3 ms·
Anyone who thinks that Texas has a shot of winning is either high or knows nothing of law. The basis of the case is that PA, GA, WI, and MI erred in enacting u
by jcranmer 6y ago
Anyone who thinks that Texas has a shot of winning is either high or knows nothing of law.
The basis of the case is that PA, GA, WI, and MI erred in enacting unconstitutional election measures, and therefore their election results should be annulled. And this must fail for several reasons.
First, Texas doesn't have standing to sue. Texas isn't injured by Pennsylvania's laws. Texas argues its standing on the basis of--wait for it--it makes its electoral votes meaningless. However, the electoral college has a fixed number of votes, so Texas can't even make a "vote dilution" basis for its votes, which is how the usual basis for standing. Therefore, the manner of which any other state chooses its votes literally has no effect on Texas's vote, although this would theoretically change if Texas adopted the National Popular Vote Compact.
Second, jurisdiction. These are challenges of other states' laws, other states' practices, and sometimes against other states' constitutions (the claim against PA in particular for the latter). The natural forum for this would obviously be the relevant state courts, although states can't sue each other in state courts usually--which brings back to standing, as Texas not having the ability to sue for these claims strongly suggests that Texas doesn't have standing in the first place.
Third, these claims have already been litigated, and already lost, and sometimes those losses have been repeatedly reaffirmed. That horse is well and truly dead, so stop beating it.
Fourth, election procedure claims that arise after the election are strongly disfavored. You usually have to justify why you couldn't bring the claim before the election, and waiting a full month after the election to bring the case does not look good (of course, see point #3 for why Texas brought the case).
Fifth, for SCOTUS original jurisdiction claims specifically, SCOTUS really doesn't like original jurisdiction. So states really need to show why they couldn't bring the claim up in other forums. Such as objecting to electors in the House, which is how the Constitution explains it is supposed to be done. (Of course, there is a law that says that votes certified by a specific date will not be questioned by the House).
Finally, relief. It's established in SCOTUS precedent that, even in election procedure claims arising after the election, the votes that are validly cast under the procedure are still to be counted. Asking the state legislatures to select their electoral slates as relief is not only literally unprecedented, but it is the exact opposite of what precedent specifies for relief.
This is the stupidest of the election cases I've seen so far, and I thought the legislator arguing that he couldn't reasonably be expected to know the law was pretty bad.
- deathanatos 6y ago(IANAL) > These are challenges of other states' laws > the votes that are validly cast under the procedure are still to be counted. The argument, as I interpret it, is that these votes were not validly cast, because they were not cast under the procedure established by the respective legislatures. That is, that the laws of the respective states were not followed; from the complaint: > Those changes are inconsistent with relevant state laws and were made by non-legislative entities, without any consent by the state legislatures. Now, I don't know if that's true, since I don't know the laws of the various states involved, and in my skimming of the complaint, I didn't see where the complaint actually listed how the elections of the various states differed from their established law. That said… on the whole I agree with you, particularly on standing.
- jcranmer 6y agoIt's about whether or not they were cast in a good-faith understanding of the law, as promulgated by official electoral authorities. So if the electoral commission says that by doing such-and-such, you can cast a vote--even if it erred in doing so--anyone who cast a vote in such a manner should still have its vote counted. In the NC (I think) case where it was argued that the lifting of the ballot signature requirement was improper, which was eventually upheld by the court, the court still held that the state must count all votes that didn't have the ballot signature so long as they had been cast before the court's ruling.
- whiddershins 6y agoCan you explain your qualifications to help me contextualize this opinion and compare to say, Ron Coleman?
- jcranmer 6y agoI am an individual who has been following SCOTUS cases for some time; most of my information is roughly tertiary source quality, in that I'm gathering it from people who are reading and summarizing the legal arguments (I highly recommend scotusblog in this respect). That said, I do actually read the briefs and opinions myself in interesting cases--such as Google v Oracle, or the election related Kelly v PA and now TX v PA. I don't know who Ron Coleman is, but doing a brief internet search, I would say that you should trust my judgement more only in the regards that I actually give explanations behind my beliefs that can be compared with other explanations to judge if I'm accurately representing the state of affairs, and to decide for yourself which explanation is more persuasive.