3 ms·
> That is the basis for Roe vs Wade, and so there's been a 40 year-long struggle by conservative lawyers that threatens this right. It takes a pretty creative
by dehrmann 6y ago
> That is the basis for Roe vs Wade, and so there's been a 40 year-long struggle by conservative lawyers that threatens this right.
It takes a pretty creative reading of the constitution to infer a right to privacy, then infer that that grants the right to an abortion.
One of the criticisms of Roe is that states were legalizing abortion on their own already, so doing it through the court angered people more than if it had happened in each state, and it's build on shaky constitutional underpinning, so it's not necessarily a robust decision.
- humanrebar 6y agoAlso note that constitutional amendments basically dropped off at that point as the legislature abrogated responsibility of protecting natural rights in favor of blaming others, especially the court system. Why hasn't a right to privacy amendment been discussed at all? Or even a Privacy Rights Act? Those would clarify things too.
- rayiner 6y agoBecause progressives (and I mean that in a negative way) don’t want to spend political capital on legislation when they can get courts to do that work for free. I suspect that approach will have to change with the current composition of the Supreme Court.
- sagarm 6y agoActually it's because the structure of the US Constitution makes it so rural types with an decidedly authoritarian bent have veto power over any amendments.
- humanrebar 6y agoRural voters are actually sympathetic to privacy concerns, at least on some issues like fun registries and healthcare records. Note that the constitution gives any 25% of the country "veto power" as far as amendments go. Folks are, yes, going to actually have to find privacy laws and amendments that significantly benefit almost everyone. And actually convince them of that.