3 ms·
An observation about SCOTUS (not) taking state-versus-state cases: > 5. One of the factors the Justices look to is whether the issues in the case can be resolv
by throw0101a 6y ago
An observation about SCOTUS (not) taking state-versus-state cases:
> 5. One of the factors the Justices look to is whether the issues in the case can be resolved in other cases in the lower courts, even if not between the same parties. Thus, the Court usually denies leave unless it's a uniquely state-state dispute (again, like borders/water).
> 6. Among lots of other things, that's almost certainly fatal to this crazy new Texas suit. As we've seen, these claims are already being brought in private suits in each of those states. Texas offers no explanation for why the issues can't be (and aren't being) addressed there.
> 7. And it's not for nothing that the Justices don't like "original" cases, partly because they don't come with a well-developed record and set of opinions from lower courts.
> Indeed, the "original" docket has shrunk to an average of <1 argued case per Term in recent years.
> 8. The other reason they don't like these cases is because they're worried about opening the floodgates. If Texas can sue these states over how they conduct their elections, what's to stop Vermont from suing Texas over how it regulates the oil industry, or other permutations.
* https://twitter.com/steve_vladeck/status/1336329907400425488 https://twitter.com/steve_vladeck/status/1336329907400425488
Another case against PA was dismissed today:
* https://www.politico.com/news/2020/12/08/supreme-court-rejects-bid-to-overturn-bidens-win-in-pennsylvania-443751 https://www.politico.com/news/2020/12/08/supreme-court-rejec...