4 ms·
They want companies that operate like banks, such as PayPal, to be licensed. I'm not sure I see the downside. PayPal has a shocking record of abusing it's custo
by stephenr 16y ago
They want companies that operate like banks, such as PayPal, to be licensed. I'm not sure I see the downside. PayPal has a shocking record of abusing it's customers, and it can only do so because it isn't bound by the same laws as banks are.
Personally, I think if you rely on PayPal/etc for your business, you're asking to get financially raped.
- thinkcomp 16y agoIf they wanted companies to be licensed they could just require a license. Instead they require a license and a bond worth millions of dollars in some cases, nominally to protect consumers. Yet if you have a million consumers in a state and a $1,000,000 bond, that means that if the company defaults, each consumer gets back a dollar. This doesn't sound like consumer protection to me. It sounds like an artificial barrier to entry. Also, PayPal has had licenses in all states that require them since its IPO, and clearly there's no connection between this issue and customer service.
- pyre 16y agoWell, there is a (flawed) line of reasoning that says that if you can come up with $1M then you must be more trustworthy than someone that can't.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- zackattack 16y agoI don't think it's that flawed. Would you elaborate?
- pyre 16y agoTrustworthiness is not tied to money, the ability to make large sums of money, or the ability to convince others to loan you money/invest in you.
- tapp 16y agoDepends on context; in some cases it absolutely is. Courts often "trust" people to go free temporarily if they can post bail pending trial. Lenders will "trust" you with their money in the form of a loan if you can post collateral.
- jbooth 16y agoYeah, but "ability to pay a court-ordered settlement" correlates pretty highly with having some cash reserves.
- hessenwolf 16y agoYes... but you don't usually have 1 million customers and owe them all money at once. That's just daft.
- MichaelGG 16y agoAnyone that has a balance in PayPal is owed money by PayPal. So, any account that does more than just send out funds to other accounts (that is, purchaser-only accounts) is owed money. Same for a bank. Any customer with an account that's greater than zero is owed money by the bank. It's not a stretch at all to have a million customers owed money.
- hessenwolf 16y agoMy apologies. The excess over your reserve per customer is unlikely to equal the account value per customer. Wait, are paypal under the auspices of the financial regulator? Who approves their reserving methodology? My spaghetti monster, do they even have to hold a reserve, or can they just spend all your money on the derivatives market?
- eropple 16y agoSounds to me like the bond needs to be a couple tens of millions, then. If you want to get into banking, you had better have the chops to be able to treat your customers correctly. It's not a hard concept.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- bluedanieru 16y agoI would agree, but the price is steep for no reason other than apparently to keep new players out, and there isn't any indication that the license, if acquired by e.g. Paypal, would do anything to curtail Paypal's abuses (they are a shitty company I agree).
- 18pfsmt 16y agoThis is the financial services industry cranking down regulations to prevent competition as the coming onslaught of digital payments is about to take place. This is nothing but downside as it relates to innovation in the payments space. These companies like their business models and don't care for it to be disrupted. They love regulations at this point.
- SwellJoe 16y agoThis won't affect PayPal in any way. They have plenty of money to cover the licenses and bonds and whatever else. They're part of the status quo and are not considered a threat by Visa/Mastercard in any way, shape, or form. In fact, PayPal is one of their best customers. If you have a bone to pick with PayPal, you ought to be wishing for more competition, not supporting barriers to entry for their competitors.
- ataggart 16y ago>PayPal has a shocking record of abusing it's customers, and it can only do so because it isn't bound by the same laws as banks are. Some might argue that they can only continue to do so due to a lack of competition, competition which is stifled by the very legislation ostensibly aimed at helping consumers.