3 ms·
Development of programming languages by corporations is not something I object but, all of the stuff told about Oracle here is correct. They're not a nice enti
by bayindirh 6y ago
Development of programming languages by corporations is not something I object but, all of the stuff told about Oracle here is correct.
They're not a nice entity unless you pay money to them and they're greedy. They always want more. Also, their hardware can fail in strange ways and they'd shrug it off.
I've met with some nice people who migrated from Sun but they all say that the terms they work are draconian.
I like Java too but, developing a nice language doesn't make Oracle good. Don't get distracted [0].
> I guess the "community" would love to keep using Java frozen in version 6.
Python doesn't stop. C++ doesn't drop. Even brainfuck doesn't stop. It'd have prevailed. OpenJDK is one fruit of the project. After removing patent encumbered image processing stuff, OpenJDK just took off. Yes, it's still part of Oracle in a sense but, OracleJDK is compiled from OpenJDK, not vice versa. Again, don't get distracted [0].
[0]: https://calebhearth.com/talks/dont-get-distracted https://calebhearth.com/talks/dont-get-distracted
- pjmlp 6y agoHere some news for you, check the names of the companies that put money on the table for Python and C++. IBM, Microsoft, Google, Apple, Oracle, Amazon, Sony, Nintendo So much better.
- bayindirh 6y agoHowever, the governing bodies of these programming languages are independent from the companies themselves, which is different than Java's position. These companies employ people who contribute to these programming languages. So the model is somewhat different. I'm not that oblivious about the real/programming world.
- pjmlp 6y agoIt is naïve to think that the employees of the companies aren't driving their employers agenda, regardless how "independent" those governing bodies are.
- bayindirh 6y agoOf course but, there are sub-committees which melt all the agendas into a single pot and create solutions which makes everyone happy. Also some of these languages have or had BDFLs. Oracle's governance is different from this. C++ is an ISO committee. Python has a lot of working groups, etc. Java is much more centralized when you compare with others.
- pjmlp 6y agoNope, IBM, Azul, Amazon, Red-Hat, Alibaba, Twitter, Microsoft also seat at the Java table. Should I also start listing the dark sides of each company that seats at ISO C and ISO C++ table? Python working groups also need money from those corporations, and Python is yet to provide the performance levels of Java, so much for free beer development.
- bayindirh 6y ago> Nope, IBM, Azul, Amazon, Red-Hat, Alibaba, Twitter, Microsoft also seat at the Java table. I know Java has stakeholders but, what I'm trying to say is the table is at Oracle's HQ, not somewhere else. > Should I also start listing the dark sides of each company that seats at ISO C and ISO C++ table? A primer would be nice, actually. > Python working groups also need money from those corporations, and Python is yet to provide the performance levels of Java, so much for free beer development. I've never alleged that Python takes no money from corporations and, Python doesn't aim the performance of Java. Their byte-code even doesn't get optimized. Instead Python prefers native libraries for performance. SciPy, NumPy, PyTorch and others obtain native performance on any system they run and, it's enough for Python. No need to move the goalposts and compare apples to oranges. Python is never meant to replace Java. Java is not meant to replace system programming languages like C/C++. You may like Java and it might help you to pay the bills but, pushing other languages around just because they don't fill your needs from your point of view is not the correct stance.
- pjmlp 6y ago> A primer would be nice, actually. Microsoft, the evil company over here, that keeps being compared to Oracle. Several C++20 features like Modules and co-routines were driven by their VC++ implementations. Apple, the company hated over here by bringing the end of open platforms, without it LLVM and clang wouldn't ever exist. Google, the spying company and forking Linux with Android, the second major clang and llvm contributor. IBM and Red-Hat, with their own Linux agenda pushing stuff like systemd hated over here, major GCC contributors. You are missing the whole point with Java, it isn't about Java, rather all mainstream languages just like Java only move forward with dirty money (from HN point of view), but hey it is cool to hate Oracle. Hint they are one of the first enterprise contributors to the Linux kernel and have been ever since. Do you also feel like removing Oracle contributions from the Linux kernel?