquid wall. This would also address erosion of the wall by sputtering, and help reduce damage from plasma disruptions (which may well otherwise be a showstopper for tokamaks.)
- lambdatronics 6y ago>There has never, at any time, been any reasonable expectation of getting practical, commercial power from magnetic-confinement hot-neutron fusion. Not true. The existence of privately-funded fusion efforts implies that some people think there is a reasonable expectation, and are willing to put money behind it. This costing study suggests that $2-6/W could be achievable for some fusion concepts[0]. Using some rough calculations, that would translate to $20-60/(MW*hr), which is competitive. >Any practical fusion plant would have to absolutely huge -- an order of magnitude bigger than the biggest fission plant. Not necessarily. Fission power plans with low power density have been operated, and may even be desirable from a safety standpoint. The current crop of small modular reactors for fission seems to target power densities in the range of 1-10MW/m^3, rather than the 50-100 MW/m^3 of PWR reactors. This suggests that reduced power density may pay off in terms of reducing the costs associated with risk mitigation (highly redundant systems, large containment structures, etc). Fusion reactors could probably get to the 1-10MW/m^3 range. > "Break-even" is nowhere near enough to get practical power out Yes, there's a distinction between 'scientific breakeven' of gain > 1, and 'engineering breakeven' of gain > 10 (ish) which is necessary to have net power output. But we gotta crawl before we can run. It's an important milestone along the way. >Tokamak fusion research is, first, foremost, and always, a jobs program to maintain a population of high-neutron-flux physicists Not really -- the high-energy-density plasma physics research (which is not tokamak-related at all) is more relevant in terms of producing people with the skills to work on weapons. > They need enough billions poured into the project to make it politically self-sustaining, where no amount of failure can ever threaten its funding, because so much has already been sunk that it would be too embarrassing to admit failure. I'll admit that I see aspects of this, particularly with the failure of NSTX-U & politcally-motivated decision to repair it. However, what I mostly see with the DOE has been trying to get the most of the 'sunk costs' by slowly ramping down the program (ie, not investing in new devices to replace old ones that are shuttered). I suspect that Synakowski's reasoning was: "if a breakthrough happens somewhere around the world, it's worth having a skeleton program in the US that can be ramped up to take advantage of it at that time." Now that Van Dam has taken over, I think we may be seeing more optimism & willingness to invest, particularly if that means partnering with industry (which is trending in Washington). [0]https://woodruffscientific.com/pdf/ARPAE_Costing_Report_2017.pdf https://woodruffscientific.com/pdf/ARPAE_Costing_Report_2017...